Thursday, July 13, 2006

British Trouble With Muslims Is Warning For Australia.

Note: This article was originally published in the London Telegraph, a major and serious British newspaper. It was later put on the paper's website and then taken down under pressure from muslims.

The problems being outlined by Dr.Sookhdeo are similar to what will happen in Australia unless the necessary 'Three Part Policy' is adopted.

Any chance of getting Dr. Sookhdeo out to Australia for a lecture tour?

Read and be concerned...





News : ENGLAND: The day is coming when British Muslims form a state within a state
Posted by David Virtue on 2006/2/21 11:30:00 (14609 reads)
ENGLAND: The day is coming when British Muslims form a state within a state

By Alasdair Palmer
The Telegraph Group
February 19, 2006

For the past two weeks, Patrick Sookhdeo has been canvassing the opinions of Muslim clerics in Britain on the row over the cartoons featuring images of Mohammed that were first published in Denmark and then reprinted in several other European countries.

"They think they have won the debate," he says with a sigh. "They believe that the British Government has capitulated to them, because it feared the consequences if it did not.

"The cartoons, you see, have not been published in this country, and the Government has been very critical of those countries in which they were published. To many of the Islamic clerics, that's a clear victory.

"It's confirmation of what they believe to be a familiar pattern: if spokesmen for British Muslims threaten what they call 'adverse consequences' - violence to the rest of us - then the British Government will cave in. I think it is a very dangerous precedent."

Dr Sookhdeo adds that he believes that "in a decade, you will see parts of English cities which are controlled by Muslim clerics and which follow, not the common law, but aspects of Muslim sharia law.

"It is already starting to happen - and unless the Government changes the way it treats the so-called leaders of the Islamic community, it will continue."

For someone with such strong and uncompromising views, Dr Sookhdeo is a surprisingly gentle and easy-going man. He speaks with authority on Islam, as it was his first faith: he was brought up as a Muslim in Guyana, the only English colony in South America, and attended a madrassa there.

"But Islamic instruction was very different in the 1950s, when I was at school," he says. "There was no talk of suicide bombing or indeed of violence of any kind. Islam was very peaceful."

Dr Sookhdeo's family emigrated to England when he was 10. In his early twenties, when he was at university, he converted to Christianity. "I had simply seen it as the white man's religion, the religion of the colonialists and the oppressors - in a very similar way, in fact, to the way that many Muslims see Christianity today.

" Leaving Islam was not easy. According to the literal interpretation of the Koran, the punishment for apostasy is death - and it actually is punished by death in some Middle Eastern states. "It wasn't quite like that here," he says, "although it was traumatic in some ways."

Dr Sookhdeo continued to study Islam, doing a PhD at London University on the religion. He is currently director of the Institute for the Study of Islam and Christianity. He also advises the Army on security issues related to Islam.

Several years ago, Dr Sookhdeo insisted that the next wave of radical Islam in Britain would involve suicide bombings in this country. His prediction was depressingly confirmed on 7/7 last year.

So his claim that, in the next decade, the Muslim community in Britain will not be integrated into mainstream British society, but will isolate itself to a much greater extent, carries weight behind it. Dr Sookhdeo has proved his prescience.

"The Government, and Tony Blair, the Prime Minister, are fundamentally deluded about the nature of Islam," he insists. "Tony Blair unintentionally revealed his ignorance when he said, in an effort to conciliate Muslims, that he had 'read through the Koran twice' and that he kept it by his bedside.

"He thought he was saying something which showed how seriously he took Islam. But most Muslims thought it was a joke, if not an insult. Because, of course, every Muslim knows that you cannot read the Koran through from cover to cover and understand it.

The chapters are not written to be read in that way. Indeed, after the first chapter, the chapters of the Koran are ordered according to their length, not according to their content or chronology: the longest chapters are first, the shorter ones are at the end.

"You need to know which passage was revealed at what period and in what time in order to be able to understand it - you cannot simply read it from beginning to end and expect to learn anything at all.

"That is one reason why it takes so long to be able to read and understand the Koran: the meaning of any part of it depends on a knowledge of its context - a context that is not in the Koran itself."

The Prime Minister's ignorance of Islam, Dr Sookhdeo contends, is of a piece with his unsuccessful attempts to conciliate it. And it does indeed seem as if the Government's policy towards radical Islam is based on the hope that if it makes concessions to its leaders, they will reciprocate and relations between fundamentalist Muslims and Tony Blair's Government will then turn into something resembling an ecumenical prayer meeting.

Dr Sookhdeo nods in vigorous agreement with that. "Yes - and it is a very big mistake. Look at what happened in the 1990s. The security services knew about Abu Hamza and the preachers like him. They knew that London was becoming the centre for Islamic terrorists. The police knew. The Government knew. Yet nothing was done.

"The whole approach towards Muslim militants was based on appeasement. 7/7 proved that that approach does not work - yet it is still being followed. For example, there is a book, The Noble Koran: a New Rendering of its Meaning in English, which is openly available in Muslim bookshops.

"It calls for the killing of Jews and Christians, and it sets out a strategy for killing the infidels and for warfare against them. The Government has done nothing whatever to interfere with the sale of that book.

"Why not? Government ministers have promised to punish religious hatred, to criminalise the glorification of terrorism, yet they do nothing about this book, which blatantly does both."

Perhaps the explanation is just that they do not take it seriously. "I fear that is exactly the problem," says Dr Sookhdeo. "The trouble is that Tony Blair and other ministers see Islam through the prism of their own secular outlook.

They simply do not realise how seriously Muslims take their religion. Islamic clerics regard themselves as locked in mortal combat with secularism.

"For example, one of the fundamental notions of a secular society is the moral importance of freedom, of individual choice. But in Islam, choice is not allowable: there cannot be free choice about whether to choose or reject any of the fundamental aspects of the religion, because they are all divinely ordained. God has laid down the law, and man must obey.

'Islamic clerics do not believe in a society in which Islam is one religion among others in a society ruled by basically non-religious laws. They believe it must be the dominant religion - and it is their aim to achieve this.

"That is why they do not believe in integration. In 1980, the Islamic Council of Europe laid out their strategy for the future - and the fundamental rule was never dilute your presence. That is to say, do not integrate.

"Rather, concentrate Muslim presence in a particular area until you are a majority in that area, so that the institutions of the local community come to reflect Islamic structures. The education system will be Islamic, the shops will serve only halal food, there will be no advertisements showing naked or semi-naked women, and so on."

That plan, says Dr Sookhdeo, is being followed in Britain. "That is why you are seeing areas which are now almost totally Muslim. The next step will be pushing the Government to recognise sharia law for Muslim communities - which will be backed up by the claim that it is "racist" or "Islamophobic" or "violating the rights of Muslims" to deny them sharia law.

"There's already a Sharia Law Council for the UK. The Government has already started making concessions: it has changed the law so that there are sharia-compliant mortgages and sharia pensions.

"Some Muslims are now pressing to be allowed four wives: they say it is part of their religion. They claim that not being allowed four wives is a denial of their religious liberty. There are Muslim men in Britain who marry and divorce three women, then marry a fourth time - and stay married, in sharia law, to all four.

"The more fundamentalist clerics think that it is only a matter of time before they will persuade the Government to concede on the issue of sharia law. Given the Government's record of capitulating, you can see why they believe that."

Dr Sookhdeo's vision of a relentless battle between secular and Islamic Britain seems hard to reconcile with the co-operation that seems to mark the vast majority of the interactions between the two communities.

"Well, it isn't me who says Islam is at war with secularisation," he says. "That's how Islamic clerics describe the situation."

But isn't it true that most Muslims who live in theocratic states want to get out of them as quickly as possible and live in a secular country such as Britain or America? And that most Muslims who come to Britain adopt the values of a liberal, democratic, tolerant society, rather than insisting on the inflexible rules of their religion?

"You have to distinguish between ordinary Muslims and their self-appointed leaders," explains Dr Sookhdeo. "I agree that the best hope for our collective future is that the majority of Muslims who have grown up here have accepted the secular nature of the British state and society, the division between religion and politics, and the importance of allowing people to choose freely how they will live.

"But that is not how most of the clerics talk. And, more significantly, it is not how the 'community leaders' whom the Government has decided represent the Muslim community think either.

"Take, for example, Tariq Ramadan, whom the Government has appointed as an adviser because ministers think he is a 'community leader'. Ramadan sounds, in public, very moderate. But in reality, he has some very extreme views. He attacks liberal Muslims as 'Muslims without Islam'. He is affiliated to the violent and uncompromising Muslim Brotherhood.

"He calls the education in the state schools of the West 'aggression against the Islamic personality of the child'. He has said that 'the Muslim respects the laws of the country only if they do not contradict any Islamic principle'. He has added that 'compromising on principles is a sign of fear and weakness'."

So what's the answer? What should the Government be doing? "First, it should try to engage with the real Muslim majority, not with the self-appointed 'community leaders' who don't actually represent anyone: they have not been elected, and the vast majority of ordinary Muslims have nothing to do with them.

"Second, the Government should say no to faith-based schools, because they are a block to integration. There should be no compromise over education, or over English as the language of education. The policy of political multiculturalism should be reversed.

"The hope was that it would to ensure separate communities would soften at the edges and integrate. But the opposite has in fact happened: Islamic communities have hardened. There is much less integration than there was for the generation that arrived when I did. There will be much less in the future if the present trend continues.

