Note: Study of the actual content of the Koran is very rarely undertaken by supporters of the 'Islam is OK' school of deludees. When the Koran is studied you will encounter this sort of 'Islamic Truth'.
How many Australian education journalists or politicians will write (or read) about this issue, based on the 39 page report issued in America? None.
Read this posting if you dare...
Christians still 'swine' and Jews 'apes' in Saudi schools.
Another story on Saudi dissembling about their textbooks. And of course, why wouldn't this material be in them? It's in the Qur'an (2:62-65; 5:59-60; 7:166).
From the Telegraph, with thanks to Anon:
Saudi Arabia has been accused of continuing to foster religious hatred in its schools, despite its repeated assurances since the September 11 attacks that it would rewrite textbooks that refer to Jews as "apes" and Christians as "swine".
The charges come after Freedom House, a non-partisan American research group which monitors civil rights worldwide, examined textbooks that it smuggled out of Saudi Arabia. The group found that despite promises of change from leading Saudi officials, including Saud al-Faisal, the foreign minister, and Turki al-Faisal, the ambassador to America, schoolbooks in the kingdom still promote hatred of those who do not practise its strict form of Wahhabi Islam.
The report also alleged that some of the textbooks are used in official Saudi schools around the world. Senior staff at the King Fahd Academy in Acton, west London, which has 750 pupils, said that it was not for the school to comment.
"Even if only a small percentage of the people who are exposed to this take it to heart and act on it, that's still a lot of people," said Nina Shea, Freedom House's director, after the release of the 39-page report, Saudi Arabia's Curriculum of Intolerance.
The report cites extracts from textbooks used in religious education classes for children aged between five and 16. It quotes the following exercise for the youngest children: "Fill in the blanks with the appropriate words (Islam, hellfire): Every religion other than ------- is false. Whoever dies outside of Islam enters -------."
It claims that older students are taught: "It is part of God's wisdom that the struggle between the Muslim and the Jews should continue until the hour (of judgment)."
The report is an embarrassment for the Saudi government, which has made great efforts to restore its image since being painted as a bastion of extremism after September 11. When it emerged that 15 of the 19 hijackers that day were Saudi, many blamed the kingdom's education system for breeding hatred.
Last month, however, only days before the report was released, the Saudi education minister gave a joint press conference with the American secretary of state, Condoleezza Rice, in which he boasted of Saudi school reform.
"The education reforms in Saudi Arabia go beyond textbook rewriting," he said. "They go into teacher training [and] the messages that are given to children in the formative years… The whole system of education is being transformed from top to bottom."
When asked about offensive language in textbooks, he said: "This is taken out." But, according to Miss Shea, this is not true. "Teaching methods that ask kindergarten children to give examples of 'false religions', like Judaism and Christianity, add up to an ideology that runs throughout," she said. "It is not hate speech here and there. It adds up to an argument, an ideology of us versus them."
Comment: The Australian government still persists in giving visas to Saudi and Egyptian Wahhabi fascist 'lecturers' to come to Australia and spread this poison (which is authentic Islam)among emotionally vulnerable muslim boys in this country. Why? Will it take a bomb outrage in Australia before 'the penny drops' for these dopes in Canberra figure out the connection between advocacy and action?
How many Australian journalists or politicians will ask this question of Senator Vanstone? None.
Monday, June 26, 2006
Sunday, June 25, 2006
Both Sides Are Correct In Their Assessments.
Note: These are interesting facts and statistics from the Pew Organisation in America. These reults can be believed. This is nutritious food for thought.
Last update - 02:08 25/06/2006
Poll: Relations between Muslims and West are poor
By The Associated Press
Muslims view people from the West, especially the United States and Europe, as selfish, immoral and greedy. People from the U.S. and Europe view Muslims as arrogant, violent and intolerant.
The deep divide between Muslims and the West was clearly illustrated in the findings of a new 15-country poll by the Pew Research Center for the People & the Press.
A solid majority in most of the 15 countries polled, both in Europe and in the Mideast, said relations between Muslims and Westerners are generally bad. And each side blames the other.
Advertisement
One of the more surprising findings in the poll was that solid majorities in Indonesia (65 percent), Turkey (59 percent), Egypt (59 percent) and Jordan (53 percent) said they do not believe the 9/11 attacks on the United States were carried out by groups of Arabs.
But Muslim support for terrorism is dropping in some countries. In Indonesia, Pakistan and especially in Jordan, there have been declines in the number of people who say suicide bombings can be justified.
Among the other findings:
* Anti-Jewish sentiment remains overwhelmingly high in Muslim countries.
* Majorities in the Muslim countries polled say the victory of Hamas in Palestinian elections will be helpful to a fair settlement between Israel and the Palestinians. That position is solidly rejected in the non-Muslim
countries.
* Overwhelming majorities in Muslim countries blame the controversy over cartoons depicting Mohammad on Western disrespect for the Muslim religion.
Majorities in Western countries tend to blame Muslim intolerance.
The polling in 15 countries of samples ranging from about 900 to 2,000 adults was conducted in April and May and has a margin of error ranging from 2 to 6 percentage points. The polling included Muslim oversamples in the European countries. In China, India and Pakistan, the polling was based on urban samples.
The nations in which polling was conducted were China, Egypt, France, Germany, Great Britain, India, Indonesia, Japan, Jordan, Nigeria, Pakistan, Russia, Spain, Turkey and the United States.
Comment: It would be good for the government to pay the Pew Organisation to do a specific poll in Australia among local muslims and non muslims. I suspect it would show that the strong majority of local muslims want to intergrate fully into Australia. The local poisonous imams would ensure that the government therefore did not arrange for such a poll.
Last update - 02:08 25/06/2006
Poll: Relations between Muslims and West are poor
By The Associated Press
Muslims view people from the West, especially the United States and Europe, as selfish, immoral and greedy. People from the U.S. and Europe view Muslims as arrogant, violent and intolerant.
The deep divide between Muslims and the West was clearly illustrated in the findings of a new 15-country poll by the Pew Research Center for the People & the Press.
A solid majority in most of the 15 countries polled, both in Europe and in the Mideast, said relations between Muslims and Westerners are generally bad. And each side blames the other.
Advertisement
One of the more surprising findings in the poll was that solid majorities in Indonesia (65 percent), Turkey (59 percent), Egypt (59 percent) and Jordan (53 percent) said they do not believe the 9/11 attacks on the United States were carried out by groups of Arabs.
But Muslim support for terrorism is dropping in some countries. In Indonesia, Pakistan and especially in Jordan, there have been declines in the number of people who say suicide bombings can be justified.
Among the other findings:
* Anti-Jewish sentiment remains overwhelmingly high in Muslim countries.
* Majorities in the Muslim countries polled say the victory of Hamas in Palestinian elections will be helpful to a fair settlement between Israel and the Palestinians. That position is solidly rejected in the non-Muslim
countries.
* Overwhelming majorities in Muslim countries blame the controversy over cartoons depicting Mohammad on Western disrespect for the Muslim religion.
Majorities in Western countries tend to blame Muslim intolerance.
The polling in 15 countries of samples ranging from about 900 to 2,000 adults was conducted in April and May and has a margin of error ranging from 2 to 6 percentage points. The polling included Muslim oversamples in the European countries. In China, India and Pakistan, the polling was based on urban samples.
The nations in which polling was conducted were China, Egypt, France, Germany, Great Britain, India, Indonesia, Japan, Jordan, Nigeria, Pakistan, Russia, Spain, Turkey and the United States.
Comment: It would be good for the government to pay the Pew Organisation to do a specific poll in Australia among local muslims and non muslims. I suspect it would show that the strong majority of local muslims want to intergrate fully into Australia. The local poisonous imams would ensure that the government therefore did not arrange for such a poll.
Real Islam In Action, Continued...
Note: This expresses the real view of Islam toward religious freedom. When readers hear words to the contrary, remember this deed. Deeds speak louder than words, and far more accurately.
June 24, 2006
Pakistan: Woman Raped for Leaving Islam
Another story about the desperate trouble in which apostates from Islam all too often find themselves.
June 23 (Compass Direct) – Attacked by her own family, one Muslim’s decision to convert to Christianity highlights the precarious situation of Muslims in Pakistan who leave their faith.
Sehar Muhammad Shafi, 24, has fled her home city of Karachi with her husband and two young daughters after being attacked and raped for changing her faith.
With help from the Center for Legal Aid Assistance and Settlement, the Christian couple has relocated to another city. But as long as Shafi and her family remain in Pakistan, they must hide the truth of Shafi’s conversion.
Shafi was born the fourth child of a Muslim proselytizer in Pakistan’s largest city, Karachi. Her family belonged to Ahle Sunnat wa-al Jimmat, a non-violent Muslim group that focused on converting non-Muslims. Members were instructed not to share food and eating utensils with “pagans” considered unclean.
Shafi’s father taught fellow members of his religious community how to proselytize. As a teenager, Shafi often attended her father’s training sessions on how to convert non-Muslims.
“It wasn’t normal for a girl to participate in those sessions,” the young woman told Compass. “But I was the daughter of an ‘evangelist’ and was eager to bring others to my faith.”
In 1999, Shafi began work for a medical company, Glaxo Wellcome plc, where she focused her energy on proselytizing a co-worker, a Christian named Naveed Paul. Paul had an interest in apologetics and engaged Shafi in religious discussions, inviting her to church with him.
Four years later, Shafi decided to become a Christian, and a local pastor secretly baptized her. “I had shared Islam with [Paul] and wanted to convert him, but instead I realized that my life was empty without Jesus,” Shafi said.
Secret Marriage
Shafi’s family was not aware of her conversion, but sometimes they would beat her when they found her singing Psalms to herself. Once they ripped up a Bible they discovered her reading.
Comment: Clearly the best reponse to Islam is a program of preaching Christianity and protecting converts from Islam.
The Australian government should give financial support to Christian groups in South East Asia for this purpose. It is in our national interest to weaken the Islamic Empire on our doorstep...it does NOT wish us well.
I won't ask whether anyone is awake in Canberra on a day when John Howard is away in Indonesia grovelling to their government.
June 24, 2006
Pakistan: Woman Raped for Leaving Islam
Another story about the desperate trouble in which apostates from Islam all too often find themselves.
June 23 (Compass Direct) – Attacked by her own family, one Muslim’s decision to convert to Christianity highlights the precarious situation of Muslims in Pakistan who leave their faith.
Sehar Muhammad Shafi, 24, has fled her home city of Karachi with her husband and two young daughters after being attacked and raped for changing her faith.
With help from the Center for Legal Aid Assistance and Settlement, the Christian couple has relocated to another city. But as long as Shafi and her family remain in Pakistan, they must hide the truth of Shafi’s conversion.
Shafi was born the fourth child of a Muslim proselytizer in Pakistan’s largest city, Karachi. Her family belonged to Ahle Sunnat wa-al Jimmat, a non-violent Muslim group that focused on converting non-Muslims. Members were instructed not to share food and eating utensils with “pagans” considered unclean.
Shafi’s father taught fellow members of his religious community how to proselytize. As a teenager, Shafi often attended her father’s training sessions on how to convert non-Muslims.
“It wasn’t normal for a girl to participate in those sessions,” the young woman told Compass. “But I was the daughter of an ‘evangelist’ and was eager to bring others to my faith.”
In 1999, Shafi began work for a medical company, Glaxo Wellcome plc, where she focused her energy on proselytizing a co-worker, a Christian named Naveed Paul. Paul had an interest in apologetics and engaged Shafi in religious discussions, inviting her to church with him.
Four years later, Shafi decided to become a Christian, and a local pastor secretly baptized her. “I had shared Islam with [Paul] and wanted to convert him, but instead I realized that my life was empty without Jesus,” Shafi said.
Secret Marriage
Shafi’s family was not aware of her conversion, but sometimes they would beat her when they found her singing Psalms to herself. Once they ripped up a Bible they discovered her reading.
Comment: Clearly the best reponse to Islam is a program of preaching Christianity and protecting converts from Islam.
The Australian government should give financial support to Christian groups in South East Asia for this purpose. It is in our national interest to weaken the Islamic Empire on our doorstep...it does NOT wish us well.
I won't ask whether anyone is awake in Canberra on a day when John Howard is away in Indonesia grovelling to their government.
Saturday, June 24, 2006
Terrorist Imams In Their Terrorist Mosques.
Note: An article from America on the problem with mosques. The problem is the imams in the mosques. The mosques are used to promote the problems that the imams foment.
Read all about it...
Some day we will be forced to deal fully with the war we are in, and when that happens we’re going to discover a lot of very nasty problems about the future of America. One of them has to do with, of all things, the First Amendment. Consider this story from Wednesday’s London Times:
AN AMERICAN al-Qaeda operative who was a close associate of the leader of the July 7 bombers was recruited at a New York mosque that British militants helped to run.
British radicals regularly travelled to the Masjid Fatima Islamic Centre, in Queens, to organise sending American volunteers to jihadi training camps in Pakistan.
Investigators reportedly found that Mohammad Sidique Khan had made calls to the mosque last year in the months before he led the terrorist attack on London that killed 52 innocent people....
Mohammad Junaid Babar, one recruit from the Masjid Fatima Islamic Centre, has told US intelligence officials that he met Khan in a jihadi training camp in Pakistan in July 2003. He claims that the pair became friends as they studied how to assemble explosive devices.
Babar, 31, a computer programmer, says that it was at the Masjid Fatima centre that he became a radical.
It’s interesting that British jihadis came to Queens to recruit Americans — and no doubt some of them, fully trained in slaughter, have returned to these shores — but the important thing is the mosque. Because there’s always a mosque, as my Italian friend Magdi Allam has been repeating for several years. Not all mosques are jihadi, but all jihadis come from a mosque.
Look at the 9/11 terrorists, look at the killer of Daniel Pearl, and you will find well-off, educated men who became radicalized in a mosque. And I’ll bet you a good-sized farm that if we ever get to the bottom of 9/11 we’ll discover that mosques were central in maintaining contact with and discipline over the terrorists.
So mosques can be very dangerous places when the local imam preaches jihadism, as is done in the thousands of Saudi-sponsored Wahhabi mosques all over the world, including the United States. It is clearly a matter of some urgency to put an end to the sort of indoctrination and recruitment that took place at the Masjid Fatima Islamic Center in New York. But that is easier said than done, because the absolutist interpretation of the First Amendment protects the imams and the incendiary sermons preached at such mosques. Freedom of religion forbids the state from meddling in the religious activities of the mosques, and freedom of speech forbids the state from telling the imams “you can’t say that.”
Freedom House should get a medal for publishing what I believe to be the only serious analysis of the contents of the literature distributed by some of these frightening places, and Nina Shea, who has driven this research for years, should have one personally engraved. As a result of this excellent work, along with that done by, inter alia, Steven Emerson, Daniel Pipes, Diana West, and Robert Spencer, we have a pretty complete picture of the dimensions of this threat. And as the London Times story illustrates quite convincingly, this is not just a theoretical matter. The evil words translate into evil action.
The all-out defenders of free speech and free religion will say that we are only entitled to go after the evil actions, because it is a greater evil to suppress the words and the thoughts that accompany them. Repressing these people and these words and thoughts today will make it possible for somebody to repress us and our thoughts and words tomorrow. I’ve got a lot of sympathy for that view, which I held throughout the Cold War with regard to Communism. And yet it seems suicidal to say “hands off all the mosques,” knowing that the radical mosques will manufacture slaughterers. Jefferson has some deep thoughts on both sides of this question.
As I say, it’s a very nasty problem. There are several things we can do right away, however, until some brilliant jurist finds a way through the fog. We can tell the Saudis to stop funding these fanatics. We can relentlessly expose the poison they are spreading (something useful for investigative journalists). We can challenge the doctrines in public fora. We can monitor the mosques, the better to spot the recruits.
But all this requires recognition that we are actually at war. At present, the most likely response from our leaders is to ask the Brits, Germans, and French to negotiate for us with the imams.
Comment: This site has consistently called for the deportation of all the imams in Australia. Don't worry about the good ones, there are no good ones.
Force the local muslims to fall back on their own spiritual resources. This will bring the reformers to the fore. Deport the imams and the political problems and security problems associated with mosques will evaporate over night.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Read all about it...
Some day we will be forced to deal fully with the war we are in, and when that happens we’re going to discover a lot of very nasty problems about the future of America. One of them has to do with, of all things, the First Amendment. Consider this story from Wednesday’s London Times:
AN AMERICAN al-Qaeda operative who was a close associate of the leader of the July 7 bombers was recruited at a New York mosque that British militants helped to run.
British radicals regularly travelled to the Masjid Fatima Islamic Centre, in Queens, to organise sending American volunteers to jihadi training camps in Pakistan.
Investigators reportedly found that Mohammad Sidique Khan had made calls to the mosque last year in the months before he led the terrorist attack on London that killed 52 innocent people....
Mohammad Junaid Babar, one recruit from the Masjid Fatima Islamic Centre, has told US intelligence officials that he met Khan in a jihadi training camp in Pakistan in July 2003. He claims that the pair became friends as they studied how to assemble explosive devices.
Babar, 31, a computer programmer, says that it was at the Masjid Fatima centre that he became a radical.
It’s interesting that British jihadis came to Queens to recruit Americans — and no doubt some of them, fully trained in slaughter, have returned to these shores — but the important thing is the mosque. Because there’s always a mosque, as my Italian friend Magdi Allam has been repeating for several years. Not all mosques are jihadi, but all jihadis come from a mosque.
Look at the 9/11 terrorists, look at the killer of Daniel Pearl, and you will find well-off, educated men who became radicalized in a mosque. And I’ll bet you a good-sized farm that if we ever get to the bottom of 9/11 we’ll discover that mosques were central in maintaining contact with and discipline over the terrorists.
So mosques can be very dangerous places when the local imam preaches jihadism, as is done in the thousands of Saudi-sponsored Wahhabi mosques all over the world, including the United States. It is clearly a matter of some urgency to put an end to the sort of indoctrination and recruitment that took place at the Masjid Fatima Islamic Center in New York. But that is easier said than done, because the absolutist interpretation of the First Amendment protects the imams and the incendiary sermons preached at such mosques. Freedom of religion forbids the state from meddling in the religious activities of the mosques, and freedom of speech forbids the state from telling the imams “you can’t say that.”
Freedom House should get a medal for publishing what I believe to be the only serious analysis of the contents of the literature distributed by some of these frightening places, and Nina Shea, who has driven this research for years, should have one personally engraved. As a result of this excellent work, along with that done by, inter alia, Steven Emerson, Daniel Pipes, Diana West, and Robert Spencer, we have a pretty complete picture of the dimensions of this threat. And as the London Times story illustrates quite convincingly, this is not just a theoretical matter. The evil words translate into evil action.
The all-out defenders of free speech and free religion will say that we are only entitled to go after the evil actions, because it is a greater evil to suppress the words and the thoughts that accompany them. Repressing these people and these words and thoughts today will make it possible for somebody to repress us and our thoughts and words tomorrow. I’ve got a lot of sympathy for that view, which I held throughout the Cold War with regard to Communism. And yet it seems suicidal to say “hands off all the mosques,” knowing that the radical mosques will manufacture slaughterers. Jefferson has some deep thoughts on both sides of this question.
As I say, it’s a very nasty problem. There are several things we can do right away, however, until some brilliant jurist finds a way through the fog. We can tell the Saudis to stop funding these fanatics. We can relentlessly expose the poison they are spreading (something useful for investigative journalists). We can challenge the doctrines in public fora. We can monitor the mosques, the better to spot the recruits.
But all this requires recognition that we are actually at war. At present, the most likely response from our leaders is to ask the Brits, Germans, and French to negotiate for us with the imams.
Comment: This site has consistently called for the deportation of all the imams in Australia. Don't worry about the good ones, there are no good ones.
Force the local muslims to fall back on their own spiritual resources. This will bring the reformers to the fore. Deport the imams and the political problems and security problems associated with mosques will evaporate over night.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Real Islam In Action.
Note: All the dopey Australians who think Islam is 'OK' should look at this story, happening in 'modern' Malaysia and compare it with the words they have heard from Australian supporters of Islam. Compare words with deeds.
23 June, 2006
MALAYSIA
Prayer campaign for Lina Joy, the law does not allow her to convert to Christianity
National Registration Department and Court of Appeal refused to accept her conversion. Federal Court is set to rule next week on her case.
Kuaka Lumpur (AsiaNews) – Malaysia’s Churches are committed one and all to a prayer campaign on behalf of Lina Joy, a Malay woman who converted to Christianity from Islam. Next Monday Malaysia’s federal Court will rule whether the law recognises her conversion or not.
After becoming Christian in 1998, Lina Joy (formerly Azlina Jailani) applied first to the National Registration Department (NRD) and then the Court of Appeal to change her identity papers to remove ‘Islam’ as her religion. She was refused in both cases because as an ethnic Malay she was legally Muslim and “could not change religion”.
Religious issues involving Malays, including conversions to other religions, fall under the jurisdiction of Islamic courts and not the country’s general laws.
Lina Joy’s problem is that if she is not recognised as Christian she can only marry a Muslim man in a Muslim ceremony and will be subject to Islamic family and inheritance laws.
Her case has opened up the debate as to the extent to which religious freedom is guaranteed in Malaysia, a country that is also home to Chinese and Indian groups who generally belong to other religions.
De facto, two legal systems coexist in the country: one based on Islam; the other, on the constitution. And the two are often in conflict. Lina Joy’s case illustrates this clearly. The constitution guarantees freedom of religion; Islamic law prohibits conversion to any other religion.
Given the seriousness of the situation, Mgr Paul Tan Chee Ing, Catholic bishop of Melata-Johor and chairman of the Christian Federation of Malaysia, is appealing to Christians to support Lina Joy through prayers.
In a prepared prayer, the prelate asks the faithful to call on God to support Lina Joy, whatever the judges’ verdict may be, and grant the judges the wisdom they need to pass judgement in the case and Malaysian Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi the strength to “uphold the Constitution”.
Comment: Australia should offer a refuge to those who leave Islam and are subjected to persecution (now only administrative, but soon enough it will get violent).
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
23 June, 2006
MALAYSIA
Prayer campaign for Lina Joy, the law does not allow her to convert to Christianity
National Registration Department and Court of Appeal refused to accept her conversion. Federal Court is set to rule next week on her case.
Kuaka Lumpur (AsiaNews) – Malaysia’s Churches are committed one and all to a prayer campaign on behalf of Lina Joy, a Malay woman who converted to Christianity from Islam. Next Monday Malaysia’s federal Court will rule whether the law recognises her conversion or not.
After becoming Christian in 1998, Lina Joy (formerly Azlina Jailani) applied first to the National Registration Department (NRD) and then the Court of Appeal to change her identity papers to remove ‘Islam’ as her religion. She was refused in both cases because as an ethnic Malay she was legally Muslim and “could not change religion”.
Religious issues involving Malays, including conversions to other religions, fall under the jurisdiction of Islamic courts and not the country’s general laws.
Lina Joy’s problem is that if she is not recognised as Christian she can only marry a Muslim man in a Muslim ceremony and will be subject to Islamic family and inheritance laws.
Her case has opened up the debate as to the extent to which religious freedom is guaranteed in Malaysia, a country that is also home to Chinese and Indian groups who generally belong to other religions.
De facto, two legal systems coexist in the country: one based on Islam; the other, on the constitution. And the two are often in conflict. Lina Joy’s case illustrates this clearly. The constitution guarantees freedom of religion; Islamic law prohibits conversion to any other religion.
Given the seriousness of the situation, Mgr Paul Tan Chee Ing, Catholic bishop of Melata-Johor and chairman of the Christian Federation of Malaysia, is appealing to Christians to support Lina Joy through prayers.
In a prepared prayer, the prelate asks the faithful to call on God to support Lina Joy, whatever the judges’ verdict may be, and grant the judges the wisdom they need to pass judgement in the case and Malaysian Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi the strength to “uphold the Constitution”.
Comment: Australia should offer a refuge to those who leave Islam and are subjected to persecution (now only administrative, but soon enough it will get violent).
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Friday, June 23, 2006
Good Advice On Handling The Muslim Problem.
Note: This result from a Conference organised by the Vatican establishes the policy framework for the Catholic church in dealing with the muslim problem.
Special interest should be shown to sections 10/11/13/35/36/and 37. The advice in these sections is very applicable to Australia's situation.
Conclusions on Migration to and From Islamic Countries
From Plenary Session of Pontifical Council
VATICAN CITY, JUNE 22, 2006 (Zenit.org).- Here are the conclusions and recommendations issued by the Pontifical Council for Migrants and Travelers, after its plenary assembly May 15-17, on the theme "Migration and Itinerancy from and towards Islamic Majority Countries."
The Vatican press office issued the document today.
* * *
Conclusions and Recommendations
Muslim Migrants in countries of Christian majority
1) In this regard, an increase in immigration of Muslims was observed in European and North American countries, of ancient Christian tradition (see instruction "Erga Migrantes Caritas Christi" -- henceforth EMCC -- Nos. 59 and 65). They come in search of a job or democracy, or for family reunification.
2) From this came the encouragement of integration (not assimilation) of Muslim immigrants (cf. EMCC 2, 60-61).
3) In consequence Catholics, in particular, are called to practice solidarity with Muslim immigrants, to be open to sharing with them and to know more about their culture and religion. At the same time they are to bear witness to their own Christian values, also in view of a new evangelization which of course respects freedom of conscience and religion (cf. EMCC, 59 and 69).
4) This means that Christians must get to know more deeply their identity (cf. EMCC, 60) as disciples of Christ, bearing witness to this in their lives and rediscovering their role in the new evangelization (cf. EMCC, 86-88).
5) It is therefore important to affirm the necessity of mutual respect and human solidarity, in an atmosphere of peace, based on the centrality of the human person, his/her dignity, rights and duties.
6) Naturally, each one's human rights and freedoms go hand in hand with those of others.
Dialogue
7) The participants in the Plenary Session strongly showed awareness of the need for authentic dialogue between believers of different religions, especially between Christians and Muslims (cf. EMCC, 69).
8) In this context, relations based on "spiritual emulation" were considered important.
9) Thus, if dialogue between Christians and Muslims is indispensable everywhere, it is especially so in Western societies, in order to improve mutual knowledge and understanding, as well as reciprocal respect and peace.
10) In any case, while it is necessary to welcome Muslim immigrants with respect for their religious freedom, it is likewise indispensable for them to respect the cultural and religious identity of the host societies.
11) It was also deemed vital to distinguish between what the receiving societies can and cannot tolerate in Islamic culture, what can be respected or shared with regard to followers of other religions (see EMCC, 65 and 66), and to have the possibility of giving indications in this regard also to policymakers, toward a proper formulation of civil legislation, with due respect for each one's competence.
12) This means also proposing a model of religious dialogue which is not only conversation, nor just listening to one another, but which reaches a mutual revelation of each one's own profound spiritual convictions.
13) It is therefore important to accompany the dialogue partner in the process of thinking out the ethical and actual dimensions, and not only the theological and religious ones, of the consequences of requests addressed to civil society, while duly respecting the distinction between civil and religious dialogue.
14) Given the reaffirmed importance of the principle of reciprocity (see EMCC, 64), confirmed by the Holy Father in his talk to the participants in the plenary session, it is thus necessary to move toward a distinction between the civil and the religious spheres also in Islamic countries.
15) In any case, it is fundamental, in this context, to distinguish between the West and Christianity, because often Christian values no longer inspire the attitude, position or actions (also with regard to public opinion) in the so-called Western world (see EMCC, 60).
16) The participants of the plenary session also expressed the hope that in those areas where Christian and Muslims "live together," they may unite their efforts, together with all their other fellow citizens, to guarantee everyone, without distinction of religion, the full exercise of his/her rights and individual freedoms, personally and as a member of a community.
Situation in some Islamic majority countries
17) On the other hand, in Islamic majority countries, Christians and immigrant workers, in general, who are poor and without real contractual power, have great difficulty in having their human rights recognized. The latter, moreover, have very little possibility of having their cause respected before justice, because they can easily be punished or deported.
18) The Church is therefore called to help Christian migrants in those countries, as well as in the whole world, in a context of due respect for legality and an interest in the formulation of just legislations concerning human mobility and the legal protection of all those involved. However, there were participants who called to mind that, in the different countries, the situation should be such that it would not be necessary for their citizens to go abroad in order to survive.
19) Moreover, in conformity with the directives of the conciliar decree "Christus Dominus" (No. 18), the Church has to ensure that the faithful who are not adequately catered for by the ordinary, i.e. territorial, pastoral ministry on account of their mobility, or are entirely deprived of it, are provided with a specific and even integrated pastoral care. This is true also in Islamic-majority countries.
20) In these countries, it is the task of the local Church to welcome immigrants and itinerants, in spite of a scanty personnel and perhaps inadequate structures.
21) In this respect, dialogue and collaboration are necessary between the Church of origin of migrants and itinerants and that in their destination countries, for their spiritual care. This is in fact a general rule for all countries (cf. EMCC, 70 and 50-55).
22) In addition, international migrants must also be helped to make their own contribution to the community where they live, and to the local portion of the People of God.
23) At the same time, the receiving community should develop a sense of solidarity toward immigrants and others who are in similar circumstances.
Solicitude of the Church in the various sectors of human mobility
The participants in the plenary session also considered the various sectors of migration and itinerancy. Everyone was convinced that with regard to migrants:
24) The Church must take care that they are properly integrated, with due respect for each one's culture and religion (cf. Pope John Paul, Message for the World Day of Peace 2001, No. 8, and Message for the World Day of Migrants and Refugees 2005, No. 3).
25) Therefore the Church must encourage dialogue that is intercultural and social, as well as interreligious, with respect for due distinctions (cf. Pope John Paul II, Message for the World Day of Peace 2001, No. 12).
For the various sectors, the following were observed particularly:
26) The need to create bonds of friendship, in an atmosphere of respect for cultural and religious differences, also with people who think of going back to their place of origin, like migrants, or with foreign (international) students who will be the future leaders of their countries.
27) For refugees and foreign students, but not only for these, it was felt desirable to set up chaplaincies.
28) With regard to pilgrimages, the need was underlined to urge pilgrims to seek God's countenance also in the believers of other religions.
29) In airports, crossroads of varied people, and in railway stations, hope was expressed for the presence of specifically Catholic chapels there, or places of prayer, even multi-religious ones, when only those are possible.
30) In Stella Maris Centers (Apostleship of the Sea), it is worthwhile to continue welcoming also Muslim seafarers, with respectful spiritual assistance, when requested.
31) With respect to the gypsy population, object of marginalization, xenophobia and racism, it was deemed necessary to fortify the maturity of democratic societies and their capacity to understand and respect the social, cultural and religious diversity of this people (cf. Guidelines for a Pastoral Care of Gypsies, No. 50).
32) As far as the "women of the street" are concerned -- given that poverty and the trafficking of human beings often lead to selling one's body, and that prostitution may depend on Christians and Muslims -- it is considered necessary to build awareness with the whole society as target.
33) However, a renewed commitment is called for to involve women in decision making, especially in issues affecting them, as well as in the work of convincing parents [to] provide girls with education equivalent to that given to boys, which should obviously include ethical formation.
Schools and education
The participants in the plenary session laid great emphasis on the fact that:
34) It is important to ensure education to the new generations, also because the school has a fundamental role to play in overcoming the conflict of ignorance and prejudices, and to have a correct and objective knowledge of the other's religion, with special attention to the freedom of conscience and religion (cf. EMCC, 62). Moreover, for Christians, provisions will be made to give them the basis for an evangelical discernment of the religious experience of believers in other religions (cf. EMCC, 65) and of the signs of the times.
35) It is therefore indispensable to work for a verification of textbooks also regarding the presentation of history in relation to the religions, which shapes one's identity, and transmits an image of the other's religious identity.
36) In any event it is necessary to delve more deeply into studies, teachings and research regarding the various faces of historical and/or contemporary Islam, including the varying degrees of its acceptance of sound modernity (cf. EMCC, 66).
37) Muslim parents and religious leaders must be helped to understand the righteous intentions of the Western educational systems and the concrete consequences of their refusal of the education imparted in the schools of these systems within which their children live.
States and religious freedom
38) Since, very often, it is the state that gives "form" to Islam in certain countries of Islamic majority, organizes its worship, interprets its spirit, transmits its heritage, thus giving the whole of society a globally Islamic character, the non-Muslims very often feel that they are second-class citizens. For Christian immigrants therefore the difficulty is even greater.
39) It is therefore necessary to work hard everywhere so that what prevails would be a culture of "living together" between host and immigrant populations, in a spirit of mutual civic understanding and respect for everyone's human rights. It is also necessary to search ways for reconciliation and of purifying memories (cf. EMCC, 65). We must also become advocates in defense of religious freedom -- our constant imperative -- and of common good, and procure respect for minorities, which is an unquestionable sign of true civilization.
40) It was observed with satisfaction that many states of Islamic majority have established diplomatic relations with the Holy See, thus becoming more sensitive in guaranteeing human rights, affirming the will to establish intercultural and interreligious dialogue, in the framework of sound plurality.
41) In this context, it is necessary to deplore, in some countries, the restrictions of human rights, especially when linked to religious differences, and the absence of the freedom also to change one's religion. It is hoped, however, that the public authorities of the countries of origin of Christian emigrants will help their citizens, in Islamic countries, achieve the effective exercise of religious freedom.
42) Those countries are thus encouraged to create spaces for exchange with countries of Islamic majority, on themes regarding universal common good, respect for minorities, human rights and especially religious freedom, foundation of all freedoms.
43) In any case, the Church must continue its initiatives of intercultural and interreligious dialogue, at different levels, especially when these are facilitated by political leaders.
44) Collaboration between Christian and Muslim institutions to bring aid to individuals and populations in need, without any discrimination, is an effective sign that destroys prejudices and closure toward mutual and reasonable openness.
45) The growing extent to which Muslims and Christians "live together" can provide an opportunity for collaborating together in view of a more peaceful world, respectful of each one's identity and more united in the service of common good, seeing that we all constitute one human family, which is in need of hope (cf. EMCC, 101-103).
46) In this context, collaboration among the various dicasteries of the Roman Curia, the episcopal conferences and the particular Churches is of capital importance.
47) A factor of unity, in legitimate diversity, will be the awareness of the dignity of every human person, whatever may be his race, culture, citizenship or religion. This is a value that is being affirmed more and more universally, in spite of all the incoherence and its practical denial in daily life.
48). In this context the participants in the plenary session paid particular attention to the African continent, which is in special need of political stability and multilateral cooperation, toward its peaceful and integral development.
49) In this respect, too, some causes of tension and conflict were considered, with the hope that these situations would be resolved justly and quickly, also to prevent war, violence and terrorism. It is in any case necessary to avoid the abusive use of religion to inculcate hatred for believers of other religions or for ideological and political reasons.
50) It is therefore hoped that Muslim and Christian intellectuals, in the name of a common humanism and of their respective beliefs, would pose to themselves the dramatic questions linked to the use of violence, often still perpetrated in the name of their religion.
The role of mass media
51) It is recognized that the media are particularly important for the creation of an appropriate climate of understanding and respect as they give information on religious matters. Journalists and mass media operators, in general, should therefore assume their own responsibilities especially with regard to information, and not only concerning freedom of speech, in a world that is becoming more and more globalized.
52) Mass media can also give an important contribution to the "formation" (and, unfortunately, vice versa, the deformation) of Christians and Muslims.
We conclude this final document noting the great satisfaction of the participants regarding the content, work method and up-to-dateness of this plenary session, which roused great interest.
Vatican City, 19 June 2006
Comment: The overall tenor of these pieces of advice is directed at a policy of 'normalising' the daily life of muslims in the West, and Christians in the muslim lands.
This is contrary to the current foolish Australian policy of pandering to Islamic fascist demands for the recognition of 'muslim exceptionalism'. These demands come from the imams, who totally monopolise the 'ear' of all governments in Australia. The imams are the core of the muslim problem; they are not part of any solution to that problem.
By sidelining the imams and dealing only with locally born and educated secular muslim men and women the various governments in Australia will be able to quickly come to an arrangement whereby the muslim problem in Australia fades away and is replaced with the normalisation of the lives of those Australians who happen to be muslims, to a greater or lesser degree.
This site advocates the proper integration and conformity to mainstream Australian life by all the people who live here. Current government policies are still moving in the opposite and wrong direction: the direction of 'muslim exceptionalism'.
The demand for 'muslim exceptionalism' is not an example of multiculturalism; it is Islamic imperialism. One would think that the governments in Australia could see this; but they do not. The eventual failure of their current policies will ultimately force them to change. Sadly, the governments do not appear to be smart enough to change before a disaster occurs.
Is anyone smart working in Canberra?
Special interest should be shown to sections 10/11/13/35/36/and 37. The advice in these sections is very applicable to Australia's situation.