"Finally, the Government should make it absolutely clear: we welcome diversity, we welcome different religions - but all of them have to accept the secular basis of British law and society. That is a non-negotiable condition of being here.

"If the Government does not do all of those things then I fear for the future, because Islamic communities within Britain will form a state within a state. Religion will occupy an ever-larger place in our collective political life. And, speaking as a religious man myself, I fear that outcome."

http://www.opinion.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/02/19/nsharia219.xml Copyright of Telegraph Group Limited 2006.



Comment: This site was pleased to read this article as it is consistent with the 'Three Part Policy' advocated for dealing with the 'Muslim Question' in Australia.

That policy is based on the need to accept the national Australian view which says that the Australian people do not want Australia 'Islamized'; nor do we want to live in some sort of South Pacific Lebanon, 'half Christian/half muslim'.

The three points of the policy are:
Communities...all community organisations can only be lead by elected Executives which comprise muslims who were born and educated in Australia.
Imams...no imams of any type are allowed in Australia. Those here are to be removed whence they came. Mosques will make their own arrangements for prayer leaders, without access to foreigners.
Money...no muslim group is allowed to receive any money from outside Australia without express government permission, which has been notified to Parliament.

This 'Three Part Policy' if adopted, would strengthen the hand of the young and currently excluded muslims born here and who identify as Australians; it would remove the source of the poison in current islam (imams with Wahhabi fascist versions of islam); it would remove any obligations of loyalty to foreign groups, on money grounds,whose interests are not Australia's interests.

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

Wednesday, July 12, 2006

Reformers In Arab Lands Getting Strength.

Note: This posting gives a few site addresses fro new and active reformers in the Arab lands.

Read and be encouraged...





July 12, 2006 No.1202

New Arabic Reformist Website: 'The Arab World Doesn't Have to Choose between Islamists and Dictators; There is a Third Way – the Way of Reform, Liberalism, and Democracy'

In an editorial posted on the new Arabic reformist website www.aafaq.org, the site's editor criticizes Arab governments and elites who show no concern for the sorry state of the Arab world but are instead waiting until the end of the Bush administration's two remaining years so that they can rid themselves of its reform initiatives. The writer goes on to encourage reformist forces in Arab countries to make their voices heard so as not to miss the current historic opportunity for reform in the Middle East.

The following are excerpts from the article: [1]


The Arab Governments Impatiently Await the End of the Bush Administration - So They Can Rid Themselves of Its Reform Initiatives

"Some say that Arab soil produces only Islamist or dictatorial regimes. We say that there is a third way - the way of reform, liberalism, and democracy, which is the way desired by millions of Arab citizens who dream of living in freedom and dignity like other human beings...

"All economic, political, social, and educational statistics reveal that the Arab countries are at the bottom of the list of the world's countries, and that their future is likely to be even worse. Yet this is the last thing that concerns the Arab governments and the intellectual elites who answer to them. What concerns them is [waiting for] the remaining two years of the Bush administration to finally come to an end - and with them the calls for reform and democracy in the Middle East - [so that] despotism may once again reign in this miserable part of the world.

"In another two years, the Arab governments will be able to breathe a sigh of relief. They will no longer hear anyone asking them to change, or imposing reform initiatives on them. They understand that most American politicians are no longer zealous about spreading democracy, and they think that investing in the modernization of the Arabs and in helping them to establish democracy is a waste of money, time, and effort - since Arab soil produces only Islamists or dictatorial regimes.

"Therefore, the Arab governments are impatiently awaiting the day when they can reap the fruits of the policy of evasion and delay, which they have adopted in the past few years to parry the calls for reform. They hope that things will return to normal and that they will once again [be free to] impose their hold on their societies."


"The [Arab] Reformists Think That the Peoples of the Middle East Deserve Better"

"But... the forces of reform and those who demand change have their own agenda. They do not think that the choice must necessarily be between Islamists and dictatorial regimes... The reformists think that the peoples of the region deserve better. They deserve to live in modern countries that respect the right to live in dignity...

"The reformists believe that in the wake of September 11, a historic opportunity for change has emerged - an opportunity that must not be missed like the first opportunity in the early 19th century..."


Arab Societies Have Already Missed an Opportunity for Reform, Instead "Follow[ing] the Dictatorial Military Regimes and... Religious Extremism"

"At that time, there appeared on the horizon a number of figures who wanted to bring enlightenment and renaissance [to the Arab world], like Sheikh Rifa'a Rafi' Al-Tahtawi in Egypt, Khayr Al-Din Al-Tunisi in Tunisia, 'Abd Al-Rahman Al-Kawakibi in Syria, Jamal Al-Din Al-Afghani, Muhammad Abduh, and others. These people dedicated their lives to extracting the Arab societies from backwardness, ignorance, and despotism. They called for modernization, [acquisition of] knowledge, and benefiting from the European model of civil institutions, rule of law, and democracy [as] the form of government.

"Yet the Arab societies missed this opportunity when they ignored the calls of these men of enlightenment and renaissance and [instead] followed the dictatorial military regimes and those who called for religious extremism. These societies had to wait some 200 years before another opportunity for reform came along...

"In response to the attacks of September 11, and in response to the jihad declared by Al-Qaeda on the U.S. in August 1998, the American administration adopted a program for spreading freedom, democracy, and reform in the Middle East, since it believed that this would be the [most] effective treatment against extremism and terrorism in the region. The Americans acted on a number of fronts. They brought down the Taliban regime in Afghanistan and Saddam Hussein's regime in Iraq, and they invested much in establishing democracy in these two countries. They called on the governments of the region to adopt programs for political, economic, and educational reform, and launched many initiatives for local and regional cooperation for encouraging democracy and reform..."


The Forces of Reform and Change in Arab Countries Must Act - So as Not to Miss This Opportunity

"However, as usual, the Arab governments have responded to the challenge in a negative way. Some have rejected it and launched an open struggle against any change, while others have adopted tactics of evasion and delay... The unfortunate thing is that most of the Arab intellectual elites sided with their governments, and chose to stand on the side of despotism and backwardness.

"In order to avoid missing the current opportunity, the forces of reform and change in the Arab countries need to act. They must take the initiative, reinforce their ranks, and make their voices heard..."



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[1] http://www.aafaq.org/content/aa/letter_from_editor.htm. The site www.aafaq.org, launched in June, 2006, joins the ranks of the Arab reformist websites that have begun operating in the past few years, with the aim of promoting reform, liberalism, and democracy in the Arab world. The most prominent of these sites are: www.metransparent.com, www.elaph.com, www.rezgar.com, and www.annaqed.com. Aafaq features articles by Arab reformists, news items and reports on reform and human rights issues, profiles of reformists, video clips from the Arab media, and open forums on topics such as economy, education, society, religion, and politics.



Comment: It is to the great shame of the Australian government that it does absolutely nothing to help reformers and their organisations in the arab and muslim lands. This dumb approach to the real world in which we live also affects muslims in Australia. Waht is wrong with this government?

Tuesday, July 11, 2006

Slowly Freedom Grows.

Note: Clearly the current Government of Malaysia has decided to adopt Western values in relation to religion. That is, you can make your own decisions on these important matters, and if you decide to leave Islam, well, that is your choice.

The Islamic Establishment in Malaysia is very upset and,islamically, does not recognise any such right for any muslim. The figure of 100,000 apostates seems large (muslims generally have trouble with numbers), but even one is entitled to make religious decisions on a personal basis.

Read and learn about 'tolerance, a la Islam'...


Malaysia: Mufti urges action against apostates from Islam
"...even one case of apostasy is serious. Why wait for 100,000? It is as if the issue is not serious among Muslims." Oh, horror of horrors! Islamic Tolerance Alert: "Perak Mufti Takes Jakim To Task Over Apostate Issue," from Bernama, with thanks to wongcheefatt:

IPOH, July 10 (Bernama) -- The Malaysian Islamic Development Department (Jakim) has been asked to be pro-active in investigating the apostate issue in view of its serious nature.
Perak Mufti Datuk Seri Harussani Zakaria Monday said Jakim should have started investigations without waiting for reports from other quarters.

"They (Jakim) are not serious in tackling this issue... even one case of apostasy is serious. Why wait for 100,000? It is as if the issue is not serious among Muslims," he told reporters at his office, here.

"I am prepared to provide a report but please come to see me," he said when asked to comment on the statement by Jakim director-general Datuk Mustafa Abdul Rahman asking those who had conducted a study and found that 100,000 Muslims had become apostates to submit a report to the department.

Minister in the Prime Minister's Department, Datuk Dr Abdullah Md Zin, Sunday had also asked Harussani to substantiate his claim that 100,000 Muslims had become apostates.

Harussani also expressed his disappointment over Jakim's announcement that five serious issues involving Muslims, among them secularism, liberalism and hedonism, which had earlier been brought up at the Rulers Conference, no longer needed to be discussed.




Comment: As a supporter of freedom of religion (which must also include freedom from religion), this site has advocated Australia as a refuge from the mandated persecution, and sometimes death, for apostates from Islam. Wouldn't it be nice to see Australia take a principled stand in favour of freedom, real freedom?

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

Stupid And Backward Mistake.

Note: This stupid and backward mistake will not bring Palestine one millimetre forward. It will be useful to observe the complete support that this absudity gains from the poisonous imams in Palestine and elsewhere, including Australia.