Conclusions on Migration to and From Islamic Countries
From Plenary Session of Pontifical Council
VATICAN CITY, JUNE 22, 2006 (Zenit.org).- Here are the conclusions and recommendations issued by the Pontifical Council for Migrants and Travelers, after its plenary assembly May 15-17, on the theme "Migration and Itinerancy from and towards Islamic Majority Countries."
The Vatican press office issued the document today.
* * *
Conclusions and Recommendations
Muslim Migrants in countries of Christian majority
1) In this regard, an increase in immigration of Muslims was observed in European and North American countries, of ancient Christian tradition (see instruction "Erga Migrantes Caritas Christi" -- henceforth EMCC -- Nos. 59 and 65). They come in search of a job or democracy, or for family reunification.
2) From this came the encouragement of integration (not assimilation) of Muslim immigrants (cf. EMCC 2, 60-61).
3) In consequence Catholics, in particular, are called to practice solidarity with Muslim immigrants, to be open to sharing with them and to know more about their culture and religion. At the same time they are to bear witness to their own Christian values, also in view of a new evangelization which of course respects freedom of conscience and religion (cf. EMCC, 59 and 69).
4) This means that Christians must get to know more deeply their identity (cf. EMCC, 60) as disciples of Christ, bearing witness to this in their lives and rediscovering their role in the new evangelization (cf. EMCC, 86-88).
5) It is therefore important to affirm the necessity of mutual respect and human solidarity, in an atmosphere of peace, based on the centrality of the human person, his/her dignity, rights and duties.
6) Naturally, each one's human rights and freedoms go hand in hand with those of others.
Dialogue
7) The participants in the Plenary Session strongly showed awareness of the need for authentic dialogue between believers of different religions, especially between Christians and Muslims (cf. EMCC, 69).
8) In this context, relations based on "spiritual emulation" were considered important.
9) Thus, if dialogue between Christians and Muslims is indispensable everywhere, it is especially so in Western societies, in order to improve mutual knowledge and understanding, as well as reciprocal respect and peace.
10) In any case, while it is necessary to welcome Muslim immigrants with respect for their religious freedom, it is likewise indispensable for them to respect the cultural and religious identity of the host societies.
11) It was also deemed vital to distinguish between what the receiving societies can and cannot tolerate in Islamic culture, what can be respected or shared with regard to followers of other religions (see EMCC, 65 and 66), and to have the possibility of giving indications in this regard also to policymakers, toward a proper formulation of civil legislation, with due respect for each one's competence.
12) This means also proposing a model of religious dialogue which is not only conversation, nor just listening to one another, but which reaches a mutual revelation of each one's own profound spiritual convictions.
13) It is therefore important to accompany the dialogue partner in the process of thinking out the ethical and actual dimensions, and not only the theological and religious ones, of the consequences of requests addressed to civil society, while duly respecting the distinction between civil and religious dialogue.
14) Given the reaffirmed importance of the principle of reciprocity (see EMCC, 64), confirmed by the Holy Father in his talk to the participants in the plenary session, it is thus necessary to move toward a distinction between the civil and the religious spheres also in Islamic countries.
15) In any case, it is fundamental, in this context, to distinguish between the West and Christianity, because often Christian values no longer inspire the attitude, position or actions (also with regard to public opinion) in the so-called Western world (see EMCC, 60).
16) The participants of the plenary session also expressed the hope that in those areas where Christian and Muslims "live together," they may unite their efforts, together with all their other fellow citizens, to guarantee everyone, without distinction of religion, the full exercise of his/her rights and individual freedoms, personally and as a member of a community.
Situation in some Islamic majority countries
17) On the other hand, in Islamic majority countries, Christians and immigrant workers, in general, who are poor and without real contractual power, have great difficulty in having their human rights recognized. The latter, moreover, have very little possibility of having their cause respected before justice, because they can easily be punished or deported.
18) The Church is therefore called to help Christian migrants in those countries, as well as in the whole world, in a context of due respect for legality and an interest in the formulation of just legislations concerning human mobility and the legal protection of all those involved. However, there were participants who called to mind that, in the different countries, the situation should be such that it would not be necessary for their citizens to go abroad in order to survive.
19) Moreover, in conformity with the directives of the conciliar decree "Christus Dominus" (No. 18), the Church has to ensure that the faithful who are not adequately catered for by the ordinary, i.e. territorial, pastoral ministry on account of their mobility, or are entirely deprived of it, are provided with a specific and even integrated pastoral care. This is true also in Islamic-majority countries.
20) In these countries, it is the task of the local Church to welcome immigrants and itinerants, in spite of a scanty personnel and perhaps inadequate structures.
21) In this respect, dialogue and collaboration are necessary between the Church of origin of migrants and itinerants and that in their destination countries, for their spiritual care. This is in fact a general rule for all countries (cf. EMCC, 70 and 50-55).
22) In addition, international migrants must also be helped to make their own contribution to the community where they live, and to the local portion of the People of God.
23) At the same time, the receiving community should develop a sense of solidarity toward immigrants and others who are in similar circumstances.
Solicitude of the Church in the various sectors of human mobility
The participants in the plenary session also considered the various sectors of migration and itinerancy. Everyone was convinced that with regard to migrants:
24) The Church must take care that they are properly integrated, with due respect for each one's culture and religion (cf. Pope John Paul, Message for the World Day of Peace 2001, No. 8, and Message for the World Day of Migrants and Refugees 2005, No. 3).
25) Therefore the Church must encourage dialogue that is intercultural and social, as well as interreligious, with respect for due distinctions (cf. Pope John Paul II, Message for the World Day of Peace 2001, No. 12).
For the various sectors, the following were observed particularly:
26) The need to create bonds of friendship, in an atmosphere of respect for cultural and religious differences, also with people who think of going back to their place of origin, like migrants, or with foreign (international) students who will be the future leaders of their countries.
27) For refugees and foreign students, but not only for these, it was felt desirable to set up chaplaincies.
28) With regard to pilgrimages, the need was underlined to urge pilgrims to seek God's countenance also in the believers of other religions.
29) In airports, crossroads of varied people, and in railway stations, hope was expressed for the presence of specifically Catholic chapels there, or places of prayer, even multi-religious ones, when only those are possible.
30) In Stella Maris Centers (Apostleship of the Sea), it is worthwhile to continue welcoming also Muslim seafarers, with respectful spiritual assistance, when requested.
31) With respect to the gypsy population, object of marginalization, xenophobia and racism, it was deemed necessary to fortify the maturity of democratic societies and their capacity to understand and respect the social, cultural and religious diversity of this people (cf. Guidelines for a Pastoral Care of Gypsies, No. 50).
32) As far as the "women of the street" are concerned -- given that poverty and the trafficking of human beings often lead to selling one's body, and that prostitution may depend on Christians and Muslims -- it is considered necessary to build awareness with the whole society as target.
33) However, a renewed commitment is called for to involve women in decision making, especially in issues affecting them, as well as in the work of convincing parents [to] provide girls with education equivalent to that given to boys, which should obviously include ethical formation.
Schools and education
The participants in the plenary session laid great emphasis on the fact that:
34) It is important to ensure education to the new generations, also because the school has a fundamental role to play in overcoming the conflict of ignorance and prejudices, and to have a correct and objective knowledge of the other's religion, with special attention to the freedom of conscience and religion (cf. EMCC, 62). Moreover, for Christians, provisions will be made to give them the basis for an evangelical discernment of the religious experience of believers in other religions (cf. EMCC, 65) and of the signs of the times.
35) It is therefore indispensable to work for a verification of textbooks also regarding the presentation of history in relation to the religions, which shapes one's identity, and transmits an image of the other's religious identity.
36) In any event it is necessary to delve more deeply into studies, teachings and research regarding the various faces of historical and/or contemporary Islam, including the varying degrees of its acceptance of sound modernity (cf. EMCC, 66).
37) Muslim parents and religious leaders must be helped to understand the righteous intentions of the Western educational systems and the concrete consequences of their refusal of the education imparted in the schools of these systems within which their children live.
States and religious freedom
38) Since, very often, it is the state that gives "form" to Islam in certain countries of Islamic majority, organizes its worship, interprets its spirit, transmits its heritage, thus giving the whole of society a globally Islamic character, the non-Muslims very often feel that they are second-class citizens. For Christian immigrants therefore the difficulty is even greater.
39) It is therefore necessary to work hard everywhere so that what prevails would be a culture of "living together" between host and immigrant populations, in a spirit of mutual civic understanding and respect for everyone's human rights. It is also necessary to search ways for reconciliation and of purifying memories (cf. EMCC, 65). We must also become advocates in defense of religious freedom -- our constant imperative -- and of common good, and procure respect for minorities, which is an unquestionable sign of true civilization.
40) It was observed with satisfaction that many states of Islamic majority have established diplomatic relations with the Holy See, thus becoming more sensitive in guaranteeing human rights, affirming the will to establish intercultural and interreligious dialogue, in the framework of sound plurality.
41) In this context, it is necessary to deplore, in some countries, the restrictions of human rights, especially when linked to religious differences, and the absence of the freedom also to change one's religion. It is hoped, however, that the public authorities of the countries of origin of Christian emigrants will help their citizens, in Islamic countries, achieve the effective exercise of religious freedom.
42) Those countries are thus encouraged to create spaces for exchange with countries of Islamic majority, on themes regarding universal common good, respect for minorities, human rights and especially religious freedom, foundation of all freedoms.
43) In any case, the Church must continue its initiatives of intercultural and interreligious dialogue, at different levels, especially when these are facilitated by political leaders.
44) Collaboration between Christian and Muslim institutions to bring aid to individuals and populations in need, without any discrimination, is an effective sign that destroys prejudices and closure toward mutual and reasonable openness.
45) The growing extent to which Muslims and Christians "live together" can provide an opportunity for collaborating together in view of a more peaceful world, respectful of each one's identity and more united in the service of common good, seeing that we all constitute one human family, which is in need of hope (cf. EMCC, 101-103).
46) In this context, collaboration among the various dicasteries of the Roman Curia, the episcopal conferences and the particular Churches is of capital importance.
47) A factor of unity, in legitimate diversity, will be the awareness of the dignity of every human person, whatever may be his race, culture, citizenship or religion. This is a value that is being affirmed more and more universally, in spite of all the incoherence and its practical denial in daily life.
48). In this context the participants in the plenary session paid particular attention to the African continent, which is in special need of political stability and multilateral cooperation, toward its peaceful and integral development.
49) In this respect, too, some causes of tension and conflict were considered, with the hope that these situations would be resolved justly and quickly, also to prevent war, violence and terrorism. It is in any case necessary to avoid the abusive use of religion to inculcate hatred for believers of other religions or for ideological and political reasons.
50) It is therefore hoped that Muslim and Christian intellectuals, in the name of a common humanism and of their respective beliefs, would pose to themselves the dramatic questions linked to the use of violence, often still perpetrated in the name of their religion.
The role of mass media
51) It is recognized that the media are particularly important for the creation of an appropriate climate of understanding and respect as they give information on religious matters. Journalists and mass media operators, in general, should therefore assume their own responsibilities especially with regard to information, and not only concerning freedom of speech, in a world that is becoming more and more globalized.
52) Mass media can also give an important contribution to the "formation" (and, unfortunately, vice versa, the deformation) of Christians and Muslims.
We conclude this final document noting the great satisfaction of the participants regarding the content, work method and up-to-dateness of this plenary session, which roused great interest.
Vatican City, 19 June 2006
Comment: The overall tenor of these pieces of advice is directed at a policy of 'normalising' the daily life of muslims in the West, and Christians in the muslim lands.
This is contrary to the current foolish Australian policy of pandering to Islamic fascist demands for the recognition of 'muslim exceptionalism'. These demands come from the imams, who totally monopolise the 'ear' of all governments in Australia. The imams are the core of the muslim problem; they are not part of any solution to that problem.
By sidelining the imams and dealing only with locally born and educated secular muslim men and women the various governments in Australia will be able to quickly come to an arrangement whereby the muslim problem in Australia fades away and is replaced with the normalisation of the lives of those Australians who happen to be muslims, to a greater or lesser degree.
This site advocates the proper integration and conformity to mainstream Australian life by all the people who live here. Current government policies are still moving in the opposite and wrong direction: the direction of 'muslim exceptionalism'.
The demand for 'muslim exceptionalism' is not an example of multiculturalism; it is Islamic imperialism. One would think that the governments in Australia could see this; but they do not. The eventual failure of their current policies will ultimately force them to change. Sadly, the governments do not appear to be smart enough to change before a disaster occurs.
Is anyone smart working in Canberra?
Thursday, June 22, 2006
An Arab Doctor Writes About The Effects Of Islam.
Note: An arab doctor points out the mental illness factor in contemporary Islam. Australian public officials and media please note.
Special Dispatch Series - No. 1190
June 21, 2006 No.1190
Iraqi Reformist on Arab Society and Social Schizophrenia
In an article titled "Arab Society and Schizophrenia," Iraqi reformist Dr. Abd Al-Khaleq Hussein, who writes on several reformist websites, argues that Arab society suffers from "social schizophrenia," - the symptoms of which are similar to those of individuals suffering from actual schizophrenia. He further argues that the Arab governments must immediately launch social and political reforms which will gradually lead to democracy in the Arab world. If significant reforms are not carried out, he says, disasters will continue to strike the Arab word, and democracy will ultimately be imposed upon it through violent upheavals, as occurred in Iraq. In the article, he also called upon the Arabs to accept the help offered to them by the West - and especially by the U. S. - with the aim of facilitating positive change that will permit them to integrate into the international community.
The following are excerpts from the article: [1]
"This Split Personality Disorder Characterizes Not Only Specific Sectors of Arab Society, But [Also] the Governments, the Institutions of Civil Society, and the [Political] Parties"
"'Schizophrenia' is a word in ancient Greek that means 'split personality'... but it is also used in the social sciences to describe societies afflicted by severe duality in their behavior and their [moral] standards. In fact, if we carefully compare the medical and social forms of this disorder, we will find that the symptoms are very similar...
"Iraqi social scientist Ali Al-Wardi was the first to characterize the Iraqi people as suffering from this severe social illness, which he labeled 'split personality.' According to his theory, Iraqis suffer... from a conflict between the Bedouin values that have been passed down through the generations and the cultural values that the Iraqi society has acquired...
"As an illustration, he presents the example of a young Iraqi who wishes to choose his own wife, just like an enlightened Western man, and to exchange love letters with her,... but when he hears that some other man has similar relations with his sister or cousin, he immediately turns into a 'Bedouin' and murders his beloved sister and her lover...
"This split personality disorder characterizes not only specific sectors of Arab society, but [also] the governments, the institutions of civil society, and the [political] parties, especially the Islamic ones...
"The social and medical forms of this disorder have similar symptoms. The most important of these is delusions from which the patient suffers... For example:"
"Delusions of Grandeur"
"A [schizophrenia] patient believes that he is exceptional and that others should treat him as though he is an important person. The Arabs also believe that they are more important than others in every respect. They [believe that they] are the best among nations..., and regard other nations with contempt. They acknowledge no religion [but their own] and are unwilling to coexist peacefully with other religions. [They believe] that their faith is the only faith that mankind should embrace, and that whoever fails to embrace it is an infidel.
"In other words, all other religions are heathen, heretical and fabricated, and their followers should abandon them and embrace the Arabs' religion - Islam. If they fail to embrace Islam, the Muslims are entitled to wage war upon them, to kill their men or convert them by force, to take their women hostage, to sell their children in the slave market and to plunder their property...
"This disparaging view applies not only to non-Muslims, but also to other schools of thought within Islam. Each Islamic school of thought is full of contempt and hostility towards the others. The Salafis and Wahhabis, for example, are convinced that the Shiites must be killed, and that whoever kills them will be rewarded in the world to come..."
"Paranoia"
"A schizophrenia patient believes that others are plotting against him with the aim of harming and killing him, even though he hasn't a shred of evidence to prove this. This is exactly what happens with the Arabs, who are addicted to conspiracy theories. Whenever a disaster befalls them, they claim that it was brought about by a 'hostile Western Crusader-Zionist' conspiracy. They [say this] without bothering to think rationally and determine the true causes for their defeat...
"A schizophrenic imagines that people have nothing better to do than to talk about him, gossip about him, and plot against him. Consequently, he lives in a constant state of intense doubt and suspicion towards others, including the people closest to him, such as his wife, whom he suspects of cheating on him... The patient believes that even broadcasts on TV or on the other media are directed personally at him.
"This is exactly what happens in the Arab society with respect to foreign ideas and books. No society places books and ideas under siege the way Arab society does. Arab airports and sea ports are known for seizing books from the passengers. The Arabs are famous for translating the fewest books and for showing the greatest hostility towards the foreign sciences, to which they refer contemptuously... as 'imported ideas.' In addition, no people burn books and persecute intellectuals with more gusto than the Arabs."
"Somatic Delusions"
"The patient imagines strange and illogical things, for instance that foreign bodies are moving inside him, even though there is no evidence to suggest this. Similarly, Arab societies and governments suffer from the illness of [constantly suspecting] espionage by foreign agents. This is why the Arab jails are full of political prisoners and oppositionists accused of spying for other [countries]. In the eyes of the Arab governments and societies, the political opposition and the liberal intellectuals are traitors and agents of foreign intelligence [apparatuses]..."
"Disorganized Speech"
"A [schizophrenic] patient's speech makes no sense. There is no connection between the sentences, and the hearer or reader cannot understand what [the patient] means to say. The Arab societies display the same symptom - [it is] even [displayed by] people who present themselves as intellectuals and writers. We read them with the hope of understanding what they mean to say, but to no avail... And when you dispute [their claims], they say that the problem lies not with the writer but with the reader, since he is shallow and insufficiently educated, and that is why he fails to understand the ideas of the important writers and intellectuals..."
"Loss of Human Feeling"
"This is another phenomenon spreading through the Arab societies. Unrestrained terrorism and cold-blooded butchering of innocent people in front of the TV cameras provide [further] indisputable proof that Arab society is afflicted with this dangerous disease. It should be noted that the famous religious scholar Sheikh Yousef Al-Qaradhawi advised to refrain from showing the killings on TV. This means that he supports these acts, but advises not showing them in this manner, since they give Islam and the Muslims a bad reputation. In the eyes of some, this makes Al-Qaradhawi a moderate cleric."
"The Patient Loses the Ability to Enjoy Activities He Enjoyed in the Past"
"This is also true of the Arab society today. During the course of their history, the Arabs used their powers of reasoning and exercised independent judgment in religious ruling [ijtihad]... in order to find rational solutions for existing problems. But a few hundred years ago... the gates of ijtihad were shut, the mind was shut down, and [clerics] began to rely exclusively on what was said by the founding fathers [of Islam] over 1,400 years ago, even if their solutions were inapplicable to contemporary problems..."
"Inactivity and Lethargy"
"Schizophrenia patients spend most of their time in idleness or slumber. Laziness,... sleepiness, fatalism and lack of productivity are also widespread in the Arab countries. A study published a number of years ago found that a Western worker is five times more productive than an Arab worker..."
"Loss of Zest for Life"
"This is a well-known tendency in Arab society. As bin Laden said in his address to the West, 'you love life, while we thirst for death.' This is an integral part of Arab heritage... This is why preachers in the mosques glorify death [in their sermons] to young people, [teach] them to hate life, and encourage them to carry out jihad terrorist operations..."
"Isolation From the World"
"Schizophrenia patients prefer to live in isolation from the rest of the world, and spend most of their time alone, detached from other people. They are uninterested in the company of friends and relatives, are unable to form friendships with other people or to maintain previous friendships, and do not care that they have no friends.
"All these symptoms are also prevalent in the Arab society, and are due to faulty education from an early age. Most textbooks for children and youth teach hatred towards others, and [encourage the reader] to avoid the company of non-Muslims. More than that, [they instruct the reader] to avoid greeting a non-Muslim, and, if greeted by a non-Muslim, to reply in an aloof and contemptuous manner. [They also teach that] if you shake hands with a non-Muslim, you must afterwards wash your hands. Directives of this sort are published by all religious schools - even by moderate clerics, and certainly by extremist ones.
"Arab culture also encourages isolation from the world. The world is divided into two camps: 'believers' and 'infidels'... Sheikh Al-Islam ibn Taymiyya encouraged [the Muslims] to hate the unbelievers, saying: 'When you spend time in the camp of the unbelievers - for purposes of medical [treatment], study or trade - harbor hostility towards them in your heart.'..."
"Denial of the Disease"
"Schizophrenia patients deny that they are ill, and believe that they are completely well. They are hostile towards anyone who tries to treat them or wishes to help them. Similarly, the Arabs are unaware of the duality in their behavior and standards, and do not realize that they are backward and require immediate treatment in order to overcome their backwardness and [to avoid] the disasters that befall them. Anyone who tries to draw their attention to their own backwardness... is accused of treason and of being a foreign agent, usually [an agent of] the 'imperialists,' 'Crusaders.' or 'Zionists.' Consequently, intellectuals have been persecuted in Arab countries throughout the ages..."
"Mental Paralysis"
"A [schizophrenia] patient is utterly convinced that his notions are correct, to the point of [mental] paralysis... The same [phenomenon] is also widespread in the Arab society, which believes that only its own culture and notions - which have been handed down from generation to generation - are valid, and tries to eliminate those who think differently... [Schizophrenia] patients are unable to understand abstract ideas according to their context, and take everything literally....
"A similar situation exists in Arab society, which cannot differentiate among various situations. Occupation of one country by another is a vile thing, but there are exceptional cases in which the occupation is necessary since it is for the good of the occupied country. This is true for Iraq, and for Europe during the Second World War. But Arab society regards the liberation of Iraq from an extremely vile, fascistic regime as an [act of] colonialism aimed at plundering [Iraq's] treasures and killing its people…"
Al-Zarqawi, bin Laden, and Al-Zawahiri Could Not Have Perpetrated Their Atrocities Without Extensive Popular Support
"Some may object [to my arguments], asking why I take the behavior of a single individual, a handful of people, or a group, [and present it] as the behavior of entire nations. Why do I ascribe the behavior of Al-Zarqawi, bin Laden or Al-Zawahiri to all Arabs? Why do I present the sin of one cleric as the sin of all clerics?
"[But] the truth is that what happened in Algeria and what is currently happening in Iraq and in other parts of the Arab world does not result from the deviant behavior of individuals, but from general behavior that is inevitably caused by [our] culture.
"Barbaric acts of mass murder were rampant in Algeria, with the number of victims reaching a quarter of a million. School girls were murdered for not wearing the veil. The murders carried out by 'jihad fighters' in Iraq have come to symbolize [the general situation there], which is condoned by Arab societies.
"Needless to say, Al-Zarqawi, bin Laden and Al-Zawahiri could not have perpetrated all these atrocities without extensive popular support, without constant recruitment [of new jihad fighters], and without the cultural and ideological support that is [ingrained] in the [Arab] heritage and education. Surveys conducted in a number of Arab countries showed that the majority supports the Al-Qaeda terrorist organization, and that bin Laden himself enjoys great popularity, especially in the Gulf countries…"
If Arab Governments Do Not Begin to Lead Their Peoples Towards Democracy, History Will Force It on Them
"Based on the above, I believe that Arab societies… suffer from duality in their standards, their views, and their behavior, and require immediate treatment if they want to heal, to overcome their backwardness, and to live in peace with the international community…
"Obviously, it is difficult to change the people's entire outlook overnight, especially when the governments constitute an obstacle to reform. The process is difficult and will take a long time, but there is nothing to prevent it from starting today… The ball is in the court of the Arab governments, who must understand the reasons for their backwardness and the backwardness of their people.
"The problem with these governments is that they have always objected, and still object, to gradual and peaceful development… [which occurs naturally] in the course of history. Democracy is the order of the day, and if the Arab governments do not begin to gradually lead their peoples towards democracy, history will force it on them through violent [upheavals], as occurred in Iraq...
"It should be noted that over 200 years ago, the Western peoples went through what the Arab peoples are experiencing now. They managed to resolve their problems, to build an advanced civilization, and to make economic, social, scientific and technological progress - but [this happened] only after reason was liberated from [the shackles of] fairytales and lies, [and after they] separated religion and state, established regimes that were secular, liberal and democratic, and gave freedom of speech and thought to [their] intellectuals."
Comment: This excellent article is not news for those of us with actual personal experience of witnessing Islamic societies close up. Readers who have never spent actual 'quality time' in Islamic countries cannot fully appreciate the truth of what the doctor has written.
Reform of Islam...much needed but probably not possible...is the final option for muslims in Australia. If this fails, apostacy looms as the only way to salvage personal mental health and the prospect of ordinary living in Australia.
Does it make sense adding to the numbers of muslims in Australia when we are just adding to the numbers of people who are lost in this miasma of mental illness and pointless backwardness?
At least do something about the poisonous imams in Australia who are the key source of all troubles for Australia and the local muslims in the poor neglected muslim communities. Start by kicking them out and do not allow replacements. Force the local muslims to fall back on their own resources.
Without the imams, who are the political 'bosses' in the political party called 'Islam', the politics of local Islam will start falling apart. If there is actually any 'religious' content to Islam, let the local muslims draw it out without the involvement of the fascist imams.
They cannot do this alone. Governments in Australia must help them.
Can we please show some mercy to the imam-oppressed muslims in Australia?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Special Dispatch Series - No. 1190
June 21, 2006 No.1190
Iraqi Reformist on Arab Society and Social Schizophrenia
In an article titled "Arab Society and Schizophrenia," Iraqi reformist Dr. Abd Al-Khaleq Hussein, who writes on several reformist websites, argues that Arab society suffers from "social schizophrenia," - the symptoms of which are similar to those of individuals suffering from actual schizophrenia. He further argues that the Arab governments must immediately launch social and political reforms which will gradually lead to democracy in the Arab world. If significant reforms are not carried out, he says, disasters will continue to strike the Arab word, and democracy will ultimately be imposed upon it through violent upheavals, as occurred in Iraq. In the article, he also called upon the Arabs to accept the help offered to them by the West - and especially by the U. S. - with the aim of facilitating positive change that will permit them to integrate into the international community.
The following are excerpts from the article: [1]
"This Split Personality Disorder Characterizes Not Only Specific Sectors of Arab Society, But [Also] the Governments, the Institutions of Civil Society, and the [Political] Parties"
"'Schizophrenia' is a word in ancient Greek that means 'split personality'... but it is also used in the social sciences to describe societies afflicted by severe duality in their behavior and their [moral] standards. In fact, if we carefully compare the medical and social forms of this disorder, we will find that the symptoms are very similar...
"Iraqi social scientist Ali Al-Wardi was the first to characterize the Iraqi people as suffering from this severe social illness, which he labeled 'split personality.' According to his theory, Iraqis suffer... from a conflict between the Bedouin values that have been passed down through the generations and the cultural values that the Iraqi society has acquired...
"As an illustration, he presents the example of a young Iraqi who wishes to choose his own wife, just like an enlightened Western man, and to exchange love letters with her,... but when he hears that some other man has similar relations with his sister or cousin, he immediately turns into a 'Bedouin' and murders his beloved sister and her lover...
"This split personality disorder characterizes not only specific sectors of Arab society, but [also] the governments, the institutions of civil society, and the [political] parties, especially the Islamic ones...
"The social and medical forms of this disorder have similar symptoms. The most important of these is delusions from which the patient suffers... For example:"
"Delusions of Grandeur"
"A [schizophrenia] patient believes that he is exceptional and that others should treat him as though he is an important person. The Arabs also believe that they are more important than others in every respect. They [believe that they] are the best among nations..., and regard other nations with contempt. They acknowledge no religion [but their own] and are unwilling to coexist peacefully with other religions. [They believe] that their faith is the only faith that mankind should embrace, and that whoever fails to embrace it is an infidel.
"In other words, all other religions are heathen, heretical and fabricated, and their followers should abandon them and embrace the Arabs' religion - Islam. If they fail to embrace Islam, the Muslims are entitled to wage war upon them, to kill their men or convert them by force, to take their women hostage, to sell their children in the slave market and to plunder their property...
"This disparaging view applies not only to non-Muslims, but also to other schools of thought within Islam. Each Islamic school of thought is full of contempt and hostility towards the others. The Salafis and Wahhabis, for example, are convinced that the Shiites must be killed, and that whoever kills them will be rewarded in the world to come..."
"Paranoia"
"A schizophrenia patient believes that others are plotting against him with the aim of harming and killing him, even though he hasn't a shred of evidence to prove this. This is exactly what happens with the Arabs, who are addicted to conspiracy theories. Whenever a disaster befalls them, they claim that it was brought about by a 'hostile Western Crusader-Zionist' conspiracy. They [say this] without bothering to think rationally and determine the true causes for their defeat...
"A schizophrenic imagines that people have nothing better to do than to talk about him, gossip about him, and plot against him. Consequently, he lives in a constant state of intense doubt and suspicion towards others, including the people closest to him, such as his wife, whom he suspects of cheating on him... The patient believes that even broadcasts on TV or on the other media are directed personally at him.
"This is exactly what happens in the Arab society with respect to foreign ideas and books. No society places books and ideas under siege the way Arab society does. Arab airports and sea ports are known for seizing books from the passengers. The Arabs are famous for translating the fewest books and for showing the greatest hostility towards the foreign sciences, to which they refer contemptuously... as 'imported ideas.' In addition, no people burn books and persecute intellectuals with more gusto than the Arabs."
"Somatic Delusions"
"The patient imagines strange and illogical things, for instance that foreign bodies are moving inside him, even though there is no evidence to suggest this. Similarly, Arab societies and governments suffer from the illness of [constantly suspecting] espionage by foreign agents. This is why the Arab jails are full of political prisoners and oppositionists accused of spying for other [countries]. In the eyes of the Arab governments and societies, the political opposition and the liberal intellectuals are traitors and agents of foreign intelligence [apparatuses]..."
"Disorganized Speech"
"A [schizophrenic] patient's speech makes no sense. There is no connection between the sentences, and the hearer or reader cannot understand what [the patient] means to say. The Arab societies display the same symptom - [it is] even [displayed by] people who present themselves as intellectuals and writers. We read them with the hope of understanding what they mean to say, but to no avail... And when you dispute [their claims], they say that the problem lies not with the writer but with the reader, since he is shallow and insufficiently educated, and that is why he fails to understand the ideas of the important writers and intellectuals..."
"Loss of Human Feeling"
"This is another phenomenon spreading through the Arab societies. Unrestrained terrorism and cold-blooded butchering of innocent people in front of the TV cameras provide [further] indisputable proof that Arab society is afflicted with this dangerous disease. It should be noted that the famous religious scholar Sheikh Yousef Al-Qaradhawi advised to refrain from showing the killings on TV. This means that he supports these acts, but advises not showing them in this manner, since they give Islam and the Muslims a bad reputation. In the eyes of some, this makes Al-Qaradhawi a moderate cleric."
"The Patient Loses the Ability to Enjoy Activities He Enjoyed in the Past"
"This is also true of the Arab society today. During the course of their history, the Arabs used their powers of reasoning and exercised independent judgment in religious ruling [ijtihad]... in order to find rational solutions for existing problems. But a few hundred years ago... the gates of ijtihad were shut, the mind was shut down, and [clerics] began to rely exclusively on what was said by the founding fathers [of Islam] over 1,400 years ago, even if their solutions were inapplicable to contemporary problems..."
"Inactivity and Lethargy"
"Schizophrenia patients spend most of their time in idleness or slumber. Laziness,... sleepiness, fatalism and lack of productivity are also widespread in the Arab countries. A study published a number of years ago found that a Western worker is five times more productive than an Arab worker..."
"Loss of Zest for Life"
"This is a well-known tendency in Arab society. As bin Laden said in his address to the West, 'you love life, while we thirst for death.' This is an integral part of Arab heritage... This is why preachers in the mosques glorify death [in their sermons] to young people, [teach] them to hate life, and encourage them to carry out jihad terrorist operations..."
"Isolation From the World"
"Schizophrenia patients prefer to live in isolation from the rest of the world, and spend most of their time alone, detached from other people. They are uninterested in the company of friends and relatives, are unable to form friendships with other people or to maintain previous friendships, and do not care that they have no friends.
"All these symptoms are also prevalent in the Arab society, and are due to faulty education from an early age. Most textbooks for children and youth teach hatred towards others, and [encourage the reader] to avoid the company of non-Muslims. More than that, [they instruct the reader] to avoid greeting a non-Muslim, and, if greeted by a non-Muslim, to reply in an aloof and contemptuous manner. [They also teach that] if you shake hands with a non-Muslim, you must afterwards wash your hands. Directives of this sort are published by all religious schools - even by moderate clerics, and certainly by extremist ones.
"Arab culture also encourages isolation from the world. The world is divided into two camps: 'believers' and 'infidels'... Sheikh Al-Islam ibn Taymiyya encouraged [the Muslims] to hate the unbelievers, saying: 'When you spend time in the camp of the unbelievers - for purposes of medical [treatment], study or trade - harbor hostility towards them in your heart.'..."
"Denial of the Disease"
"Schizophrenia patients deny that they are ill, and believe that they are completely well. They are hostile towards anyone who tries to treat them or wishes to help them. Similarly, the Arabs are unaware of the duality in their behavior and standards, and do not realize that they are backward and require immediate treatment in order to overcome their backwardness and [to avoid] the disasters that befall them. Anyone who tries to draw their attention to their own backwardness... is accused of treason and of being a foreign agent, usually [an agent of] the 'imperialists,' 'Crusaders.' or 'Zionists.' Consequently, intellectuals have been persecuted in Arab countries throughout the ages..."
"Mental Paralysis"
"A [schizophrenia] patient is utterly convinced that his notions are correct, to the point of [mental] paralysis... The same [phenomenon] is also widespread in the Arab society, which believes that only its own culture and notions - which have been handed down from generation to generation - are valid, and tries to eliminate those who think differently... [Schizophrenia] patients are unable to understand abstract ideas according to their context, and take everything literally....
"A similar situation exists in Arab society, which cannot differentiate among various situations. Occupation of one country by another is a vile thing, but there are exceptional cases in which the occupation is necessary since it is for the good of the occupied country. This is true for Iraq, and for Europe during the Second World War. But Arab society regards the liberation of Iraq from an extremely vile, fascistic regime as an [act of] colonialism aimed at plundering [Iraq's] treasures and killing its people…"
Al-Zarqawi, bin Laden, and Al-Zawahiri Could Not Have Perpetrated Their Atrocities Without Extensive Popular Support
"Some may object [to my arguments], asking why I take the behavior of a single individual, a handful of people, or a group, [and present it] as the behavior of entire nations. Why do I ascribe the behavior of Al-Zarqawi, bin Laden or Al-Zawahiri to all Arabs? Why do I present the sin of one cleric as the sin of all clerics?
"[But] the truth is that what happened in Algeria and what is currently happening in Iraq and in other parts of the Arab world does not result from the deviant behavior of individuals, but from general behavior that is inevitably caused by [our] culture.
"Barbaric acts of mass murder were rampant in Algeria, with the number of victims reaching a quarter of a million. School girls were murdered for not wearing the veil. The murders carried out by 'jihad fighters' in Iraq have come to symbolize [the general situation there], which is condoned by Arab societies.
"Needless to say, Al-Zarqawi, bin Laden and Al-Zawahiri could not have perpetrated all these atrocities without extensive popular support, without constant recruitment [of new jihad fighters], and without the cultural and ideological support that is [ingrained] in the [Arab] heritage and education. Surveys conducted in a number of Arab countries showed that the majority supports the Al-Qaeda terrorist organization, and that bin Laden himself enjoys great popularity, especially in the Gulf countries…"
If Arab Governments Do Not Begin to Lead Their Peoples Towards Democracy, History Will Force It on Them
"Based on the above, I believe that Arab societies… suffer from duality in their standards, their views, and their behavior, and require immediate treatment if they want to heal, to overcome their backwardness, and to live in peace with the international community…
"Obviously, it is difficult to change the people's entire outlook overnight, especially when the governments constitute an obstacle to reform. The process is difficult and will take a long time, but there is nothing to prevent it from starting today… The ball is in the court of the Arab governments, who must understand the reasons for their backwardness and the backwardness of their people.
"The problem with these governments is that they have always objected, and still object, to gradual and peaceful development… [which occurs naturally] in the course of history. Democracy is the order of the day, and if the Arab governments do not begin to gradually lead their peoples towards democracy, history will force it on them through violent [upheavals], as occurred in Iraq...
"It should be noted that over 200 years ago, the Western peoples went through what the Arab peoples are experiencing now. They managed to resolve their problems, to build an advanced civilization, and to make economic, social, scientific and technological progress - but [this happened] only after reason was liberated from [the shackles of] fairytales and lies, [and after they] separated religion and state, established regimes that were secular, liberal and democratic, and gave freedom of speech and thought to [their] intellectuals."