Aksa Brigades announce female suicide bomber unit
Equal opportunity in murder. From the Jerusalem Post:

A group belonging to Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas's Fatah party announced on Monday that it had recruited Palestinian women to launch suicide attacks against Israel.
A woman who identified herself as Um al-Abed told reporters in Gaza City that so far about 100 women had expressed their desire to carry out suicide attacks against Israel. She claimed that she was a spokeswoman for the Aksa Martyrs Brigades, the armed wing of Fatah.
The Aksa Martyrs Brigades, she added, recently established a secret military unit for female suicide bombers from the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Jerusalem. "We have so far recruited 100 women for the new unit," Um al-Abed said as she sat next to several masked women who identified themselves as members of Fatah.
"We are expecting more female suicide bombers. The new unit is now preparing to launch attacks against Israel in response to the Israeli aggression and crimes against our people in the Gaza Strip."
Since September 2000, Palestinian women have carried out seven suicide bombings inside Israel in which 37 people were killed and more than 250 injured. The most serious attack was launched in October 2003 by Hanadi Jaradat, an Islamic Jihad woman from Jenin, who detonated herself at the Maxim Restaurant in Haifa. The attack left 21 civilians dead and 48 wounded.
Four of the female suicide bombers belonged to Fatah, one to Hamas and two to Islamic Jihad.
Um al-Abed also hinted that the group was planning to target Hamas members who are responsible for attacks on Fatah activists. She pointed out that a senior Fatah militiaman, Haitham Rai, was killed over the weekend in Gaza City apparently by Hamas gunmen.
"We know the identity of the murderers and we urge the Palestinian government to take immediate action against them," she said. "If the government fails, the Aksa Martyrs Brigades will punish the Hamas culprits in our own way."


Comment: This decision will be greeted with basically silence in Australian muslim circles. In private the imams will applaud it, but the muslim publications will pass over it in embarrassed silence. No one single muslim in Australia will publiclly denounce this 'crime against humanity'.

Further proof that the government's 'policy' on integration of muslims in Australia is failing.

Monday, July 10, 2006

Another Beautiful Rose In The Arab World.

Note: This posting is about an Egyptian cultural monthly which sounds beautiful. It has recently published a prize winning short story from Israel. This sort of cross cultural movement is a good and healthy sign that the future can actually be positive if enough effort is made by all persons of good will.

Read and be encouraged...

Devil or ally?

By Sasson Somekh

"I was very hesitant when approaching the translation of the story 'Ana min al-yahud' into Arabic. The story is beautiful and interesting, and in my opinion very important because of the possibility inherent in it for understanding contemporary Israeli reality; moreover the story won the prize for the best short story in 2005 from Haaretz, the foremost Israeli publication, a newspaper whose annual prizes are esteemed by the Israeli cultural elite. I hesitated - despite the fact that the writer of the Hebrew story gave it a title in the Arabic language, 'Ana min hayahud' ["I Am From the Jews"], achieved a collective recognition in Israel and he overnight became a star on the cultural front there, and is now one of the outstanding writers published in Haaretz, a newspaper in which many wish to publish, but only talented writers are given the opportunity to do so."



Thus Muhammed Abboud, a researcher of Israel and its culture in Cairo, begins the extensive analysis he devoted to Almog Behar's story in the June issue of the well-known Cairene monthly Al-Hilal ("The Crescent"). Abboud indeed translated the story in full and published it along with an analytical article, and the monthly printed the story and analysis on special yellow paper and devoted the cover of the issue to this subject (the cover shows an ultra-Orthodox yeshiva student reading as he walks). Thus, Almog Behar, a young Jerusalemite poet and storyteller, a student at Hebrew University, has been given an honor the likes of which few Israelis have earned in the past.



The veteran al-Hilal, which has been coming out in Cairo since 1892, is one of the most popular cultural monthlies in Egypt and the Arab world, and many millions in the Middle East have expanded their cultural horizons thanks to its contents. It should be noted that this is not a literary publication, but rather a panoramic one that has tried, since the day it first went to press, to expand the reader's horizons and knowledge, and to endow him with information and criticism about what is happening in the world of culture everywhere, with a certain emphasis on what is happening in Egypt and its neighboring countries. It was founded by an energetic Lebanese immigrant, Jurjy Zeidan, who was a prolific writer and founded, inter alia, a literary monthly that remained in existence for 115 years, while most of the activities of the other Lebanese immigrants, who came to Egypt during the last quarter of the 19th century, sank into oblivion (apart from the daily newspaper Al-Ahram, which was also founded by a Lebanese immigrant at about the same time and continues to appear to this day).



Al-Hilal has preserved its original mission - that is, to expand the reader's cultural horizons - throughout the years, even if during the days of Gamal Abdel Nasser's regime, it was nationalized, together with all the rest of the publications, and for quite a few years it had editors forced upon it who had nationalist and "socialist" ideological tendencies. Fundamentally, however, al-Hilal never relinquished a number of its first intentions.





Spinoza and Einstein

When I was a high-school student in Baghdad, during the late 1940s, I would run to the newsstand in our neighborhood at a regular time each month to buy the new issue of Al-Hilal. Once I bought it I could not wait until I got home, and from reading the table of contents I would rejoice in the feeling that fascinating hours of reading awaited me. I will admit without embarrassment: Much of my knowledge of our contemporary world came to me from the issues of al-Hilal.



I must note that the issue of June 2006, presents, even in these "crazy" times, a secular cultural world whose existence one has difficulty believing, because of the atmosphere of return to orthodoxy in the Arab world in recent years - signs of which are also very evident in daily newspapers and journals that have no connection with the radical religious stream. In this issue, for example, there are articles on the following subjects: "Spinoza and Einstein: The philosopher and the scientist;" "Secularism in Egypt" (this article is written by prominent philosopher Murad Wahba, a leader of the secular stream in Cairo); "The roots of philosophy in Coptic Egypt;" an article by Butrous Butrous Ghali; and many other subjects 1,000 leagues apart from Islamic religious topics.



The article that Abboud has written about Behar's story is called "An outcry against cultural oppression." The aim of his analysis is to illuminate the theme in the folds of the story, which in Abboud's opinion is: I am an Arab Jew and I am oppressed and downtrodden because of the hegemony of the Ashkenazim (Jews of European origin). Abboud's article itself is very deserving of extensive analysis, on the one hand, in order to illustrate the vast knowledge the man has acquired concerning society and culture in Israel and, on the other hand, the mistakes that to a large extent derive from the fact that he has never visited Israel, and from his keenness to prove his own view of the contents of the story. My analysis will, I hope, appear in due course elsewhere.



Tenable interpretation

This interpretation of the text of the story is tenable to some extent, and it is possible to quote sentences and paragraphs of the story that will support such an interpretation. However, anyone who read Almog's story noticed that there is not a trace of protest in it against social or political protest by the Ashkenazim of Jews that came from the countries of the East (that is, not oppression or discrimination in the material sense). The plot of the story is "linguistic,"} above all. The narrator in the story suddenly loses his ability to speak Israeli Hebrew, and thus policemen and passersby suspect him of being an Arab or an Arab terrorist. Now he speaks with the glottal 'ayyin, the guttural het and the Arab tzadi, which is more in the direction of "s" with the tongue raised at the back than the sound "tz," the way his Iraqi grandfather used to speak. In the end, the protagonist infects his wife, who is not of Iraqi origin, and thus the linguistic "disease" spreads in all directions, and even Ashkenazim come down with it.



This summary of the plot does not, of course, do justice to its experiential contents, but it is clear that the protest is against a different injustice: against the coercion of speech (and perhaps also culture) that Mizrahi Israelis (Jews with origins in the Arab countries) did not want, and in the shaping of which they did not participate.



If the story is a protest story, we are dealing with spiritual oppression whose thrust is an attempt to eradicate the Arab-Mizrahi element in the experience of the Jews of the Middle East, and in any case not to include their universe and their memories in the central cultural norm. Anyone who wants to, can talk about hegemonism or even "racism" in the sense of a scornful attitude toward the other's culture and past, but this topic, as noted, deserves a more thorough discussion.



And indeed, the author of the article in al-Hilal was aware (although not to a sufficient extent, in my opinion) of the dangers of imposing a simplistic, one-way, black-and-white interpretation on a story as complex as Behar's. And this is what Abboud writes, after the paragraphs I translated at the start of this article: "My discomfort increased with respect to the question of whether this story - which deals with the problematics of the identity of the Jews who 'immigrated' to Israel from Arab countries - can enlighten us from the perspective of 'Is he for us or against us?' as the story contains the nuclei of many and varied interpretations. Simplistic superficial logic is liable to turn the Hebrew writer into the Devil's incarnation or, alternatively, a friend and ally to Arab culture, and all this because it deals with the oppression that exists in the State of Israel. These two approaches are far from being correct approaches."



However, despite this self-warning, Abboud adds that he, like many of his fellow scholars of Hebrew in Cairo (and they are many!), relates to the literary works that are written in Israel as raw materials from which it is possible to learn and to draw unambiguous conclusions about the "situation" in Israel and its culture. Relating to the artistic text as an aesthetic exhibit with multiple meanings is absent, in the end, from Abboud's fine article.

The translation of the story into Arabic is generally faithful to the original, and it is definitely readable, while Abboud's discussion, even if it is somewhat programmatic, testifies to impressive familiarity with everyday life and the linguistic aspects of the Israeli reality of today. Translation errors are to be found here and there, particularly in the transliteration and translation of the names of places and streets. The Jerusalemite names "Katamon" and "Talbieh," which apparently were incorrectly transliterated, whereas Yordei Hasira Street (literally, "those who came off the boat," referring to the illegal immigrants who came in by ship) is translated into something like "The Jumpers off the Ship."