Comment: This excellent article is not news for those of us with actual personal experience of witnessing Islamic societies close up. Readers who have never spent actual 'quality time' in Islamic countries cannot fully appreciate the truth of what the doctor has written.
Reform of Islam...much needed but probably not possible...is the final option for muslims in Australia. If this fails, apostacy looms as the only way to salvage personal mental health and the prospect of ordinary living in Australia.
Does it make sense adding to the numbers of muslims in Australia when we are just adding to the numbers of people who are lost in this miasma of mental illness and pointless backwardness?
At least do something about the poisonous imams in Australia who are the key source of all troubles for Australia and the local muslims in the poor neglected muslim communities. Start by kicking them out and do not allow replacements. Force the local muslims to fall back on their own resources.
Without the imams, who are the political 'bosses' in the political party called 'Islam', the politics of local Islam will start falling apart. If there is actually any 'religious' content to Islam, let the local muslims draw it out without the involvement of the fascist imams.
They cannot do this alone. Governments in Australia must help them.
Can we please show some mercy to the imam-oppressed muslims in Australia?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
islamic Political Uniforms Banned In Norwegian Schools.
Note: Islamic political uniforms are banned in Norwegian schools and the push back against Islamic imperialism has another victory.
Oslo bans burqas at school
Wednesday 21 June 2006, 20:36
Several European countries have already banned face coverings.
Schools in the Norwegian capital will ban Muslim girls from covering their faces, adding to the list of European cities and states that have banned the garment.
Toerger Odegaard, the head of the city's education department, said Oslo's city council wants to ban the burqa and niqab, garments which cover the face.
He said teachers could not do their job properly without seeing their students' faces.
"We will introduce a ban after the summer holidays at the end of August," he told Reuters on Wednesday.
Lawyers at the education ministry had just told the council it would not be illegal under Norwegian law to ban the headdress.
Religious symbols
France has banned overt religious symbols at school. In December, the Dutch parliament voted in favour of banning burqas, and the Belgian town of Maaseik has forbidden them through an existing law which required people to be identifiable in public.
Muslims in Norway - which has large Pakistani and Somali minorities concentrated mainly in Oslo - said the move was an encroachment on personal freedom.
Fakhra Salimi, the head of MiRA a partly state-sponsored group that helps female immigrants in Norway, said: "We have been having a discussion about whether you should wear the niqab or not, but making laws which ban it is just going too far."
She said women over the age of 16 should be able to wear the niqab if they chose.
Comment: Australian schools have to follow suit and ban Islamic political uniforms in Australia.
Anyone awake in Canberra?
Oslo bans burqas at school
Wednesday 21 June 2006, 20:36
Several European countries have already banned face coverings.
Schools in the Norwegian capital will ban Muslim girls from covering their faces, adding to the list of European cities and states that have banned the garment.
Toerger Odegaard, the head of the city's education department, said Oslo's city council wants to ban the burqa and niqab, garments which cover the face.
He said teachers could not do their job properly without seeing their students' faces.
"We will introduce a ban after the summer holidays at the end of August," he told Reuters on Wednesday.
Lawyers at the education ministry had just told the council it would not be illegal under Norwegian law to ban the headdress.
Religious symbols
France has banned overt religious symbols at school. In December, the Dutch parliament voted in favour of banning burqas, and the Belgian town of Maaseik has forbidden them through an existing law which required people to be identifiable in public.
Muslims in Norway - which has large Pakistani and Somali minorities concentrated mainly in Oslo - said the move was an encroachment on personal freedom.
Fakhra Salimi, the head of MiRA a partly state-sponsored group that helps female immigrants in Norway, said: "We have been having a discussion about whether you should wear the niqab or not, but making laws which ban it is just going too far."
She said women over the age of 16 should be able to wear the niqab if they chose.
Comment: Australian schools have to follow suit and ban Islamic political uniforms in Australia.
Anyone awake in Canberra?
Another Example Of Why Islam Needs Reforming.
Note: This fake 'religious' rubbish which is 'Islam in the real world' has no future. Unless reform is undertaken, Islam will fall further and further behind the rest of the world. The evil imams do not recognise that as muslims experience the real world they will reject the pigswill in which they currently live.
But who can reform Islam?
21 June, 2006
PAKISTAN
Government silent as blasphemy law continues to kill, say Pakistani bishops
In a statement released by the Justice and Peace Commission of the Bishops’ Conference of Pakistan the government’s negligence vis-à-vis crimes committed in the name of religion and on the basis of blasphemy laws is described as a “real sin”.
Lahore (AsiaNews) – The Justice and Peace Commission of the Bishops’ Conference of Pakistan has expressed “profound concern” for the evident negligence by the authorities and elected officials who should uphold the law regarding the growing intolerance associated with blasphemy laws.
Fr Emmanuel Yousaf and Peter Jacob, respectively director and executive secretary of the bishops’ commission, said in a joint statement that “the horrible murder of Mohammad Sadiq, an elderly school teacher killed last Sunday whilst trying to save someone else from the blasphemy laws, and that of Abdul Sattar, who was killed the next day when he was under police protection, underscore the alarming level of insecurity Pakistani citizens feel as a result of the abuse of religion”.
“It is extremely sad that two other lives were sacrificed owing to a legislative void created by the blasphemy laws,” the added.
“In the first case we have a respected citizen killed by the people of Hasilpur whilst trying to rescue from a lynch mob the imam of the local mosque, Hafiz Mohammad Qamar, who was being tortured by some miscreants.”
“In the second,” the statement reads, “we have a man who gets himself killed for allegedly insulting the prophet when in fact all he wanted was a driver to pay his fee.”
The so-called blasphemy law or laws refer to article 295, sections B and C, of the Pakistan Criminal Code. The first section covers offences against the Qur‘an, a crime punishable with life in prison. The second section imposes either the death penalty or life in prison on anyone found guilty of defaming the Prophet Muhammad.
Since 1996 when the two sections came into effect, a lot of Christians have been killed for defaming Islam. Altogether some 560 people have been charged with 30 still waiting for trial.
Very often the law is used to eliminate adversaries.
According to data provided by different human rights groups, 23 people have died as a result of blasphemy charges, 18 of whom were Muslim. In each case law enforcement authorities did not intervene to stop the murder.
“It is a real sin that the government has allowed this kind of ‘unlawful legality’ to exist in name of religion, abdicating its duty to tell the people how often the law is misused,” the statement said.
“It is important that those guilty of these crimes be brought to justice. For this reason, we call for an immediate inquiry to unmask those responsible for this situation.”
Comment: Australia does not need this pigswill 'religion' here. We should stop letting Pakistani Muslims into Australia. Only allow Christians and Achmadiyya to come here from that hopeless backward place.
But who can reform Islam?
21 June, 2006
PAKISTAN
Government silent as blasphemy law continues to kill, say Pakistani bishops
In a statement released by the Justice and Peace Commission of the Bishops’ Conference of Pakistan the government’s negligence vis-à-vis crimes committed in the name of religion and on the basis of blasphemy laws is described as a “real sin”.
Lahore (AsiaNews) – The Justice and Peace Commission of the Bishops’ Conference of Pakistan has expressed “profound concern” for the evident negligence by the authorities and elected officials who should uphold the law regarding the growing intolerance associated with blasphemy laws.
Fr Emmanuel Yousaf and Peter Jacob, respectively director and executive secretary of the bishops’ commission, said in a joint statement that “the horrible murder of Mohammad Sadiq, an elderly school teacher killed last Sunday whilst trying to save someone else from the blasphemy laws, and that of Abdul Sattar, who was killed the next day when he was under police protection, underscore the alarming level of insecurity Pakistani citizens feel as a result of the abuse of religion”.
“It is extremely sad that two other lives were sacrificed owing to a legislative void created by the blasphemy laws,” the added.
“In the first case we have a respected citizen killed by the people of Hasilpur whilst trying to rescue from a lynch mob the imam of the local mosque, Hafiz Mohammad Qamar, who was being tortured by some miscreants.”
“In the second,” the statement reads, “we have a man who gets himself killed for allegedly insulting the prophet when in fact all he wanted was a driver to pay his fee.”
The so-called blasphemy law or laws refer to article 295, sections B and C, of the Pakistan Criminal Code. The first section covers offences against the Qur‘an, a crime punishable with life in prison. The second section imposes either the death penalty or life in prison on anyone found guilty of defaming the Prophet Muhammad.
Since 1996 when the two sections came into effect, a lot of Christians have been killed for defaming Islam. Altogether some 560 people have been charged with 30 still waiting for trial.
Very often the law is used to eliminate adversaries.
According to data provided by different human rights groups, 23 people have died as a result of blasphemy charges, 18 of whom were Muslim. In each case law enforcement authorities did not intervene to stop the murder.
“It is a real sin that the government has allowed this kind of ‘unlawful legality’ to exist in name of religion, abdicating its duty to tell the people how often the law is misused,” the statement said.
“It is important that those guilty of these crimes be brought to justice. For this reason, we call for an immediate inquiry to unmask those responsible for this situation.”
Comment: Australia does not need this pigswill 'religion' here. We should stop letting Pakistani Muslims into Australia. Only allow Christians and Achmadiyya to come here from that hopeless backward place.
Tuesday, June 20, 2006
Jewish Hatred Of Christianity Starting to Show.
Note: The reactionary nature of Jewish religious politics in Israel shows up starkly in these developments. The Jewish religious establishment in Israel is better educated than the backward imams and mullahs of the muslims, but just as vicious. Do not expect much progress in this matter; it shows clearly the real value of the word of an Israeli government.
Influential US MP tells Bush: let’s ask Israel to reach accord with Holy See
by Arieh Cohen
Henry Hyde, Chairman of the Committee on International Relations of the US House of Representatives, has expressed concern about the lack of progress in negotiations between the Israeli state and the Holy See towards accepting the Fundamental Agreement and for the conclusion – stipulated in it – of a comprehensive accord about pending claims on economic and property matters.
Tel Aviv (AsiaNews) – A year or so after his letter to then Secretary of State Colin Powell, which helped re-start the negotiations earlier suspended by Israel, the Chairman of the Committee on International Relations of the U.S. House of Representatives, Henry Hyde, has written to President George W. Bush, to express once more his concern for the Catholic Church in the Holy Land. Chairman Hyde, one of the most highly respected Member of the U.S. Congress, and a devout Catholic, shares, among other things, with the American President, his "concerns regarding negotiations between the Holy See and the State of Israel."
AsiaNews has now obtained from a reliable source a copy of that letter.
The influential Catholic statesman sends the President, together with his letter, a report on, among other things, Israel's attitude to the "Fundamental Agreement [which] is an historic international treaty signed by the Holy See and Israel ...[which] entered into force in 1994..." In spite of the many years that have passed since then, "The agreement has not been ratified by the Israeli Knesset [i.e. parliament], making it impossible for church institutions to uphold the provisions of the agreement in Israeli courts. As a result, these institutions are vulnerable." Moreover, the Fundamental "Agreement ... mandates a comprehensive agreement on all outstanding claims concerning economic and property matters" pending between the State of Israel and the Catholic Church. It was to have been achieved "within two years" of the entry into force of the Fundamental Agreement in 1994. Many more years "have passed since the treaty [i.e. the Fundamental Agreement itself] has entered into force, and still there is no comprehensive agreement" on those vital fiscal and property matters. As a consequence of that, the report concludes, there is a "need for the United States to urgently extend its political support for the successful resolution of the negotiations between the Holy See and the State of Israel. It is vital that there be a comprehensive settlement of all outstanding claims so the various agreements may be written into Israeli law, permitting the Church access to due process in Israel's democratic government, allowing Christian institutions to focus on serving the communities they serve". To this end Israel's "newly elected Prime Minister... should ensure that there is a team in place that is empowered [to negotiate] " and there should be allocated "sufficient time to negotiate an agreement."
As reported several times by AsiaNews over the years, the negotiations are principally aimed at obtaining Israel's recognition of the rights possessed by the Catholic Church at the time the State of Israel was created in 1948. Although the U.N. Resolution that authorised the creation of the Jewish State (Resolution 181 of 29 November 1947) had laid down, for example, that no taxes should be imposed on the Church's institutions, from which they were previously exempt, Israel has never formally acknowledged that the Church possessed any such "existing rights." Involved, in addition to internationally recognised tax exemptions, are matters concerning Church property, especially sacred places. As an essential part of normalising relations with the State, the Church is claiming restitution of lost religioius property, including the church-shrine in Caesarea - confiscated by the State and razed to the ground in the 1950's - and an important convent of Franciscan Sisters in Jerusalem, occupied since 1948 by the national university, the Hebrew University.
Even more importantly, the Church's possession of all sacred places is jeopardised by an Israeli law which reserves jurisdiction to the Executive - i.e. to politicians - in all disputes concerning "religious building or sites." This means that the Government may arbitrarily deny the Church access to the Israeli courts, and instead decide such cases in accordance with electoral or any other extraneous considerations, rather than in accordance with the laws governing property. In this matter the Church is not asking for any privileges, but only for the right of any property owner to have disputes decided in the courts and according the law.
The negotiations on all of these questions were formally begun only on 11 March 1999, and have continued sporadically since then. As reported in the media, Israel has repeatedly cancelled planned meetings, asked for extended intervals, and on 28 August 2003 Israel withdrew from the negotiations altogether. American interest in the matter greatly helped in bringing Israel back to the negotiating table (although meetings continue to be held only sporadically). Nonetheless – reliable sources tell AsiaNews – there is no end in sight. Meanwhile, on the ground, problems have multiplied for Church institutions, explaining the sense of urgency emphasised by the Hyde letter to President Bush.
Americans feel closely involved, both because of the large number of Catholic citizens in the U.S., and because American Catholics are generous donors to the Catholic Church in Israel, and want to be sure that their hard-earned money goes to the purposes, for which it is given, and not gobbled up in taxes, from which, in the U.S. itself, the Church (along with the Synagogue and the Mosque) is exempt, or to which the Church throughout the Holy Land has "existing rights" to exemption.
It remains to be seen whether the combination of the extraordinary abilities of Vatican diplomacy and the weight of American support, together with fresh thinking on the part of Prime Minister Olmert and his new Foreign Minister Tzippi Livni, will finally achieve the too-long-delayed "comprehensive agreement."
Comment: It is not only Islam in the Middle East which is a source of long term trouble. Fundamentalist Judaism is working day and night to avoid having to live in the modern world.
I wonder if any Australian politicians are willing to add their voices to the chorus for Israel to 'keep its word', and negotiate in good faith?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Influential US MP tells Bush: let’s ask Israel to reach accord with Holy See
by Arieh Cohen
Henry Hyde, Chairman of the Committee on International Relations of the US House of Representatives, has expressed concern about the lack of progress in negotiations between the Israeli state and the Holy See towards accepting the Fundamental Agreement and for the conclusion – stipulated in it – of a comprehensive accord about pending claims on economic and property matters.
Tel Aviv (AsiaNews) – A year or so after his letter to then Secretary of State Colin Powell, which helped re-start the negotiations earlier suspended by Israel, the Chairman of the Committee on International Relations of the U.S. House of Representatives, Henry Hyde, has written to President George W. Bush, to express once more his concern for the Catholic Church in the Holy Land. Chairman Hyde, one of the most highly respected Member of the U.S. Congress, and a devout Catholic, shares, among other things, with the American President, his "concerns regarding negotiations between the Holy See and the State of Israel."
AsiaNews has now obtained from a reliable source a copy of that letter.
The influential Catholic statesman sends the President, together with his letter, a report on, among other things, Israel's attitude to the "Fundamental Agreement [which] is an historic international treaty signed by the Holy See and Israel ...[which] entered into force in 1994..." In spite of the many years that have passed since then, "The agreement has not been ratified by the Israeli Knesset [i.e. parliament], making it impossible for church institutions to uphold the provisions of the agreement in Israeli courts. As a result, these institutions are vulnerable." Moreover, the Fundamental "Agreement ... mandates a comprehensive agreement on all outstanding claims concerning economic and property matters" pending between the State of Israel and the Catholic Church. It was to have been achieved "within two years" of the entry into force of the Fundamental Agreement in 1994. Many more years "have passed since the treaty [i.e. the Fundamental Agreement itself] has entered into force, and still there is no comprehensive agreement" on those vital fiscal and property matters. As a consequence of that, the report concludes, there is a "need for the United States to urgently extend its political support for the successful resolution of the negotiations between the Holy See and the State of Israel. It is vital that there be a comprehensive settlement of all outstanding claims so the various agreements may be written into Israeli law, permitting the Church access to due process in Israel's democratic government, allowing Christian institutions to focus on serving the communities they serve". To this end Israel's "newly elected Prime Minister... should ensure that there is a team in place that is empowered [to negotiate] " and there should be allocated "sufficient time to negotiate an agreement."
As reported several times by AsiaNews over the years, the negotiations are principally aimed at obtaining Israel's recognition of the rights possessed by the Catholic Church at the time the State of Israel was created in 1948. Although the U.N. Resolution that authorised the creation of the Jewish State (Resolution 181 of 29 November 1947) had laid down, for example, that no taxes should be imposed on the Church's institutions, from which they were previously exempt, Israel has never formally acknowledged that the Church possessed any such "existing rights." Involved, in addition to internationally recognised tax exemptions, are matters concerning Church property, especially sacred places. As an essential part of normalising relations with the State, the Church is claiming restitution of lost religioius property, including the church-shrine in Caesarea - confiscated by the State and razed to the ground in the 1950's - and an important convent of Franciscan Sisters in Jerusalem, occupied since 1948 by the national university, the Hebrew University.
Even more importantly, the Church's possession of all sacred places is jeopardised by an Israeli law which reserves jurisdiction to the Executive - i.e. to politicians - in all disputes concerning "religious building or sites." This means that the Government may arbitrarily deny the Church access to the Israeli courts, and instead decide such cases in accordance with electoral or any other extraneous considerations, rather than in accordance with the laws governing property. In this matter the Church is not asking for any privileges, but only for the right of any property owner to have disputes decided in the courts and according the law.
The negotiations on all of these questions were formally begun only on 11 March 1999, and have continued sporadically since then. As reported in the media, Israel has repeatedly cancelled planned meetings, asked for extended intervals, and on 28 August 2003 Israel withdrew from the negotiations altogether. American interest in the matter greatly helped in bringing Israel back to the negotiating table (although meetings continue to be held only sporadically). Nonetheless – reliable sources tell AsiaNews – there is no end in sight. Meanwhile, on the ground, problems have multiplied for Church institutions, explaining the sense of urgency emphasised by the Hyde letter to President Bush.