And finally: In the cover picture in al-Hilal, as mentioned, there is a yeshiva boy with curly earlocks, who is reading a book as he walks (or stands to pray). It is possible to point to an error in identification, as the narrator in our story is explicitly a person from the Eastern Jewish communities who has Iraqi roots; there is no way he is Ashkenazi (or Yemenite). Although we learn that the protagonist of the story is growing a beard, he is definitely not an ultra-Orthodox person with earlocks. However, this mistaken identity should apparently not be attributed to Abboud, but rather to the designer of the issue who sought a clearly Jewish scene, supposedly, and also a Jerusalem scene in order to exemplify the backdrop of the plot of Behar's story.



Sasson Somekh is professor emeritus at Tel Aviv University. His memoir "Baghdad, Yesterday" (Hebrew, 2004) is to be published in English translation by Ibis.



http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/735651.html



Comment: If Australia had a government which had the slightest clue about handling the Muslim Question in Australia it would ensure that the Australia Council published a fortnightly magazine in Arabic which drew articles from very high quality secular magazines in the Middle East and paid for this magazine to be distributed as a supplement in the Arabic language newspapers.

But, of course, why spend money like that when it can be spent on more armour for SWAT teams?

Stupidity, thy name is Australia.

Commonsense Advice For Muslim Communities.

Note: This editorial from the British Catholic publication 'The Tablet' is spot on with its advice for muslim communities. This advice is consistent with the ideas promoted by this site.

Read on...




08/07/2006
The challenge for Islam
Editorial


The week the nation remembered the victims of the London suicide bombings a year ago also became the week the nation agonised over the degree of alienation of its Muslim population. The bombers were young British Muslims who appeared to think that their religion justified them in an indiscriminate attack on their fellow citizens. The Prime Minister told the Muslim community this week that the issue that should concern them was the misuse of Islam to justify terrorism, and that this was an internal religious issue rather than one where the Government has a role. He was answering those Muslims who see discrimination and poverty as prime factors in the alienation of Muslim youth, and look to the Government to provide a remedy.

Meanwhile a survey by the polling organisation Populus, commissioned by ITN and The Times, showed an encouraging awareness among Muslims that their closer integration with the majority population is desirable. But it also showed a gulf between the majority of Muslims, who flatly oppose terrorism in Islam’s name or any other, and about one in six who is sympathetic to it and see it as “martyrdom” – though only a tiny minority expressed support for last year’s bombers.

As the experience of Northern Ireland showed, success in the fight against terrorism depends not just on outwitting a small number of active terrorists but in addressing “the sea in which they swim” – the degree of tolerance of terrorist activity. And the poll suggests that most Muslims are sufficiently antagonistic to terrorism to cooperate with the police in combating it, even to the extent of tolerating police monitoring of the messages being preached in mosques. The Catholic population in Northern Ireland never went that far.

Nevertheless there is clearly a list of Muslim grievances needing to be acknowledged, including opposition to British foreign policy in Iraq and Afghanistan. They cannot expect a veto over such issues, though they have votes and can use them. But this is also the week a devout Muslim Lance Corporal in the British army was killed in the campaign against the Taliban. He went to Afghanistan hoping to help bring peace and reconciliation to that tortured country. His death is another kind of Islamic martyrdom, one more worthy of the name.

Mr Blair’s insistence that Muslims have to put their own affairs in order rather than rely on outside influences is an important clue that maturity, internal cohesion and self-esteem are positive factors in the integration of minorities. The Jewish and Catholic experiences of migration, settlement and integration are both relevant. The ability of those communities to contribute by advice and example to the healthy development of the Muslim community (as many Muslims would agree) cannot be over-emphasised.

So is the example of the change in Catholicism brought about by theological renewal. A hundred years ago, convinced that the modern world was a threat, the Church then – like fundamentalist Muslims now – was implacably opposed to democracy, religious tolerance and human rights. Now, thanks to the teachings of the Second Vatican Council and Pope John XXIII, it has no hesitation in standing up for them. But such changes cannot be triggered by governments. Mr Blair was right that the real challenge from terrorism conducted in the name of Islam is to Islam itself.




Comment: The muslims in Australia can also take this article to heart. Much can be gained by the muslims in Australia setting out to integrate properly into Australia. They will find many people willing to help and a welcoming Australian community.

It is in our national character to be welcoming and to help those 'who help themselves'. The main work has to be done by the muslims in Australia.

Saturday, July 08, 2006

Thoughtful Ideas From Karen Armstrong.

Note: Karen Armstrong is a well known writer on Islam and a former Catholic nun who became a Shi'ite convert. She is always thoughtful and it is always the smart thing to do, to read her contributions.

Read and learn...




Extremists are proud of their deviance, and moderate Muslims can't be held responsible

Karen Armstrong
Saturday July 8, 2006
The Guardian


A few years ago at a conference in the US, a Christian fundamentalist erupted into the hall and launched a vitriolic attack on me and my fellow panellists. His words were tumbling over one another incoherently, but the note of pain was clear. We had obviously assaulted him at some profound level. For three days my colleagues and I had discussed complex and radical issues in theology, not once at a loss for words; but stunned by the impact of this attack, we could find nothing to say. Dumbfounded, we gazed bleakly at our assailant across an abyss of incomprehension, until he was hustled out.

This type of incident is now common. Increasingly, people find it difficult to communicate with their co-religionists. The divide is as great as that between religious and secular people. Many of the faithful feel threatened by those who interpret their tradition differently; it seems their sacred values are in jeopardy. An apparently impassable gulf yawns between liberal and fundamentalist Christians, reform and orthodox Jews, traditional and extremist Muslims. Because of our preoccupation with the so-called clash of civilisations, this internal tension is often overlooked.

It is a year since the London bombings, an act committed in the name of Islam by a viciously disaffected minority, but which violated the essential principles of any religion. Doubtless with this anniversary in mind, the prime minister has complained that British Muslims are not doing enough to deal with the extremists. The "moderate" Muslims, he said testily, must confront the Islamists; they cannot condemn their methods while tacitly condoning their anger. The extremists' anti-western views are wrong, and mainstream Muslims must tell them that violent jihad "is not the religion of Islam".

This regrettable step will put yet more pressure on a community already under strain. It ignores the fact that the chief problem for most Muslims is not "the west" per se, but the suffering of Muslims in Guantánamo, Abu Ghraib, Iraq and Palestine. Many Britons share this dismay, but the strong emphasis placed by Islam upon justice and community solidarity makes this a religious issue for Muslims. When they see their brothers and sisters systematically oppressed and humiliated, some feel as wounded as a Christian who sees the Bible spat upon or the eucharistic host violated.

It is disingenuous of Tony Blair to separate the rising tide of "Islamism" from his unpopular foreign policy, particularly when Palestinians are being subjected to new dangers in Gaza. He is also mistaken to imagine that law-abiding Muslims could bring the extremists to heel in the same way that he disciplines recalcitrant members of his cabinet. This is just not how religious groups operate.

During the 20th century, a militant piety erupted in almost every major world faith: in Buddhism, Sikhism, Hinduism and Confucianism, as well as in Judaism, Christianity and Islam. It is often called "fundamentalism". Its aim is to bring God and/or religion from the sidelines back to centre stage, though very few fundamentalists commit acts of violence. Coined by American Protestants who wanted a return to Christian "fundamentals", the term is unsatisfactory, not least because it suggests a conservative and backward-looking religiosity. In fact, fundamentalists are rebels who have separated themselves irrevocably and on principle from the main body of the faithful. Fundamentalist movements are nearly always the result of an internal dispute with traditional or liberal co-religionists; fundamentalists regard them as traitors who have made too many concessions to modernity. They withdraw from mainstream religious life to create separatist churches, colleges, study groups, madrasas, yeshivas and training camps. Only later, if at all, do fundamentalists turn their wrath against a foreign foe.

Thus Sayyid Qutb (1906-66), whose ideology is followed by most Sunni fundamentalists, had no love for the west, but his jihad was primarily directed against such Muslim rulers as Jamal Abdul Nasser. In order to replace secularist Fatah, Hamas began by attacking the PLO, and was initially funded by Israel in order to undermine Arafat. Osama bin Laden began by campaigning against the Saudi royal family and secularist rulers such as Saddam Hussein; later, when he discovered the extent of their support for these regimes, he declared war against the US. Even when fundamentalists are engaged in a struggle with an external enemy, this internal hostility remains a potent force.

It is unrealistic to hope that radical Islamists will be chastened by a rebuke from "moderate" imams; they have nothing but contempt for traditional Muslims, who they see as part of the problem. Nor are extremists likely to be dismayed when told that terrorism violates the religion of Islam. We often use the word "fundamentalist" wrongly, as a synonym for "orthodox". In fact, fundamentalists are unorthodox - even anti-orthodox. They may invoke the past, but these are innovative movements that promote entirely new doctrines.

Fundamentalist Christians who claim that every word of the Bible is literally true are reading in an essentially modern way; before the advent of our scientifically oriented culture, Jews, Christians and Muslims all relished highly allegorical interpretations of their holy texts. Religious Zionists who regard Israel as sacred also fly in the face of tradition. A hundred years ago, most orthodox rabbis condemned the idea of a Jewish secular state in the Holy Land. In making the assertion that a cleric should be head of state, Ayatollah Khomeini flouted centuries of Shia orthodoxy, which separated religion and politics as a matter of sacred principle.