Americans feel closely involved, both because of the large number of Catholic citizens in the U.S., and because American Catholics are generous donors to the Catholic Church in Israel, and want to be sure that their hard-earned money goes to the purposes, for which it is given, and not gobbled up in taxes, from which, in the U.S. itself, the Church (along with the Synagogue and the Mosque) is exempt, or to which the Church throughout the Holy Land has "existing rights" to exemption.
It remains to be seen whether the combination of the extraordinary abilities of Vatican diplomacy and the weight of American support, together with fresh thinking on the part of Prime Minister Olmert and his new Foreign Minister Tzippi Livni, will finally achieve the too-long-delayed "comprehensive agreement."
Comment: It is not only Islam in the Middle East which is a source of long term trouble. Fundamentalist Judaism is working day and night to avoid having to live in the modern world.
I wonder if any Australian politicians are willing to add their voices to the chorus for Israel to 'keep its word', and negotiate in good faith?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Monday, June 19, 2006
Canary Sings In The European Mine.
Note: This post from a high ranking member of the British Navy should give Australians pause for thought. We also are on the edge of an area with lots of impoverished muslims...Indonesia. Grovelling to them is never a solution.
The Sunday Times June 11, 2006
Beware: the new goths are coming
Peter Almond
ONE of Britain’s most senior military strategists has warned that western civilisation faces a threat on a par with the barbarian invasions that destroyed the Roman empire.
In an apocalyptic vision of security dangers, Rear Admiral Chris Parry said future migrations would be comparable to the Goths and Vandals while north African "barbary" pirates could be attacking yachts and beaches in the Mediterranean within 10 years.
Europe, including Britain, could be undermined by large immigrant groups with little allegiance to their host countries — a "reverse colonisation" as Parry described it. These groups would stay connected to their homelands by the internet and cheap flights. The idea of assimilation was becoming redundant, he said.
The warnings by Parry of what could threaten Britain over the next 30 years were delivered to senior officers and industry experts at a conference last week. Parry, head of the development, concepts and doctrine centre at the Ministry of Defence, is charged with identifying the greatest challenges that will frame national security policy in the future.
If a security breakdown occurred, he said, it was likely to be brought on by environmental destruction and a population boom, coupled with technology and radical Islam. The result for Britain and Europe, Parry warned, could be "like the 5th century Roman empire facing the Goths and the Vandals".
Parry pointed to the mass migration which disaster in the Third World could unleash. "The diaspora issue is one of my biggest current concerns," he said. "Globalisation makes assimilation seem redundant and old-fashioned . . . [the process] acts as a sort of reverse colonisation, where groups of people are self-contained, going back and forth between their countries, exploiting sophisticated networks and using instant communication on phones and the internet."
Third World instability would lick at the edges of the West as pirates attacked holidaymakers from fast boats. "At some time in the next 10 years it may not be safe to sail a yacht between Gibraltar and Malta," said the admiral.
Parry, 52, an Oxford graduate who was mentioned in dispatches in the Falklands war, is not claiming all the threats will come to fruition. He is warning, however, of what is likely to happen if dangers are not addressed by politicians.
Parry — who used the slogan "old dog, new tricks" when he commanded the assault ship HMS Fearless — foresees wholesale moves by the armed forces to robots, drones, nanotechnology, lasers, microwave weapons, space-based systems and even "customised" nuclear and neutron bombs.
Lord Boyce, the former chief of the defence staff, welcomed Parry’s analysis. "Bringing it together in this way shows we have some very serious challenges ahead," he said. "The real problem is getting them taken seriously at the top of the government."
Comment: The last line says it all...'The real problem is getting them taken seriously at the top of government'.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
The Sunday Times June 11, 2006
Beware: the new goths are coming
Peter Almond
ONE of Britain’s most senior military strategists has warned that western civilisation faces a threat on a par with the barbarian invasions that destroyed the Roman empire.
In an apocalyptic vision of security dangers, Rear Admiral Chris Parry said future migrations would be comparable to the Goths and Vandals while north African "barbary" pirates could be attacking yachts and beaches in the Mediterranean within 10 years.
Europe, including Britain, could be undermined by large immigrant groups with little allegiance to their host countries — a "reverse colonisation" as Parry described it. These groups would stay connected to their homelands by the internet and cheap flights. The idea of assimilation was becoming redundant, he said.
The warnings by Parry of what could threaten Britain over the next 30 years were delivered to senior officers and industry experts at a conference last week. Parry, head of the development, concepts and doctrine centre at the Ministry of Defence, is charged with identifying the greatest challenges that will frame national security policy in the future.
If a security breakdown occurred, he said, it was likely to be brought on by environmental destruction and a population boom, coupled with technology and radical Islam. The result for Britain and Europe, Parry warned, could be "like the 5th century Roman empire facing the Goths and the Vandals".
Parry pointed to the mass migration which disaster in the Third World could unleash. "The diaspora issue is one of my biggest current concerns," he said. "Globalisation makes assimilation seem redundant and old-fashioned . . . [the process] acts as a sort of reverse colonisation, where groups of people are self-contained, going back and forth between their countries, exploiting sophisticated networks and using instant communication on phones and the internet."
Third World instability would lick at the edges of the West as pirates attacked holidaymakers from fast boats. "At some time in the next 10 years it may not be safe to sail a yacht between Gibraltar and Malta," said the admiral.
Parry, 52, an Oxford graduate who was mentioned in dispatches in the Falklands war, is not claiming all the threats will come to fruition. He is warning, however, of what is likely to happen if dangers are not addressed by politicians.
Parry — who used the slogan "old dog, new tricks" when he commanded the assault ship HMS Fearless — foresees wholesale moves by the armed forces to robots, drones, nanotechnology, lasers, microwave weapons, space-based systems and even "customised" nuclear and neutron bombs.
Lord Boyce, the former chief of the defence staff, welcomed Parry’s analysis. "Bringing it together in this way shows we have some very serious challenges ahead," he said. "The real problem is getting them taken seriously at the top of the government."
Comment: The last line says it all...'The real problem is getting them taken seriously at the top of government'.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Sunday, June 18, 2006
Lunacy As Part Of Islamic Historiography.
Note: This posting is a good example of the widespread, low level of historical studies undertaken by contemporary Islamic 'scholars'.
Shakespeare the Muslim and the Collapse of the West
By Robert Spencer
FrontPageMagazine.com | October 29, 2004
“We know what we are, but know not what we may become,” observed Shakespeare, who no doubt knew not that four hundred years after his death, he himself would be proclaimed a Sufi Muslim. “Shakespeare would have delighted in Sufism,” said the Islamic scholar Martin Lings, himself a Sufi Muslim who also goes by the name Abu Bakr Siraj ad-Din. “We can see he obviously knew a lot about some kind of equivalent sect or order.”
According to The Guardian, Lings will argue that Shakespeare’s “work resembles the teachings of the Islamic Sufi sect” in the International Shakespeare Globe Fellowship Lecture at Shakespeare’s own Globe Theatre in London. Lings will speak in November during Islam Awareness Week, which will also feature other Muslim speakers, while Islamic scenes are projected on the Globe’s outside walls. “On the final weekend,” says The Guardian, “a souk will take over the premises, with stalls selling eastern wares.”
By the pricking of my thumbs, something preposterous this way comes. “It’s impossible for Shakespeare to have been a Muslim,” David N. Beauregard, a Shakespeare scholar and coeditor of Shakespeare and the Culture of Christianity in Early Modern England, told me. Beauregard has argued that there is a “growing consensus that Shakespeare was a Roman Catholic.… he maintained Roman Catholic beliefs on crucial doctrinal differences.” He notes that “this is not to say that Shakespeare was occupied with writing religious drama, but only that a specific religious tradition informs his work.” And it isn’t Sufism.
But of course, the Globe’s Islam Awareness Week is not so much about Shakespeare as it is about present-day Britain’s anxiety to appease its growing and restive Muslim population. Shakespeare is just the latest paradigmatic figure of Western Christian culture to be remade in a Muslim-friendly manner: recently the State Department asserted, without a shred of evidence, that Christopher Columbus (who in fact praised Ferdinand and Isabella for driving the Muslims out of Spain) was aided on his voyages by a Muslim navigator.
It is a sign of the times when this kind of thinking is no longer confined to Islamic apologetics websites, but is taken up by the Globe Theatre and the U.S. State Department — hardly representatives of the cultural fringes — and even American textbook publishers. The state of American education is so dismal today that teachers themselves are ill-equipped to counter these historical fantasies. They will become willing propagators of the new history: nothing to fear from Muslims, you see. Shakespeare was one of them. Oh yes, and Goethe. And Abraham Lincoln’s mother. And Napoleon Bonaparte. What? You didn’t know the Napoleonic Code was based on Sharia law?
Sharia law — aye, there’s the rub. No doubt there will be no mention at the Globe Theatre’s souk of the fact that many Muslims in Britain believe that the British government, and indeed any government, has no legitimacy unless it implements Sharia. No admirer of the Sufi Shakespeare is likely during the festivities to quote the Egyptian Muslim writer Sayyid Qutb, whose writings are revered today by radical Muslims worldwide. Qutb declared that “the foremost duty of Islam is to depose Jahiliyyah [the government and society of unbelievers] from the leadership of man.” Radical Muslim leaders everywhere today call upon Muslims to recover the teachings of the Qur’an and Islamic tradition that enjoined them to institute Islamic hegemony by force if necessary.
But it has become a rule of the public debate that such aspects of Islam cannot be mentioned. We must accept on faith that no Muslim among those streaming into Western countries has any plans to interfere with the constitutions of those countries, now or in the future. And if they do, what of it? Muslim Spain, after all, was a paradise of multiculturalist harmony. Shakespeare was a Muslim. And on and on.
The Syrian writer Sadik Al-Azm recently declared that there was no clash of civilizations, because the West was so strong and the Islamic world so weak that any conflict would inevitably result in the triumph of the West. Al-Azm didn’t consider, however, that the West itself would look upon Othello’s boast of smiting “a malignant and a turban’d Turk” and decide that he should go for some sensitivity training. If radical Muslims like Britain’s notorious Sheikh Omar Bakri ultimately realize their dream of seeing the black flag of Islam flying from #10 Downing Street, and continue to advance elsewhere in the West, the fault, as Cassius told Brutus, will be not in our stars, but in ourselves.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert Spencer is a scholar of Islamic history, theology, and law and the director of Jihad Watch. He is the author of five books, seven monographs, and hundreds of articles about jihad and Islamic terrorism, including Islam Unveiled: Disturbing Questions About the World’s Fastest Growing Faith and The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam (and the Crusades). He is also an Adjunct Fellow with the Free Congress Foundation.
Comment: It would be certain that this sort of absurdity would be taught in muslim schools. Of course, no muslim school could ever actually perform any of Shakespeare's plays...forbidden by Islam.
Can Islam really become part of Australian life?
Shakespeare the Muslim and the Collapse of the West
By Robert Spencer
FrontPageMagazine.com | October 29, 2004
“We know what we are, but know not what we may become,” observed Shakespeare, who no doubt knew not that four hundred years after his death, he himself would be proclaimed a Sufi Muslim. “Shakespeare would have delighted in Sufism,” said the Islamic scholar Martin Lings, himself a Sufi Muslim who also goes by the name Abu Bakr Siraj ad-Din. “We can see he obviously knew a lot about some kind of equivalent sect or order.”
According to The Guardian, Lings will argue that Shakespeare’s “work resembles the teachings of the Islamic Sufi sect” in the International Shakespeare Globe Fellowship Lecture at Shakespeare’s own Globe Theatre in London. Lings will speak in November during Islam Awareness Week, which will also feature other Muslim speakers, while Islamic scenes are projected on the Globe’s outside walls. “On the final weekend,” says The Guardian, “a souk will take over the premises, with stalls selling eastern wares.”
By the pricking of my thumbs, something preposterous this way comes. “It’s impossible for Shakespeare to have been a Muslim,” David N. Beauregard, a Shakespeare scholar and coeditor of Shakespeare and the Culture of Christianity in Early Modern England, told me. Beauregard has argued that there is a “growing consensus that Shakespeare was a Roman Catholic.… he maintained Roman Catholic beliefs on crucial doctrinal differences.” He notes that “this is not to say that Shakespeare was occupied with writing religious drama, but only that a specific religious tradition informs his work.” And it isn’t Sufism.
But of course, the Globe’s Islam Awareness Week is not so much about Shakespeare as it is about present-day Britain’s anxiety to appease its growing and restive Muslim population. Shakespeare is just the latest paradigmatic figure of Western Christian culture to be remade in a Muslim-friendly manner: recently the State Department asserted, without a shred of evidence, that Christopher Columbus (who in fact praised Ferdinand and Isabella for driving the Muslims out of Spain) was aided on his voyages by a Muslim navigator.
It is a sign of the times when this kind of thinking is no longer confined to Islamic apologetics websites, but is taken up by the Globe Theatre and the U.S. State Department — hardly representatives of the cultural fringes — and even American textbook publishers. The state of American education is so dismal today that teachers themselves are ill-equipped to counter these historical fantasies. They will become willing propagators of the new history: nothing to fear from Muslims, you see. Shakespeare was one of them. Oh yes, and Goethe. And Abraham Lincoln’s mother. And Napoleon Bonaparte. What? You didn’t know the Napoleonic Code was based on Sharia law?
Sharia law — aye, there’s the rub. No doubt there will be no mention at the Globe Theatre’s souk of the fact that many Muslims in Britain believe that the British government, and indeed any government, has no legitimacy unless it implements Sharia. No admirer of the Sufi Shakespeare is likely during the festivities to quote the Egyptian Muslim writer Sayyid Qutb, whose writings are revered today by radical Muslims worldwide. Qutb declared that “the foremost duty of Islam is to depose Jahiliyyah [the government and society of unbelievers] from the leadership of man.” Radical Muslim leaders everywhere today call upon Muslims to recover the teachings of the Qur’an and Islamic tradition that enjoined them to institute Islamic hegemony by force if necessary.
But it has become a rule of the public debate that such aspects of Islam cannot be mentioned. We must accept on faith that no Muslim among those streaming into Western countries has any plans to interfere with the constitutions of those countries, now or in the future. And if they do, what of it? Muslim Spain, after all, was a paradise of multiculturalist harmony. Shakespeare was a Muslim. And on and on.
The Syrian writer Sadik Al-Azm recently declared that there was no clash of civilizations, because the West was so strong and the Islamic world so weak that any conflict would inevitably result in the triumph of the West. Al-Azm didn’t consider, however, that the West itself would look upon Othello’s boast of smiting “a malignant and a turban’d Turk” and decide that he should go for some sensitivity training. If radical Muslims like Britain’s notorious Sheikh Omar Bakri ultimately realize their dream of seeing the black flag of Islam flying from #10 Downing Street, and continue to advance elsewhere in the West, the fault, as Cassius told Brutus, will be not in our stars, but in ourselves.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert Spencer is a scholar of Islamic history, theology, and law and the director of Jihad Watch. He is the author of five books, seven monographs, and hundreds of articles about jihad and Islamic terrorism, including Islam Unveiled: Disturbing Questions About the World’s Fastest Growing Faith and The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam (and the Crusades). He is also an Adjunct Fellow with the Free Congress Foundation.
Comment: It would be certain that this sort of absurdity would be taught in muslim schools. Of course, no muslim school could ever actually perform any of Shakespeare's plays...forbidden by Islam.
Can Islam really become part of Australian life?
Another Clear Thinking Muslim Writer.
Note: This post is from a Pakistani newspaper. The author is muslim (at least by cultural background.) His observations about the Wahhabi/Salafist fascist Islam are important for Australians because it is the Wahhabi/Salafists who are taking over the sunni muslim community and organisations in Australia.
This takeover is with the full support of the Federal and State governments in Australia. You don't have to be a muslim to be an idiot in relation to Islam.
Read and be warned...
Thursday, June 15, 2006
THINKING ALOUD: ‘An archaic incongruity’? — Razi Azmi
Whenever a terrorist outrage occurs in any Muslim country and the victims are ordinary Muslims, we are told that Muslims must never kill Muslims. Even fatwas are issued to that effect. The unspoken and unwritten subtext seems to suggest that it is acceptable for Muslims to kill non-Muslims, provided there is a pretext
In their nearly 400-page Report of the Court of Inquiry into the Punjab Disturbances of 1953, popularly known as the Munir Report, two eminently learned Pakistani judges, Chief Justice Muhammad Munir and Justice MR Kayani had concluded, after 117 sittings, perusing 3,600 pages of written statements and sifting through 2,700 pages of evidence over eight months:
“Nothing but a bold reorientation of Islam to separate the vital from the lifeless can preserve it as a world idea and convert the Musalman into a citizen of the present and the future world from the archaic incongruity that he is today.”
Has anything changed since this bold statement was made by the justices over half a century ago?
Seventeen Canadian Muslims, five of whom are teenagers, were arrested earlier this month in Toronto for conspiring to carry out terrorist attacks in the very country which not only hosted and nurtured them but is also considered a model of multiculturalism and tolerance. Indeed, the province of Ontario recently came close to allowing Muslims to be governed by their own Sharia courts instead of secular civil courts.
At least six of those arrested regularly attended the same mosque in a middle-class Toronto suburb. The oldest, Qayyum Abdul Jamal, 43, is said to be an active member of the mosque who frequently led prayers and made fiery speeches.
In England, another bastion of multiculturism with a massive and thriving Muslim presence, less than a year after 9/11 Al Qaeda sympathisers were openly selling a video at Birmingham’s Central Mosque after the busy Friday prayers showing the chilling “last will and testament” of one of the September 11 hijackers. Duly impressed, a couple of years later four British Muslims carried out suicide-attacks on London transport killing 52 fellow-Britons and injuring hundreds.
When Abu Musab al Zarqawi was killed in Iraq a week ago, Pakistani parliamentarians belonging to Islamist parties demanded that the National Assembly hold a condolence meeting. The country’s Urdu newspapers are referring to Zarqawi as a martyr for Islam (shaheed). There have been demonstrations in the Palestinian territories hailing him as a hero.
Arabic Islamist chat rooms claim that Zarqawi is in heaven. One wrote: “Oh God, make heaven celebrate his arrival there.” “Oh Allah, reunite us with Abu Musab al Zarqawi in the great paradise alongside Prophet Muhammad [peace be upon him],” wrote another. “Farewell, oh hero,” said an unsigned poem. “We hope to meet you in ... a paradise filled with rivers and sweetness /And beautiful virgins that beckon to us in a unique voice.”
The subject of these fulsome tributes was a man whose barbarity knew no bounds. Zarqawi’s achievements included the “horribly grotesque” beheading of the Jewish-American businessman Nick Berg, in May 2004, publicised in his promotional video titled Sheikh Abu Musab Zarqawi Slaughters an American Infidel.
In another video released by Zarqawi, to quote Paul McGeogh, an award-winning Australian journalist critical of the American occupation of Iraq, “the world was forced to hold its breath as two Americans and a British hostage pleaded for their lives, before Zarqawi himself, according to CIA analysis of the web footage, callously cut the throats of the struggling Americans. Then he roughly decapitated them, holding the heads up for the cameras — and, with a nonchalant twist of the knife, gouged out one of the victim’s eyes.”
A week later, another video showed the British, 62-year-old Kenneth Bigley, “shackled and kneeling in a cage” pleading for his life, but in vain.
The very people who openly or secretly admire Zarqawi will, at the appropriate forums, cite the Quranic verse to the effect that the killing of even one innocent person is tantamount to the killing of all mankind and to emphasise that Islam literally means peace. Those who will not allow any differences of opinion or interpretation even within the Muslim community convene and attend what are called inter-faith dialogues with followers of other faiths, some of whom they regard as errant or misguided and others as evil and sinful.
Muslim clerics freely refer to Muslims leaders who incur their displeasure as taghout (infidels) or Kafir and to followers of all sects other than their own as heretical (bid’ah). Sh’ias are now fair game in Pakistan and the target of a merciless terror campaign in Iraq. In a letter, Zarqawi, the chief of Al Qaeda in Iraq, referred to the Shi’as with his characteristic bluntness: “They are the insurmountable obstacle, the lurking snake, the crafty and malicious scorpion and the penetrating venom ... they are the enemy ... the bone in [our] throats.”
Such is the Salafist doctrine which is gaining popularity among Muslims. Besides rejecting any genuine attempt at understanding, accommodation, coexistence and ijtehad, Salafism bars all joyous pursuits and entertainment (including most games, films and music.
In the heartland of Islam, namely, Saudi Arabia, women can neither vote nor drive, and alleged criminals routinely have their hands, feet and heads chopped off in public squares; in Iran, the Ayatollahs will not allow women to watch men playing soccer; and in Taliban-dominated lands (which includes Afghanistan and parts of Pakistan), alleged criminals have been stoned to death. Here, even fully veiled women cannot leave their homes without being chaperoned by a mehram (close male relative).
In Algeria in the 1990s, Salafists carried out a campaign of slitting the throats of anyone they could catch who was accused of supporting the government, including women and children.
Whenever a terrorist outrage occurs in any Muslim country and the victims are ordinary Muslims, we are told that Muslims must never kill Muslims. Even fatwas are issued to that effect. The unspoken and unwritten subtext seems to suggest that it is acceptable for Muslims to kill non-Muslims, provided there is a pretext.
Many Muslims will go to any lengths to migrate to the West, but, to the Salafists, the West is the evil enemy. The American-educated leader of Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood, Syed Qutb, stated that “truth and falsehood cannot coexist on earth ... the liberating struggle of jihad does not cease until all religion belongs to God”.
If that is militant, extremist Islam, determined to conquer or destroy all who follow another creed or beg to differ, other varieties are a hodgepodge of obscurantism, ignorance, mythology and mob mentality.
A quiz programme on a mainstream TV network recently asked the contestants to identify the saint (one out of three mentioned) who for 40 years after his death would shake hands with anybody who visited his grave and greeted him. Whatever that means!
Pakistani Muslims are unable to celebrate Eid ul Fitr on the same day because of differences on the issue of sighting the moon strictly in accordance with tradition.
Hundreds of people, including Muslims, have been jailed, in some cases killed, for alleged blasphemy in the last two decades. In one such case about a year ago, the accused included five children, aged between nine and 13. In 2002, one Zahid of Chak Jhumra, a mentally ill person, was stoned to death for blasphemy by a mob instigated by a maulvi after being set free by a court.
Rapists have escaped prosecution for lack of “eye-witnesses” as required by traditional Muslim law. But many victims, including a blind woman who became pregnant as a consequence of being raped, have been convicted of adultery or fornication.
I wonder what the venerable Justices Munir and Kayani would have said about the present state of the ummah. An incongruity wrapped in absurdity?
The writer can be contacted at raziazmi@hotmail.com
Comment: Isn't it strange that writers like Razi Azmi are never brought to Australia to give public lectures, speak to students in schools and apear on TV. The stupid (corrupt?)officials in the Immigration Department are happy to give visas to 'lecturers' from Saudi Arabia and Egypt so that the poisonous fascism of Wahhabi/Salafist Islam can be preached in Australia; but sensible men like Razi Azmi are never part of government programs. Strange, eh?
The government is still trying to get a handle on the muslim problem by going through the imams. That is like putting Germany back on its feet in 1948 by using former Nazi officials. The Nazis were the cause of the problems; the imams are the cause of the Islamic problems.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
This takeover is with the full support of the Federal and State governments in Australia. You don't have to be a muslim to be an idiot in relation to Islam.
Read and be warned...
Thursday, June 15, 2006
THINKING ALOUD: ‘An archaic incongruity’? — Razi Azmi
Whenever a terrorist outrage occurs in any Muslim country and the victims are ordinary Muslims, we are told that Muslims must never kill Muslims. Even fatwas are issued to that effect. The unspoken and unwritten subtext seems to suggest that it is acceptable for Muslims to kill non-Muslims, provided there is a pretext
In their nearly 400-page Report of the Court of Inquiry into the Punjab Disturbances of 1953, popularly known as the Munir Report, two eminently learned Pakistani judges, Chief Justice Muhammad Munir and Justice MR Kayani had concluded, after 117 sittings, perusing 3,600 pages of written statements and sifting through 2,700 pages of evidence over eight months:
“Nothing but a bold reorientation of Islam to separate the vital from the lifeless can preserve it as a world idea and convert the Musalman into a citizen of the present and the future world from the archaic incongruity that he is today.”
Has anything changed since this bold statement was made by the justices over half a century ago?
Seventeen Canadian Muslims, five of whom are teenagers, were arrested earlier this month in Toronto for conspiring to carry out terrorist attacks in the very country which not only hosted and nurtured them but is also considered a model of multiculturalism and tolerance. Indeed, the province of Ontario recently came close to allowing Muslims to be governed by their own Sharia courts instead of secular civil courts.
At least six of those arrested regularly attended the same mosque in a middle-class Toronto suburb. The oldest, Qayyum Abdul Jamal, 43, is said to be an active member of the mosque who frequently led prayers and made fiery speeches.
In England, another bastion of multiculturism with a massive and thriving Muslim presence, less than a year after 9/11 Al Qaeda sympathisers were openly selling a video at Birmingham’s Central Mosque after the busy Friday prayers showing the chilling “last will and testament” of one of the September 11 hijackers. Duly impressed, a couple of years later four British Muslims carried out suicide-attacks on London transport killing 52 fellow-Britons and injuring hundreds.
When Abu Musab al Zarqawi was killed in Iraq a week ago, Pakistani parliamentarians belonging to Islamist parties demanded that the National Assembly hold a condolence meeting. The country’s Urdu newspapers are referring to Zarqawi as a martyr for Islam (shaheed). There have been demonstrations in the Palestinian territories hailing him as a hero.
Arabic Islamist chat rooms claim that Zarqawi is in heaven. One wrote: “Oh God, make heaven celebrate his arrival there.” “Oh Allah, reunite us with Abu Musab al Zarqawi in the great paradise alongside Prophet Muhammad [peace be upon him],” wrote another. “Farewell, oh hero,” said an unsigned poem. “We hope to meet you in ... a paradise filled with rivers and sweetness /And beautiful virgins that beckon to us in a unique voice.”
The subject of these fulsome tributes was a man whose barbarity knew no bounds. Zarqawi’s achievements included the “horribly grotesque” beheading of the Jewish-American businessman Nick Berg, in May 2004, publicised in his promotional video titled Sheikh Abu Musab Zarqawi Slaughters an American Infidel.
In another video released by Zarqawi, to quote Paul McGeogh, an award-winning Australian journalist critical of the American occupation of Iraq, “the world was forced to hold its breath as two Americans and a British hostage pleaded for their lives, before Zarqawi himself, according to CIA analysis of the web footage, callously cut the throats of the struggling Americans. Then he roughly decapitated them, holding the heads up for the cameras — and, with a nonchalant twist of the knife, gouged out one of the victim’s eyes.”
A week later, another video showed the British, 62-year-old Kenneth Bigley, “shackled and kneeling in a cage” pleading for his life, but in vain.
The very people who openly or secretly admire Zarqawi will, at the appropriate forums, cite the Quranic verse to the effect that the killing of even one innocent person is tantamount to the killing of all mankind and to emphasise that Islam literally means peace. Those who will not allow any differences of opinion or interpretation even within the Muslim community convene and attend what are called inter-faith dialogues with followers of other faiths, some of whom they regard as errant or misguided and others as evil and sinful.
Muslim clerics freely refer to Muslims leaders who incur their displeasure as taghout (infidels) or Kafir and to followers of all sects other than their own as heretical (bid’ah). Sh’ias are now fair game in Pakistan and the target of a merciless terror campaign in Iraq. In a letter, Zarqawi, the chief of Al Qaeda in Iraq, referred to the Shi’as with his characteristic bluntness: “They are the insurmountable obstacle, the lurking snake, the crafty and malicious scorpion and the penetrating venom ... they are the enemy ... the bone in [our] throats.”
Such is the Salafist doctrine which is gaining popularity among Muslims. Besides rejecting any genuine attempt at understanding, accommodation, coexistence and ijtehad, Salafism bars all joyous pursuits and entertainment (including most games, films and music.
In the heartland of Islam, namely, Saudi Arabia, women can neither vote nor drive, and alleged criminals routinely have their hands, feet and heads chopped off in public squares; in Iran, the Ayatollahs will not allow women to watch men playing soccer; and in Taliban-dominated lands (which includes Afghanistan and parts of Pakistan), alleged criminals have been stoned to death. Here, even fully veiled women cannot leave their homes without being chaperoned by a mehram (close male relative).
In Algeria in the 1990s, Salafists carried out a campaign of slitting the throats of anyone they could catch who was accused of supporting the government, including women and children.
Whenever a terrorist outrage occurs in any Muslim country and the victims are ordinary Muslims, we are told that Muslims must never kill Muslims. Even fatwas are issued to that effect. The unspoken and unwritten subtext seems to suggest that it is acceptable for Muslims to kill non-Muslims, provided there is a pretext.
Many Muslims will go to any lengths to migrate to the West, but, to the Salafists, the West is the evil enemy. The American-educated leader of Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood, Syed Qutb, stated that “truth and falsehood cannot coexist on earth ... the liberating struggle of jihad does not cease until all religion belongs to God”.
If that is militant, extremist Islam, determined to conquer or destroy all who follow another creed or beg to differ, other varieties are a hodgepodge of obscurantism, ignorance, mythology and mob mentality.
A quiz programme on a mainstream TV network recently asked the contestants to identify the saint (one out of three mentioned) who for 40 years after his death would shake hands with anybody who visited his grave and greeted him. Whatever that means!
Pakistani Muslims are unable to celebrate Eid ul Fitr on the same day because of differences on the issue of sighting the moon strictly in accordance with tradition.
Hundreds of people, including Muslims, have been jailed, in some cases killed, for alleged blasphemy in the last two decades. In one such case about a year ago, the accused included five children, aged between nine and 13. In 2002, one Zahid of Chak Jhumra, a mentally ill person, was stoned to death for blasphemy by a mob instigated by a maulvi after being set free by a court.
Rapists have escaped prosecution for lack of “eye-witnesses” as required by traditional Muslim law. But many victims, including a blind woman who became pregnant as a consequence of being raped, have been convicted of adultery or fornication.
I wonder what the venerable Justices Munir and Kayani would have said about the present state of the ummah. An incongruity wrapped in absurdity?
The writer can be contacted at raziazmi@hotmail.com
Comment: Isn't it strange that writers like Razi Azmi are never brought to Australia to give public lectures, speak to students in schools and apear on TV. The stupid (corrupt?)officials in the Immigration Department are happy to give visas to 'lecturers' from Saudi Arabia and Egypt so that the poisonous fascism of Wahhabi/Salafist Islam can be preached in Australia; but sensible men like Razi Azmi are never part of government programs. Strange, eh?
The government is still trying to get a handle on the muslim problem by going through the imams. That is like putting Germany back on its feet in 1948 by using former Nazi officials. The Nazis were the cause of the problems; the imams are the cause of the Islamic problems.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Saturday, June 17, 2006
Pope Benedict Supports Reform Of Islam, Especially In Education.
Note: This post is part of an article concerning the upcoming visit to Turkey by Pope Benedict in November 2006. The Pope is one of the leading voices in promoting the proper reform of Islam, especially the Islam of the muslims in Europe. In the end the muslims in Europe and Australia have no choice but to dramatically reform their local Islam; without it, they will continue to be marginalised (which is not good for them)and eventually they will be expelled. This is the way of History.
"But on that trip, which includes stops in Ankara and Ephesus in addition to Istanbul, Benedict XVI will also encounter Islam, and Turkish Islam in particular.
And the pope made statements of significant interest on this topic in recent days.
He made them while receiving in private audience the president of North Rhine-Westphalia, Jürgen Rüttgers, who later related the pope’s comments during an interview with Vatican Radio.
Around a million Muslims live in North Rhine-Westphalia, most of them having come from Turkey.
Jürgen Rüttgers said that Benedict XVI “holds that it is very important for Muslim children to have the opportunity to attend in our schools an hour of instruction, in German, in the Muslim religion, with teachers who have been trained in Germany and under school supervision.”
And not only that: “The Holy Father vigorously called attention back to the necessity for every society to live on the basis of values. These are the same values found in the German constitution, which are founded on the Jewish-Christian West and the Enlightenment.” A positive integration of the new Muslim generations “presupposes the recognition of the rules of the federal Republic.”
It is interesting to link these affirmations from Benedict XVI to the controversy unleashed last March by a statement by cardinal Renato Martino in favor of the teaching of the Muslim religion in the schools in Europe.
Benedict XVI also says he is in favor of this instruction. But he joins it to precise conditions, which Martino ignored.
They are the same conditions to which cardinal Camillo Ruini referred when speaking on the controversy: “in particular it is necessary that there not be any conflict in the content of the instruction with respect to our constitution, for example with regard to civil rights, from religious freedom to the equality between man and woman to marriage”.
It is well known that pope Ratzinger sees in this instruction a decisive vehicle for the integration of Muslims into Western society. He said so in no uncertain terms on August 20, 2006, while meeting with German representatives of Islam in Cologne:
“You guide Muslim believers and train them in the Islamic faith. Teaching is the vehicle through which ideas and convictions are transmitted. Words are highly influential in the education of the mind. You, therefore, have a great responsibility for the formation of the younger generation. As Christians and Muslims, we must face together the many challenges of our time.”
By coincidence, in recent days in Italy an authoritative Muslim thinker of Algerian origin recently elected to the Italian parliament, professor Khaled Fouad Allam, advanced a proposal that has much in common with the hopes of Benedict XVI.
In a June 14 interview with the daily “il Foglio,” Allam said:
“We must think of a future cycle of education for Italian and European Muslim students that has their faith at heart. And not an exported faith, but one that has been reformulated, because living in Rome or Venice is not the same thing as living in their countries of origin. I am thinking of an Islamic faith that has internalized the principles of humanism and the modern West: the theology that intellectuals like Abdennour Bidar have been reflecting on for years in Turkey, a country that looks toward Europe. One can imagine the creation of a three-year cycle of studies in Italy and Europe, and a two-year cycle of specialization in one of the Muslim countries that adhere to the initiative.”
Comment: It is clearly necessary for a reformed Islam to be taught to local Australian muslims; not in islamic schools(there should not be any), but in state schools. This is not for our benefit, but for the benefit of the muslims.
There is not any equivalence between muslim schools and the catholic school system in Australia. Catholicism is integral to the 'way of life' in Australia, along with other influences. The catholic school system has produced generations of Australians at all levels from Prime Ministers to garbage collectors. There is no 'disconnect' between the values taught in catholic schools and the common mainstream values that are current in Australia.
The same cannot be said for Islam. Koranic Islamic values are not mainstream Australian values, and we are right to dismiss them from our communal life. Therefore it is not in Australia's national interest for muslim children to be educated in them.(If adult muslims want to acquire these values, let them do so, on their own time and expense.) Koranic Islamic values are not a benefit to Australia.
All education in every country is to produce citizens who are properly integrated into that country and its social norms. This principle should be publiclly adherred to by the authorities and, for the integrational benefit of muslim children, they should be educated in state schools.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
"But on that trip, which includes stops in Ankara and Ephesus in addition to Istanbul, Benedict XVI will also encounter Islam, and Turkish Islam in particular.
And the pope made statements of significant interest on this topic in recent days.
He made them while receiving in private audience the president of North Rhine-Westphalia, Jürgen Rüttgers, who later related the pope’s comments during an interview with Vatican Radio.
Around a million Muslims live in North Rhine-Westphalia, most of them having come from Turkey.
Jürgen Rüttgers said that Benedict XVI “holds that it is very important for Muslim children to have the opportunity to attend in our schools an hour of instruction, in German, in the Muslim religion, with teachers who have been trained in Germany and under school supervision.”
And not only that: “The Holy Father vigorously called attention back to the necessity for every society to live on the basis of values. These are the same values found in the German constitution, which are founded on the Jewish-Christian West and the Enlightenment.” A positive integration of the new Muslim generations “presupposes the recognition of the rules of the federal Republic.”
It is interesting to link these affirmations from Benedict XVI to the controversy unleashed last March by a statement by cardinal Renato Martino in favor of the teaching of the Muslim religion in the schools in Europe.
Benedict XVI also says he is in favor of this instruction. But he joins it to precise conditions, which Martino ignored.
They are the same conditions to which cardinal Camillo Ruini referred when speaking on the controversy: “in particular it is necessary that there not be any conflict in the content of the instruction with respect to our constitution, for example with regard to civil rights, from religious freedom to the equality between man and woman to marriage”.