The same is true of the new emphasis on violent jihad. Until recently, no Muslim thinker had ever claimed it was the central tenet of Islam. The first to make this controversial, even heretical, claim was the Pakistani ideologue Abu Ala Mawdudi in 1939. Like Qutb, he was well aware that this innovation could only be justified by the godless cruelty of modernity. Informed extremists today do not need to be told that their holy war is unorthodox; they already know.

The extremists believe that mainstream Muslims have failed to respond to the current crisis and are proud of their own deviance. Attempting to shift the blame to the already beleaguered Muslim community could further alienate the disaffected. It will certainly not prevent another London bombing.

· Karen Armstrong is the author of The Battle for God, A History of Fundamentalism



Comment: This posting highlights the need for the governments of the West to actively make sure that the muslim community organisations are in the hands of the locally born and educated muslims. This would be a big step forward in strengthening the ties of the young muslims to the broader society if the governments were not allied with the 'old powers' to be found in every mosque.

It is also vital to put a stop to the 'war on Islam' which is being waged under various pretexts, by various Western governments.

Muslims Coming Up for Air, And Laughs...A Great Development.

Note: A truely great development is under way with the rise of muslim comics and 'stand up comedy'. This is marvellous. The comics in this story are not yet booked to appear in Australia. Great pity...can't someone do something about this?
A suggestion is made below in the 'Comments'section.

Read on...and laugh




In a comedy of terrors
Waleed Aly
July 8, 2006


Shazia Mirza jokes about her pilot's licence.


Advertisement
AdvertisementMel Brooks once insisted that no subject, however dark or serious, is unfit for comedy. He should know; his musical comedy The Producers derived much of its humour from the Holocaust. Still, stand-up comedy scarcely thrived in the immediate aftermath of September 11, 2001, particularly in the United States. Some sores were just too sensitive to be prodded.

But according to the cliche, humour equals tragedy plus time. If this could be true of the Holocaust, it was inevitable that September 11 would eventually provide swathes of new material, opening up new comedic spaces. Yet few would have expected Muslims to fill them.

Enter Azeem, Azhar Usman and Preacher Moss, three American Muslim comics who form Allah Made Me Funny: The Official Muslim Comedy Tour. The trio came together in 2004 and have toured across the US and Canada, attracting extraordinary attention at every stop. Their media file is impressive, with reviews and interviews in The New York Times, Time, American television and, in Britain, the BBC and The Guardian. The reviews have been overwhelmingly positive, though smacking of quaint curiosity.

Muslim comedy? Surely, in the popular imagination, there is no phrase more oxymoronic. The public Muslim is pathologically humourless. Not surprisingly, these Muslim comedians are under no illusions about the cynicism that confronts them.

"A lot of people don't expect the tour to be funny," Usman admits frankly. Azeem agrees: "They think a Muslim comedy show is like going to a prostate exam and telling him he's going to have a great time."

Muslim comedians, meanwhile, are emerging with surprising regularity. Arab-American comics, many of whom are Muslims, have long been a fixture in the US. Across the Atlantic, British-born Shazia Mirza is perhaps the first person to do stand-up in a headscarf. Her career took off with the opening line of her first gig after September 11: "My name is Shazia Mirza. At least that's what it says on my pilot's licence." Other Muslim comics joining Mirza at last year's Edinburgh Fringe Festival were fellow Brit Paul Chowdhry and Danish-Egyptian Omar Marzouk.

Perhaps, then, it is to be expected that Allah Made Me Funny is shooting for the mainstream. What began in mosques and Islamic community centres has now ventured successfully into some of the US's best-known comedy clubs, such as The Improv. This is a calculated step, designed to force Muslims and non-Muslims to come together and interact through laughter.

Also, this is a comedy tour with a pedigree. It is the brainchild of Preacher Moss, a veteran of the industry who has written for Damon Wayans, George Lopez and Saturday Night Live. Azeem has shared the stage with Steve Harvey, Adam Ferrara and John Pinette.

Moss and Azeem are black American Muslim converts of about 20 years and their roots have left an unmistakable imprint on their acts. Much of their material trades on the kind of racial observational humour mastered by Eddie Murphy and Richard Pryor.

The result is a kind of black-Muslim fusion. Azeem recalls being 17 and telling his grandmother, a devout southern Baptist, that he had become a Muslim. "I said, 'Grandma, I'm a Muslim.' She looked up and said, 'No, you're not. You ain't never been to jail."'

In many ways, Usman is the odd one out. The Chicago-born former lawyer is the only one of the trio born into a Muslim family. He is also probably the least experienced, having started performing what he calls his "Muslim schtick" only a few months before September 11. His act hasn't changed substantially since. "The main difference," he says, "is now people care."

Usman is right. To borrow from John Howard, the times suit him. Muslims in the West find themselves in an intense spotlight, and this can be thoroughly exhausting. "Muslims need a laugh," Usman says, and Moss quips that after September 11 the tension and paranoia were so high that you couldn't even tell a Muslim a knock-knock joke. Try it, he says. "Knock knock." "Don't answer it!"

This environment guarantees no shortage of stereotypes waiting to be given the stand-up treatment. "Muslims are the most peaceful people on the planet Earth," retorts Azeem to the common perception that Muslims are violent. "Y'all don't believe it? Think about it. Mike Tyson ain't won a fight since he became a Muslim."

Like all good comedians, Azeem, Usman and Moss are quite prepared to laugh at themselves. Usman's character comedy brings us "Sheikh Abdul, the radical imam", who intersperses vitriolic lectures with announcements about double-parked cars and meetings to re-elect the mosque committee that has remained unchanged for 37 years.

There's also "Uncle Letmesplainyou", an antique Muslim who barely speaks English, has crazy political views and a voracious desire to share them, elbowing others aside to embarrass the community in television interviews. He also brags about the growth of Muslim America to people who don't care. "He's bragging to his friends at work: 'Can you believe it, Bob? Seven million Muslims in America!' He thinks Bob is impressed. He's not; he's scared."

Muslims connect immediately with these characters because they, and the elements of internal community dysfunction they represent, are so achingly familiar. Usman recounts a conversation with a friend who says he is completely uninterested in organised religion. "I said: 'Great! Become a Muslim. We're the most disorganised people on Earth!"' In this way, Allah Made Me Funny gives Muslims permission to acknowledge and laugh at the problems in their own community, as well as to celebrate who and what they are, and to share the process with non-Muslims. "It is therapy," Usman says.

It is also empowering. Through the 1980s, Greek Australians such as George Kapiniaris and Nick Giannopoulos fought social alienation through the wog humour of shows such as Acropolis Now.

In the process they took ownership of a range of ethnic quirks and insulting stereotypes. The xenophobe's weapons were immediately, irredeemably blunted. No one did wog jokes better than wogs themselves. The stereotypes ceased being sources of prejudice and instead became endearing sources of amusement. If wog comedy is tired now, it is only because it has been so spectacularly successful.

It makes sense that American Muslims would do the same. There are few more quintessentially American popular art forms than stand-up. Particularly for maligned social groups, it has long been a simultaneous source of catharsis and rebuttal.

Usman calls this "comedy of distortion", where "the minority group that is the butt of the stereotype [is] using that stereotype, flipping it inside out and exposing it for what it is".

From all reports, the sense of empowerment is observable in Muslim audiences. "The group of people that I've noticed that come out are those persons who, for some reason, have felt spiritually disenfranchised," Azeem says. "What I've noticed is that as they leave, it's like they just came from a spiritual revival."

Plans are afoot to tour Allah Made Me Funny in Britain and requests have flooded in from the Muslim world. Australian Muslims have made similar requests, but so far a tour has not been viable.

If stand-up at its best is a commentary on the human condition and if the lives of American Muslims are by now indelibly politicised, it is inevitable that Allah Made Me Funny would have a political edge. Jokes about the absurdities of modern security measures are high on the agenda. Xenophobes are also useful fodder. Usman wonders how some callers to Fox News get through the screening process: "Yeah, hi, my name is Billy Bob. I'm calling from Louisiana and I just wanna say that all them Muslims - and them Islams, and all them Pakistanis and Afghanistanis and Iraqistanis - they should just go back to Africa!"

Typical of comedy that emerges from social and political tension, Allah Made Me Funny draws heavily on the darker parts of the comedian's condition as a source of inspiration. Comedy has this unique power. As Australian comic Adam Vincent says: "The jester would be the only one who could get away with telling the king what was wrong with the kingdom." Usman is explicit on this point. "There's a history of the underdog using stand-up comedy to speak truth to power. People take notice and are transformed by the experience."

Viewed through this lens, Allah Made Me Funny represents the forging of a new American Muslim identity. And, like all social development, it is not without its resistance. Some Muslims will be uncomfortable with the mix of comedy and religion.

Moss is frank about the challenges. "You know, some Muslims just take themselves too seriously," he muses. When Usman was booked to perform for a Shiite audience, some members of the community objected. It took a favourable ruling from their ayatollah himself before the show could go ahead. Now, Usman is dubbed the "Ayatollah of comedy".


Comment: Would it not be possible for the Australia Council to book this trio of muslim comics to do a tour of Australia? The best way would be to do shows in the great shopping malls all over the country for a month. Other venues could be lunch gigs at major employment venues, the 38 universities; imagine them doing a 15 minute gig at half time in a Bulldogs game! Nothing would help pacify the tensions in the muslim communities faster than good natured laughter.

Instead of continually sucking up to the worn out old businessmen farts and poisonous imams who misrule the poor muslims in Australia, why can't the government show some sensible thinking and pitch policy to a future paradigm that has some chance of success?

'Allah Made Me Funny'...well, we are all funny. It is very hard to have strife between people who are sharing laughs.

I apologise to all public servants and politicians who are offended at this idea because it is out of the square.

Friday, July 07, 2006

Backwardness! Thy Name Is Islam.

Note: Just a quick posting for those Australian dopes who think that Islam can be reformed, and is , anyway, 'OK'.

This is the true voice of mainstream Sunni Islam. These guys may not be terrorists or supporters of it...but look at what they DO support.

Read and laugh...





Ulema convention vows to defend Hudood laws

ISLAMABAD, July 6: A convention of religious scholars on Thursday vowed to protect the Hudood laws and said that the punishment for adultery, slander and liquor offences had been prescribed by Holy Quran and Sunnah.

A joint declaration issued at the end of the convention of Ulema and Mashaikh held at the Ahl-i-Hadith Mosque here said that punishments prescribed by Holy Quran had been incorporated in these laws and could not be revoked.

The declaration said that the punishments were aimed at providing justice to the oppressed, eradicating oppression and tyranny and protecting the honour and dignity of women.

It condemned statements issued by what it termed westernised NGOs and so-called intellectuals against the Hudood laws and said they were being issued at the behest of the government.

Accusing certain ‘media cells’ of backing and patronising such elements, it said that the current Council of Islamic Ideology was being used to promote an “anti-Islamic” agenda.

The declaration said that some people were committing blasphemy by saying that the Islamic edicts were brutal.

It said that all attempts to revise the Islamic law of evidence in adultery cases would be resisted.

“We warn all blasphemers to rein in their m ouths and pens; otherwise they will have to face consequences in this world for their wrongdoings and suffer humiliation and degradation in the hereafter.”

Ulema urged the government to abide by Islamic rules and to encourage people to adhere to the Islamic way of life. “We asked two daily newspapers, through correspondence and telephone, to publish apologies and express repentance on behalf of the blasphemers. But regrettabl, they did not pay heed to our demand.” The Ulema demanded that these dailies should apologise for their ‘blasphemous act’; otherwise “we will take them to court”.

The declaration also said that the present Council of Islamic Ideology, which had become controversial, should be dissolved and a new council comprising Ulema from all schools of thoughts, be constituted.

They termed the chief justice of the Federal Shariat court a controversial person and demanded his replacement.

Criticising the introduction of English in primary classes, the declaration said it had given the West the message that ‘we are your slaves’.

It also said that it was derogatory that the teaching of Islamiyat had been deleted from the syllabus of class one and two.

Criticising President Pervez Musharraf, the declaration accused him of trying to stay in power through “massacres and bloodshed”.

“We demand that General Musharraf should quit both the offices and set up an interim government under the chairman Senate”.

The convention called upon the government to change its visa policy regarding foreign students applying to study in Islamic seminaries. It also urged the government to recognise the certificates issued by all the five Tanzeemat equivalent to Bachelors and Masters degrees and to accord the Tanzeemat the status of an education board.

The convetion was addressed by several members of the National Assembly, senators and religious scholars.

The Ulema condemned the anti-Hudood bill tabled by the People’s Party Parliamentarian and the ruling PML.—Online


Comment: Is there any real need to allow Pakistani muslims into Australia? Can't we do better than this rubbish?

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

'Mohammad Luther, Please Call Your Office!'

Note: An excellent article about the improvements taking place in Islamic religious circles. Real scholars like Dr. Bassam Tahhan should be given a radio program on Arabic Radio in Australia. A sensible Australian government could bring this about.



July 6, 2006 No.1198

Muslim Intellectual Calls for 'Protestant Islam'

Dr. Bassam Tahhan, a Syrian-born French professor of Arabic literature, teaches at the prestigious Henri IV secondary school in Paris and is an expert on the Koran. In his numerous lectures and interviews, he advocates "Protestant Islam," which he defines as Islam that allows freedom of thought and permits questioning the Sunna, abrogating hadiths not grounded in the Koran, and reinterpreting the Koran in light of modern values. Tahhan recently attended a UNESCO conference on human rights in Morocco, where he gave the following interview to the independent French-language Moroccan daily Telquel: [1]

"To Be a Rationalist is to Acknowledge That the Orthodox Approach is Fundamentally Wrong"

Telquel: "You characterize yourself as one who interprets the Koran rationally. What do you mean by that?"

Tahhan: "To read the Koran rationally is to accept that the Koran is open [to interpretation] and has many meanings. The tradition regards the Koran as one-dimensional and fixed. This approach is not rationalist. To be a rationalist is to accept that each era, with its [particular] methods and discoveries, presents its own reading of the Koran, and this is the way it will be until the end of days. To be a rationalist is to acknowledge that the orthodox approach is fundamentally wrong since it does not accept the multiplicity of readings."

Telquel: "You are one of a handful of experts around the world on the different versions of the Koran. How did you come to have a passion for this topic?"

Tahhan: "Let me remind you of a historical fact that is accepted by all. In the year 901 - an unfortunate year for Muslims - a Muslim qadi named Ibn Mujahid canonized [one version of] the Koran. Before that, there were many different versions of the Koran, and this did not upset the good Muslims!"


Examining the Different Versions of the Koran Reveals "Its WideRange of Possible Meanings"

Tahhan: "Today, Muslim thought evolves within a very rigid framework, namely the framework of the Shari'a. I, on the other hand, refer to the sacred scriptures. Specifically, I allow myself to draw upon the various [versions of the] 'sacred scriptures,' since there are many of them. This is a fact. In order to see this, one must merely read the chapter Kutub Al-Masahif ('The Books of the Koran') in Ibn Nadim's book Al-Fihrist. Ibn Nadim enumerates several versions of the Koran which were not recognized by the Caliphs. He explicitly refers to mushaf al-rasul (the Prophet's Koran)! Remember that, ever since the Koran was canonized, we have been referring to Mushaf 'Uthman ['Uthman's version of the Koran].

"The German orientalist Theodor Noeldeke wrote several volumes on the history of the various Korans. Today the Arabic translation of his book is being circulated in secret. Jews and Christians readily accept the different versions of their sacred scriptures. Why shouldn't we? When you examine the different versions from different perspectives - sociological, philosophical, juridical and linguistic - you reveal the Koran's wide range of possible meanings. This breathes new life into [the Koran], instead of petrifying it for all time!"


"Why Can't the Word of God Be Multifaceted? Why Can't the Koran Be True in its Different Versions?"

Telquel: "You do understand, though, that it is difficult for believing [Muslims] to accept your arguments, [since they] believe that there is only one truth, which stems from a divine revelation and is recorded in one single book, namely the Koran."

Tahhan: "I allow myself to search for the historical truth. I believe that it is my right and duty to check the sources. Who decreed that the Koran is monolithic because the word of God is one? Why can't the word of God be multifaceted? Why can't the Koran be true in its different versions? God never deprived man of his freedom of thought. God created history, and allows it to unfold. But he never deprived human beings of the right to manage their own affairs in the course of history. Arab and Muslim history - the history which bores our children in school - is a history of palaces; it is not a social history. When our elite [finally] examines the social history of Islam, no one will find it strange that researchers are excited about examining the various versions of the Koran!"


"As a Protestant Muslim, I... Challenge the Over-Application of the Shari'a"

Telquel: "You find it unfortunate that Islam is limited to the Shari'a. Must we become 'Protestant Muslims' in order to set the Shari'a aside?"

Tahhan: "As a Protestant Muslim, I do not merely challenge the over-application of the Shari'a. I believe that basing Islam [only] on the Five Pillars is a narrow approach. I say that Islam has many dimensions: the judicial dimension which deals with ethics, the theological dimension that has to do with philosophy, and the mystical dimension which has to do with socio-psychology and spirituality. I wish that the training of theologians in Muslim countries would consider all these various dimensions. When you limit religious teaching to the Shari'a, you impoverish it. That is why I completely support the pioneering reforms of [Moroccan] Minister Ahmad Tawfiq, including the modern reforms implemented by [the Moroccan institute of] Dar Al-Hadith Al-Hassania..."


"We Should Found a New Community... of Protestant Muslims"

Telquel: "For many, 'Islam' and 'Protestant' [are concepts that] do not go together. How do you reconcile them?"

Tahhan: "We should found a new community: the community of Protestant Muslims. Its roots already exist in [Muslim] history. This community would promote a return to the word of God, since the overwhelming majority of prophetic hadiths are subject to serious questioning and suspicion. A Protestant Muslim has only one goal: to track down the truth to its very source. He has only one guiding principle: never to let himself be content with the so-called revealed truth. Freedom of thought is a God-given gift that should be honored by Muslims."


Why Should OneReligiousSchool Be Better Than Another?

Telquel: "You often object to the dictates of the religious schools regarding religious practices. Why is that a problem?"