It is well known that pope Ratzinger sees in this instruction a decisive vehicle for the integration of Muslims into Western society. He said so in no uncertain terms on August 20, 2006, while meeting with German representatives of Islam in Cologne:
“You guide Muslim believers and train them in the Islamic faith. Teaching is the vehicle through which ideas and convictions are transmitted. Words are highly influential in the education of the mind. You, therefore, have a great responsibility for the formation of the younger generation. As Christians and Muslims, we must face together the many challenges of our time.”
By coincidence, in recent days in Italy an authoritative Muslim thinker of Algerian origin recently elected to the Italian parliament, professor Khaled Fouad Allam, advanced a proposal that has much in common with the hopes of Benedict XVI.
In a June 14 interview with the daily “il Foglio,” Allam said:
“We must think of a future cycle of education for Italian and European Muslim students that has their faith at heart. And not an exported faith, but one that has been reformulated, because living in Rome or Venice is not the same thing as living in their countries of origin. I am thinking of an Islamic faith that has internalized the principles of humanism and the modern West: the theology that intellectuals like Abdennour Bidar have been reflecting on for years in Turkey, a country that looks toward Europe. One can imagine the creation of a three-year cycle of studies in Italy and Europe, and a two-year cycle of specialization in one of the Muslim countries that adhere to the initiative.”
Comment: It is clearly necessary for a reformed Islam to be taught to local Australian muslims; not in islamic schools(there should not be any), but in state schools. This is not for our benefit, but for the benefit of the muslims.
There is not any equivalence between muslim schools and the catholic school system in Australia. Catholicism is integral to the 'way of life' in Australia, along with other influences. The catholic school system has produced generations of Australians at all levels from Prime Ministers to garbage collectors. There is no 'disconnect' between the values taught in catholic schools and the common mainstream values that are current in Australia.
The same cannot be said for Islam. Koranic Islamic values are not mainstream Australian values, and we are right to dismiss them from our communal life. Therefore it is not in Australia's national interest for muslim children to be educated in them.(If adult muslims want to acquire these values, let them do so, on their own time and expense.) Koranic Islamic values are not a benefit to Australia.
All education in every country is to produce citizens who are properly integrated into that country and its social norms. This principle should be publiclly adherred to by the authorities and, for the integrational benefit of muslim children, they should be educated in state schools.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Friday, June 16, 2006
Educated Voices From Iran.
Note: These four polls were taken from an Iranian site. They are quite interesting and give an indication of the attitudes of computer literate Iranians.
Food for thought...
Is Today's Islam Associated With Terrorism ?
Don't Know 261
Yes, of course 7372
No way 1299
Total votes: 8932
Can Islam, democracy mix ?
Don't Know 420
Yes, of course 1981
No way 5857
Total votes: 8258
Do you believe in separation of religion from state in Iran?
Don't Know 203
Yes, of course 8963
No way 1186
Total votes: 10352
After 1400 years Islam's present in Iran, how do you rate it?
Don't Know 669
Not Good 14727
Good 1489
Total votes: 16885
Comment: These results should be thought about seriously.
Food for thought...
Is Today's Islam Associated With Terrorism ?
Don't Know 261
Yes, of course 7372
No way 1299
Total votes: 8932
Can Islam, democracy mix ?
Don't Know 420
Yes, of course 1981
No way 5857
Total votes: 8258
Do you believe in separation of religion from state in Iran?
Don't Know 203
Yes, of course 8963
No way 1186
Total votes: 10352
After 1400 years Islam's present in Iran, how do you rate it?
Don't Know 669
Not Good 14727
Good 1489
Total votes: 16885
Comment: These results should be thought about seriously.
Thursday, June 15, 2006
Islamic Vandalism.
Note: Read this post and the one under it. Islam is just too much trouble to be bothered with...why does Australia take on this headache.
Turkey erases artifacts of jahiliyya (the pre-Islamic period of ignorance) while attempting to join the jahili EU. From AP, with thanks to all who sent this in:
ANKARA, Turkey -- Turkey's Islamic-rooted government has ordered a 500-year old Latin inscription believed to have been carved by the Knights of St. John erased from an old castle, newspaper reports said Tuesday.
In the written order, the Culture Minister told museum officials to scrape away the inscription "Inde deus abest," or "Where God does not exist," carved at the entrance to the dungeon of the Castle of St. Peter in the Aegean resort of Bodrum, Hurriyet, Sabah and Milliyet newspapers reported Tuesday.
The ministry claimed the inscription had no historical value, the papers said....
The move comes at a time when Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's government is under criticism for alleged attempts to raise Islam's profile in predominantly Muslim but secular Turkey. The government denies it has an Islamic agenda.
The sign could be considered offensive to devout Muslims who believe in God's omnipresence.
Of course, so did the people who carved the inscription. They were making a different point.
"Baffling censorship on 500-year-old inscription," Sabah said in a banner headline.
"500-year-old inscription has no historic value!" read the headline in Milliyet.
The Castle of St. Peter is now a museum of underwater archaeology displaying ship wrecks. The castle's dungeon -- the Gatineau dungeon -- was used as a lockup and torture chamber from 1513 to 1523.
Milliyet said the ministry ordered the inscription erased two months ago. Museum officials had removed a tin plate sign with the English and Turkish translations of "Inde deus abest" and were pondering what to do with the inscription, it said.
"Either we will scrape it away or cover it somehow," the paper quoted museum director Yasar Yildiz as saying.
Comment: Read the post and comment under this one.
Turkey erases artifacts of jahiliyya (the pre-Islamic period of ignorance) while attempting to join the jahili EU. From AP, with thanks to all who sent this in:
ANKARA, Turkey -- Turkey's Islamic-rooted government has ordered a 500-year old Latin inscription believed to have been carved by the Knights of St. John erased from an old castle, newspaper reports said Tuesday.
In the written order, the Culture Minister told museum officials to scrape away the inscription "Inde deus abest," or "Where God does not exist," carved at the entrance to the dungeon of the Castle of St. Peter in the Aegean resort of Bodrum, Hurriyet, Sabah and Milliyet newspapers reported Tuesday.
The ministry claimed the inscription had no historical value, the papers said....
The move comes at a time when Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's government is under criticism for alleged attempts to raise Islam's profile in predominantly Muslim but secular Turkey. The government denies it has an Islamic agenda.
The sign could be considered offensive to devout Muslims who believe in God's omnipresence.
Of course, so did the people who carved the inscription. They were making a different point.
"Baffling censorship on 500-year-old inscription," Sabah said in a banner headline.
"500-year-old inscription has no historic value!" read the headline in Milliyet.
The Castle of St. Peter is now a museum of underwater archaeology displaying ship wrecks. The castle's dungeon -- the Gatineau dungeon -- was used as a lockup and torture chamber from 1513 to 1523.
Milliyet said the ministry ordered the inscription erased two months ago. Museum officials had removed a tin plate sign with the English and Turkish translations of "Inde deus abest" and were pondering what to do with the inscription, it said.
"Either we will scrape it away or cover it somehow," the paper quoted museum director Yasar Yildiz as saying.
Comment: Read the post and comment under this one.
Real Islam Always Means Real Vandalism.
Note: The spread of Islam in the West will bring this cultural problem to the fore. The problem will not grab the popular mind in the West until some truely major art work is destroyed by muslims. This is the price we will have to pay; Westerners are invariably stupidly slow to realise the significance of the 'rising temperature'. Just like the frog in the pot.
Read this and think...
Jihad Watch Board Vice President Hugh Fitzgerald discusses the threat to Western art posed by the Islamization of Europe:
Already statues have been vandalized by Muslims in public places, and in churches, in both France and Italy. The destruction of the monuments and artifacts and hence part of the histories of Infidels, that so many Christians, Jews, Zoroastrians, Hindus, and Buddhists in the Middle East, in North Africa, in the Balkans and southeastern Europe, in Central Asia and Hindustan and in southeast Asia know well, now has come to Western Europe.
What will happen in Italy, where every street corner in Rome has something that could be damaged by determined Muslims? What will happen to the churches, to the frescoes (including that which Muslims have been taped planning to destroy in Bologna), to the paintings in the Louvre, the Prado, the National Gallery, the Rijksmuseum, the Alte Pinakothek, the Uffizi? Has any organized association of museum curators, or of art scholars, even dared to think of organizing a conference on the protection of art in Europe, and the prohibitions of Islam against sculpture of all kinds, against paintings of living creatures?
Is anyone at all thinking about this, and contacting others? What about Philippe de Montebello or J. Carter Brown or Anne d'Harnoncourt or any other museum directors or retired directors, or any celebrated collectors, or those who already belong to such groups as Save Venice or Save Florence or FAI or Save Art here and there and everywhere? What about those who fund foundations that will pay to rescue Roman mosaics from the rising man-made floods that covered Zeugma, or the Temples near Aswan, but have a new kind of inundation to deal with, the flood-tide of Islam's adherents, who to the extent that they take their Islam seriously, can only threaten Western art, as they once not only threatened, but managed to destroy, so much of Christian, Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, Greco-Bactrian monuments, stupas, manuscripts, temples, artifacts, to erase, or to appropriate as their own, the signs and symbols of anything pre-Islamic or non-Islamic?
Comment: Real Islam always means an attack on Western cultural artifacts. we all remember the destruction of the ancient staues of Buddha in Afghanistan. That was Real Islam at work. Don't ever forget that.
You see small examples of this backward muslim culture at work in Australian schools where the Education Department cravenly allow some muslim pupils to avoid music classes and school concerts, due to some crazed Islamic notions about music.
Australia has a culture that is superior to that of the muslims who came here...if not, why did they come? Our superior culture is the foundation of our successful life in Australia, just as their failed Islamic culture is the basis of their failed lives in 'the old country'. The function of education in Australia is to prepare all the pupils for life and work in Australia. This can only be successful if the pupils absorb the Australian culture that is available here.
Muslims should be let know that Australia is not just Centrelink and Medicare.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Read this and think...
Jihad Watch Board Vice President Hugh Fitzgerald discusses the threat to Western art posed by the Islamization of Europe:
Already statues have been vandalized by Muslims in public places, and in churches, in both France and Italy. The destruction of the monuments and artifacts and hence part of the histories of Infidels, that so many Christians, Jews, Zoroastrians, Hindus, and Buddhists in the Middle East, in North Africa, in the Balkans and southeastern Europe, in Central Asia and Hindustan and in southeast Asia know well, now has come to Western Europe.
What will happen in Italy, where every street corner in Rome has something that could be damaged by determined Muslims? What will happen to the churches, to the frescoes (including that which Muslims have been taped planning to destroy in Bologna), to the paintings in the Louvre, the Prado, the National Gallery, the Rijksmuseum, the Alte Pinakothek, the Uffizi? Has any organized association of museum curators, or of art scholars, even dared to think of organizing a conference on the protection of art in Europe, and the prohibitions of Islam against sculpture of all kinds, against paintings of living creatures?
Is anyone at all thinking about this, and contacting others? What about Philippe de Montebello or J. Carter Brown or Anne d'Harnoncourt or any other museum directors or retired directors, or any celebrated collectors, or those who already belong to such groups as Save Venice or Save Florence or FAI or Save Art here and there and everywhere? What about those who fund foundations that will pay to rescue Roman mosaics from the rising man-made floods that covered Zeugma, or the Temples near Aswan, but have a new kind of inundation to deal with, the flood-tide of Islam's adherents, who to the extent that they take their Islam seriously, can only threaten Western art, as they once not only threatened, but managed to destroy, so much of Christian, Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, Greco-Bactrian monuments, stupas, manuscripts, temples, artifacts, to erase, or to appropriate as their own, the signs and symbols of anything pre-Islamic or non-Islamic?
Comment: Real Islam always means an attack on Western cultural artifacts. we all remember the destruction of the ancient staues of Buddha in Afghanistan. That was Real Islam at work. Don't ever forget that.
You see small examples of this backward muslim culture at work in Australian schools where the Education Department cravenly allow some muslim pupils to avoid music classes and school concerts, due to some crazed Islamic notions about music.
Australia has a culture that is superior to that of the muslims who came here...if not, why did they come? Our superior culture is the foundation of our successful life in Australia, just as their failed Islamic culture is the basis of their failed lives in 'the old country'. The function of education in Australia is to prepare all the pupils for life and work in Australia. This can only be successful if the pupils absorb the Australian culture that is available here.
Muslims should be let know that Australia is not just Centrelink and Medicare.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Wednesday, June 14, 2006
Wrong! Wrong! Wrong!
Note: The Queensland government must not pander to the demands of criminals. Being a muslim criminal does not entitle a person to extra consideration. These events can happen because the rules allow this leeway. Better to change the rules rather than have to constantly be going to Appeals Courts.
"A Muslim prisoner successfully sued a state government in Australia $2,000 dollars because the halal meat he was given in jail was not fresh, authorities have said.
The Queensland government said it would appeal the ruling, handed down last month by the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal, saying it could set a costly precedent.
State Corrective Services Minister Judy Spence said the man, who was serving an eight year prison term for a child sex offence, had been given tinned halal meat because fresh meat slaughtered according to Islamic traditions had been too expensive and difficult to source.
"So the prison authorities made the compromise and bought him tinned halal meat, but he complained that it was too salty and too fatty," she told national radio.
"I'm very concerned that this decision could open the floodgates to other prisoners requesting all manner of special diets," Spence added, and said the state government would appeal the decision".
Comment: The Queensland government made its first mistake when it bought into the myth that Islam is a religion...it is a political movement, especially in its more virulent 'islamist' form.
Prisons in Australia are rife with muslims mafias. Aboriginal Australians are particularly vulnerable to the attractions of this mafia. (Considering how atrociously they have been treated over the years by mainstream Australia, I am not surprised they would find an anti-Australian force attractive.)
The only safe way to deal with muslims in prison is to put them on a vegetarian diet,that is, if they don't want the ordinary diet available to the other prisoners, and keep them isolated from the non muslim others. Keep all muslim writings out of their hands, including the koran. These writings are an incitement to them and it is not in Australia's interest to incite them.
The political movement called Islam is now in a violent phase; violent toward the West and that includes Australia.
It is time for the government of Queensland to come back to Earth on the question of Islam and muslims.
Is anyone awake in Brisbane?
"A Muslim prisoner successfully sued a state government in Australia $2,000 dollars because the halal meat he was given in jail was not fresh, authorities have said.
The Queensland government said it would appeal the ruling, handed down last month by the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal, saying it could set a costly precedent.
State Corrective Services Minister Judy Spence said the man, who was serving an eight year prison term for a child sex offence, had been given tinned halal meat because fresh meat slaughtered according to Islamic traditions had been too expensive and difficult to source.
"So the prison authorities made the compromise and bought him tinned halal meat, but he complained that it was too salty and too fatty," she told national radio.
"I'm very concerned that this decision could open the floodgates to other prisoners requesting all manner of special diets," Spence added, and said the state government would appeal the decision".
Comment: The Queensland government made its first mistake when it bought into the myth that Islam is a religion...it is a political movement, especially in its more virulent 'islamist' form.
Prisons in Australia are rife with muslims mafias. Aboriginal Australians are particularly vulnerable to the attractions of this mafia. (Considering how atrociously they have been treated over the years by mainstream Australia, I am not surprised they would find an anti-Australian force attractive.)
The only safe way to deal with muslims in prison is to put them on a vegetarian diet,that is, if they don't want the ordinary diet available to the other prisoners, and keep them isolated from the non muslim others. Keep all muslim writings out of their hands, including the koran. These writings are an incitement to them and it is not in Australia's interest to incite them.
The political movement called Islam is now in a violent phase; violent toward the West and that includes Australia.
It is time for the government of Queensland to come back to Earth on the question of Islam and muslims.
Is anyone awake in Brisbane?
Tuesday, June 13, 2006
Reformist Muslims Slowly Gaining Strength.
Note: This site tries to be very fair...give credit where it is due. This post from Pakistan, a really serious source of Islamic jihadist terrorism and general muslim backwardness, shows that reformist muslims are 'fighting the good fight' (as St.Paul urged)and are standing against the REAL ISLAM to push modernity forward in that backward Islamic country. More strength to them!
Five girls saved from ‘penalty marriages’
KARACHI, June 12: Five girls whose parents were ordered by a recent jirga in Haji Kamal Magsi village near Thul to hand them over in ‘marriage’ to a rival family to settle a long-drawn feud over a murder must have heaved a sigh of relief on Monday when the jirga verdict was declared unlawful.
The decision to annul the verdict was taken at a meeting presided over by Sindh Chief Minister Dr Arbab Ghulam Rahim, who took the opportunity to criticise PPP legislator Mir Hazar Khan Bijarani for allegedly taking part in the jirga and being a party to the controversial decision.
The MNA from Jacobabad distanced himself from the jirga decision on Sunday when he told a press conference that he had taken part in a reconciliation meeting, and not a jirga, to help two groups of the Banglani clan to which he belonged, to bury the hatchet. Mr Bijarani earned the criticism of the Sindh chief minister for not attending the Monday meeting to which he had been called.
Dr Rahim asked the Kashmore district’s top police officer to find out why the jirga was allowed to be held. He said an FIR should be registered in the murder case.—Agencies.
Comment: Australian authorities should take far more interest in the local Australian slave trade (aka marriages between muslims in Australia and muslims from backward places like Pakistan.)
This particular saga of the 'marriage racket' deserves a complete investigation in the light of Australian marriage norms. If it was done, the story would be very sad and dirty.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Five girls saved from ‘penalty marriages’
KARACHI, June 12: Five girls whose parents were ordered by a recent jirga in Haji Kamal Magsi village near Thul to hand them over in ‘marriage’ to a rival family to settle a long-drawn feud over a murder must have heaved a sigh of relief on Monday when the jirga verdict was declared unlawful.
The decision to annul the verdict was taken at a meeting presided over by Sindh Chief Minister Dr Arbab Ghulam Rahim, who took the opportunity to criticise PPP legislator Mir Hazar Khan Bijarani for allegedly taking part in the jirga and being a party to the controversial decision.
The MNA from Jacobabad distanced himself from the jirga decision on Sunday when he told a press conference that he had taken part in a reconciliation meeting, and not a jirga, to help two groups of the Banglani clan to which he belonged, to bury the hatchet. Mr Bijarani earned the criticism of the Sindh chief minister for not attending the Monday meeting to which he had been called.
Dr Rahim asked the Kashmore district’s top police officer to find out why the jirga was allowed to be held. He said an FIR should be registered in the murder case.—Agencies.
Comment: Australian authorities should take far more interest in the local Australian slave trade (aka marriages between muslims in Australia and muslims from backward places like Pakistan.)
This particular saga of the 'marriage racket' deserves a complete investigation in the light of Australian marriage norms. If it was done, the story would be very sad and dirty.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)