Tahhan: "Why should one [religious] school be better than another? For example: Abu Hanifa accepts the testimony of a Muslim woman, whereas the other schools reject it along with the testimonies of Jews and Christians - and thus treat the Muslim woman as an apostate! Why should [we believe that] Malik is right and not Abu Hanifa? Why should I be considered a less devout Muslim if I follow the directives of Al-Tabari (a brilliant exegete who was murdered by obscurantists) rather than those of [Ibn] Hanbal? God granted me freedom of thought and I intend to make use of it!"


"Al-Shafi'i is Dangerous Because" He Gives the Same Status to the Sunna and to the Koran

Telquel: "You say that [Imam] Al-Shafi'i is dangerous because he replaced the Koran with the Sunna. What do you mean by that?"

Tahhan: "There was always a tendency to supplement the Koran with the Sunna. This tendency is questionable since the Koran is defined as the Sunna of God and his Prophet! Various historical factors gradually led the Sunna to become an indispensable supplement to the Koran, to the point that it superseded the Koran. Remember that the Koran never mentions [the practice of] stoning, but [only] whipping. Likewise, the Koran does not explicitly [mandate] the death penalty for apostates (la ikraha fi din). The Koran doesn't totally prohibit [the drinking of] wine... Al-Shafi'i is dangerous because, in his book Rissala, he explains that the Koran and the Sunna can be given the same status. Al-Shafi'i is dangerous because he created a certain ambiguity: he turned the fundamental text [of Islam] into a twofold text [consisting of the Koran and the Sunna], to the point where the Sunna came to impinge on the word of God. Unfortunately, [even] in the 21st century, the orthodox world still fails to challenge his unjustified status.

"We should also have the right to [apply] a diversified reading of the Koran in religious ruling. The [status of the] Sunna must be redefined. Why should those who believe only in the Koran be expelled from the Sunni community?"

Telquel: "You say that Islam did not abolish slavery. This is not what we were taught in school..."

Tahhan: "Many suras deal with slaves, for example with abid [slaves] and ma malakat aymanukum ['those whom you own'], which clearly refers to women captured in war. Islam is against slavery, but no sura explicitly forbids it. This shows that it is necessary to come up with a new historical and sociological reading of the scriptures. And since you offer me the opportunity to do so, let me call upon the [religious] authorities. Our orthodox religious scholars take the liberty of abrogating the sacred text, so why don't they go all the way and abrogate everything that infringes on the universal rights of Muslim women? The problem is that the religious scholars have only one guiding principle - the domination of women by men, to the extent that they made laws that undermine the [one] positive [right] granted to Muslim women, namely financial independence... The [notion that] women are naqisat 'aql wa din ['deficient in both intellect and faith'] is an outdated theological fabrication which is mentioned nowhere in the Koran. However, it is so frequently evoked in sermons that the Muslim in the street believes that this absurdity is mentioned in the scriptures, when [in actuality] it is [nothing more than] a 'weak tradition' [i.e. a tradition whose authenticity is in doubt]..."

Telquel: "Aren't you being over-optimistic when you say that Morocco holds the seeds of Islamic renewal, including a reform in the status of women?"

Tahhan: "I honestly believe that it is no coincidence that Mohammad VI was the one who ratified the new mudawana [the new Moroccan family code that grants more rights to women]. He is a descendent of [the Prophet Muhammad's daughter] Fatima, who was dispossessed by the followers of Abbas. They are the ones who decreed that women cannot inherit, and thus deprived her descendants of the right to the caliphate... And it was Fatima's descendant... who restored the Muslim women's rights. In this I see the seeds of Protestant Islam - which are potent enough to shake the dust off [Islam] after 13 centuries of stagnation!"


Comment: One wonders what disaster actually has to occur in Australia before our idiotic leaders in politics and media finally see that the muslims in Australia need to be exposed to the views of scholars like this modern man.

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

Proper Integration: The Only Possible Way Forward.

Note: The remarks by the British Conservative Party Member of Parliament are perfectly sensible. He even praises the feeble efforts being made in Australia on the Muslim Question.

We need some local MPs to start writing and speaking in this style, here in Australia.

This posting is from the excellent Dhimmi Watch site.

Read on...

UK: Tory pol speaks common sense, dhimmi Tories recoil in horror
What did Sir Nick say that was so terrible? Nothing: he said that Muslim immigrants should adopt British values and drop the elements of Islam that are incompatible with those values. That such views would be controversial at all indicates the depth of the crisis in Britain today.

"Tories rebuff Sir Nick over attack on British muslims," from the Macclesfield Express:

SIR NICHOLAS Winterton’s latest views on British Muslims have been branded "offensive and divisive" by the region’s racial equality council.
But the unrepentant Macclesfield MP this week stood by comments made in his latest article in the Macclesfield Express, published in full in today’s edition.

In it, Sir Nick blames multi-culturalism for the terrorist threat facing the country and says that "agitating so-called Muslim community leaders" who criticise the police "should be ashamed of themselves and held to account".

He also adds: "The Australian Government has spelt out bluntly what it expects of its ethnic minority communities and we in the UK should do the same.

"They should stop politicising dress, such as wearing the hijab and burkha, they should learn English, they should not return to their homelands to get a spouse, cease forced marriages and accept once and for all that the United Kingdom is not, and never will be, an Islamic state."

His views come just two days before the first anniversary of the July 7 London bombings and the right-wing Tory MP suggests the "outrageous outcry" in response to last month’s raid in East London, where police found no evidence of a terrorist plot, shows that the British public have already forgotten about the atrocities of one year ago.

The Conservative Party Central Office has distanced itself from the comments, releasing a statement saying: "These are Sir Nick’s personal views".

But they are sure to embarrass Tory leader David Cameron who is aiming to make the party more appealing to the ethnic communities.


In other words, David Cameron wants to sell Britain's soul and future for Muslim votes. Don't get in the way, Sir Nick.

Director of the Cheshire, Halton and Warrington Racial Equality Council, Shantele Janes, said she would raise her concerns over the article with Mr Cameron.
"We are extremely concerned by the article," she says.

"We think that it is offensive and divisive and we are appalled that someone in his position would be so irresponsible as to make the comments he did, contributing to the climate of hostility towards Muslims in the UK."


Janes, of course, does not consider the possibility that Muslims may be contributing to that "climate of hostility" by not doing the things Sir Nick has said they should do. No, once again, the responsibility for concessions and accommodations lies solely with the non-Muslims.

But Sir Nick insisted such comments represent the views of both his constituents and the wider public.
"They are forthright and positive and express the views of many of those people who have communicated to me and speak to me about these issues," he said.

"It is time straight talking took place on the sensitive issue of integration and asylum. It is right that people should be told what the majority of British people believe.

"I’m advised there are 70 suspected terror plots to attack Britain that are being investigated and the threat has not diminished almost a year on from the bombings in London which resulted in 56 innocent people losing their lives.

"I would prefer the police to raid a house and, ultimately, for the people who were arrested to be released than for people to be allowed to develop terrorist plots.

"We have experienced terrorism in this country from the IRA and I took just as strong a line in respect of IRA terrorism.

"But if people come to this country they should seek to integrate into the country and to accept our laws and our traditions."




Comment: Clearly integration is the only way forward into the Australian mainstream for muslims in Australia. Integration is not assimilation. Assimilation would mean muslims abandoning their cultural/religious/ethnic background. This is not possible for most and is wrong from a psychological health angle. ( If a muslim wanted to abandon his muslim background, that is possible, but only as a genuinely free choice. Coercion in such matters is psychologically catastrophic.)

Integration means that the local muslim community is controlled by muslims who were born here and educated here; it means keeping poisonous imams out; it means stopping Wahhabi money coming into Australia from the Middle East.

None of these three essential actions is part of any government policy in Australia. Therefore what we really have in Australia is 'play acting' pretending to be policy. Both sides of Parliament are into this game.

Australia needs now to have the 'Three Part Policy' introduced without delay.

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

Thursday, July 06, 2006

Current Views Of The Vatican Establishment On The Muslim Question.

Note: This issue will get bigger as time goes on. Therefore it is best to confront it now. (It's called the 'Cancer Principle') Would it be remotely possible to get the Australian media to look at this matter? Not likely.

Read on...

The Vatican Confronts Islam
By Daniel Pipes
FrontPageMagazine.com | July 5, 2006

“Enough now with this turning the other cheek! It’s our duty to protect ourselves.” Thus spoke Monsignor Velasio De Paolis, secretary of the Vatican’s supreme court, referring to Muslims. Explaining his apparent rejection of Jesus’ admonition to his followers to “turn the other cheek,” De Paolis noted that “The West has had relations with the Arab countries for half a century…and has not been able to get the slightest concession on human rights.”

De Paolis is hardly alone in his thinking; indeed, the Catholic Church is undergoing a dramatic shift from a decades-old policy to protect Catholics living under Muslim rule. The old methods of quiet diplomacy and muted appeasement have clearly failed. The estimated 40 million Christians in Dar al-Islam, notes the Barnabas Fund’s Patrick Sookhdeo, increasingly find themselves an embattled minority facing economic decline, dwindling rights, and physical jeopardy. Most of them, he goes on, are despised and distrusted second-class citizens, facing discrimination in education, jobs, and the courts.

These harsh circumstances are causing Christians to flee their ancestral lands for the West’s more hospitable environment. Consequently, Christian populations of the Muslim world are in a free-fall. Two small but evocative instances of this pattern: for the first time in nearly two millennia, Nazareth and Bethlehem no longer have Christian majorities.

This reality of oppression and decline stands in dramatic contrast to the surging Muslim minority of the West. Although numbering fewer than 20 million and made up mostly of immigrants and their offspring, it is an increasingly established and vocal minority, granted extensive rights and protections even as it wins new legal, cultural, and political prerogatives.

This widening disparity has caught the attention of the Roman Catholic Church, which for the first time is pointing to radical Islam, rather than the actions of Israel, as the central problem facing Christians living with Muslims.

Rumblings of this could be heard already in John Paul II’s time. For example, Cardinal Jean-Louis Tauran, the Vatican equivalent of foreign minister, noted in late 2003 that “There are too many majority Muslim countries where non-Muslims are second-class citizens.” Tauran pushed for reciprocity: “Just as Muslims can build their houses of prayer anywhere in the world, the faithful of other religions should be able to do so as well.”

Catholic demands for reciprocity have grown, especially since the accession of Pope Benedict XVI in April 2005, for whom Islam is a central concern. In February, the pope emphasized the need to respect “the convictions and religious practices of others so that, in a reciprocal manner, the exercise of freely-chosen religion is truly assured to all.” In May, he again stressed the need for reciprocity: Christians must love immigrants and Muslims must treat well the Christians among them.

Lower-ranking clerics, as usual, are more outspoken. “Islam’s radicalization is the principal cause of the Christian exodus,” asserts Monsignor Philippe Brizard, director general of Oeuvre d’Orient, a French organization focused on Middle Eastern Christians. Bishop Rino Fisichella, rector of the Lateran University in Rome, advises the Church to drop its “diplomatic silence” and instead “put pressure on international organizations to make the societies and states in majority Muslim countries face up to their responsibilities.”

The Danish cartoons crisis offered a typical example of Catholic disillusionment. Church leaders initially criticized the publication of the Muhammad cartoons. But when Muslims responded by murdering Catholic priests in Turkey and Nigeria, not to speak of scores of Christians killed during five days of riots in Nigeria, the Church responded with warnings to Muslims. “If we tell our people they have no right to offend, we have to tell the others they have no right to destroy us, ” said Cardinal Angelo Sodano, the Vatican’s Secretary of State. “We must always stress our demand for reciprocity in political contacts with authorities in Islamic countries and, even more, in cultural contacts,” added Archbishop Giovanni Lajolo, its foreign minister.

Obtaining the same rights for Christians in Islamdom that Muslims enjoy in Christendom has become the key to the Vatican’s diplomacy toward Muslims. This balanced, serious approach marks a profound improvement in understanding that could have implications well beyond the Church, given how many lay politicians heed its leadership in interfaith matters. Should Western states also promote the principle of reciprocity, the results should indeed be interesting.


Comment: Australia can play a useful role in this crisis. Our political leaders must speak up on this issue. It does not only affect Catholics...all Christian groups are subject to violence (actual or pending) from the 'religion of peace' as the muslims like to say.

Only when the politicians start talking about this and demanding action, will our media follow suit.

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

Wednesday, July 05, 2006

The Current Views Of The British Establishment On The Muslim Question.

Note: This article from a researcher at Chatham House is important.
Chatham House is the intellectual clearing house in London for all the thinking that goes on in the British security services and the British Establishment concerning deep and serious political questions. Questions like...

"what do we do about Islam in general and the muslims who are here, in particular".

Read this and see for yourself...





5 July 2006

Is “Eurabia” Inevitable?

Mai Yamani



What is it that makes young Muslims in the West susceptible to radicalism? What is it about the experience of the West’s rising generation of Muslims that leads a small minority to see violence as a solution to their economic and political dilemmas, and suicide as their reward and salvation?



Britain, which will soon mark the anniversary of last year’s bombings in London, provides a test case for seeking answers to these questions. For young British Muslims, our globalized world challenges key beliefs, destabilizing their identity and thus encouraging a defensive response. British citizenship, of course, guarantees freedom of expression and minority rights, and young Muslims take full advantage of this. Yet they are using this freedom to deepen family and cultural ties to the closed world of their inherited Muslim identity, particularly its politics.



In practice, this means that many young Muslims are utterly preoccupied with events in the Arab and Muslim world. They see what we see: a region where autocratic countries seem corrupt and paralyzed. But they also see an unprecedented level of hostility from the West, with regime after regime seeming to be either in peril or facing chaos. Afghanistan, Iraq, Palestine, and now Iran: all seem to be under attack as part of the “global war on terror.” As a result, the West’s strategic choices appear inherently anti-Islamic to countless of its young Muslims.



This preoccupation with the Middle East is at the heart of young Muslims’ politics in British universities, mosques, and websites. Although most do not support Pakistan’s Pervez Musharraf, Egypt’s Hosni Mubarak, or the al-Saud family, they see hypocrisy in Western criticism of these leaders that is designed to manipulate and marginalize – after all, the West does not really want to push these regimes too far.



Access to the Internet, satellite television, and travel is drawing these young Muslims into a community that shares their vision and their rage. So technology is heightening the tensions that exist between the mechanics of a modern free society and the sense of a vast conspiracy against Muslims. This has led to a schism between the hopes young Muslims have for successful lives in the West and their aspirations for their Muslim brothers and sisters, who have suffered so many terrible disappointments.



As young Muslims in Britain (and across the West) try to maneuver between the various, and often conflicting, aspects of their identity, three clear tendencies have emerged.



A secular and pragmatic response, which makes Islam a private matter;

A conservative stance that reconciles cultural, religious, and familial ties with ‘Britishness’;

A radical response to the perceived collision between the foreign policies of their new homelands and the welfare of the Islamic world.

Messianic waves from the Middle East, reaching both schools and mosques, help draw young Muslims into radicalism. One such wave is created by the hardline Saudi/Wahhabi education system, which is based on the concept of al-wala’ wa al bara’, loyalty to the system and hostility to the infidels. This curriculum, exported Westward by fat Saudi subsidies, is heavily punctuated with denunciations of the infidels and calls to jihad. Designed to secure the legitimacy of the Saudi monarchy at home, it is indoctrinating young Western Muslims with values antithetical to open and free societies.



Britain’s government is beginning to recognize the danger, and is trying to clamp down on schools and mosques that spread hate. Unfortunately, such repression has been merely reactive and shortsighted, with no clear long-term vision about the nature of Islamic education in the West. Thus, it merely feeds young Muslims’ fears that they are being singled out for persecution.



One difficulty with the British government’s response is that it classifies all Muslims as just that: Muslim. By defining people on the basis of their religion, nuances – of national identity or of the degree of orthodoxy – are lost. This plays into the hands of radicals, because it makes Islam the central element of identity.



This process, indeed, is echoed in the 22 Arab countries, where religious orthodoxy rules out any significant liberal political opposition. In such circumstances, the Mosque becomes the sole public space in which people can voice political views. Politicization of the mosque has, sadly, also become the norm in Britain.



Islamic radicalization and terror need not continue to flourish in the West. Regardless of their disappointments with the Western countries’ foreign policy, young Muslims have been exposed to their undeniable democratic spirit. They may now seek a deeper connection to their Muslim identity, but, having learned to question authority, they are unlikely to accept rigid parental or Islamic traditions. Like other young people around them, they want to be the agents of their own destiny.



This desire is changing Islam, especially in the West. The basic texts remain the same, but their interpretation, and the application of religion in people’s lives, has not. Young Muslims, particularly in the West, are setting an example that is slowly being echoed in the Middle East, despite massive state repression.



The task for Western policymakers is to recognize the interconnection of foreign and domestic policies. They must become serious about backing legitimate democratic representation in Muslim countries, for only then will Western policy seem less hypocritical. They must also ensure that career choices are as open to their Muslim citizens as they are to everyone else.



In short, young Muslims in the West need to believe that democratic principles are respected abroad and applied equally at home. Only when such a belief becomes general will despair stop fueling terrorism, and suicide bombing come to be viewed as an obscene calling.



* Mai Yamani, the author of Cradle of Islam, is a Senior Research fellow at Chatham House, the Royal Institute of International Affairs.



Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2006.

www.project-syndicate.org




Comment: This is all very nice, but it skirts the real option (unavoidable in this site's view)of expelling the imams and sheiks who are 'beyond the pale' and not allowing any replacements. Until this nasty bullet is bitten, the troubles will fester, because there will remain poison to make them fester.

The poison comes from the imams and sheiks.

Britain will never do this because the Wahhabis in Saudi Arabia can always play the corrupt British off against the corrupt French by 'playing games' with the endless billion dollar weapons contracts.

Australia has no similar weakness in relation to Saudi Arabia. We must kick out all the imams, without delay.

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

Thought Provoking Figures From Britain

Note: Why are there no similar serious studies on the views of muslims in Australia?



Muslim Britain split over 'martyrs' of 7/7


A SIGNIFICANT minority of British Muslims believe they are at war with the rest of society, the largest poll of Muslims in this country suggests.
The Populus survey for The Times and ITV News has found that more than one in ten thinks that the men who carried out the London bombings of 7/7 should be regarded as “martyrs”. Sixteen per cent of British Muslims, equivalent to more than 150,000 adults, believe that while the attacks were wrong, the cause was right.

But the poll also revealed a stark gulf between this group and the majority of British Muslims, who want the Government to take tougher measures against extremists within their community.

More than half (56 per cent) believe that the Government has failed to combat extremism, a higher proportion than the 49 per cent of the general population who agree.


No suggestion that maybe it is the Muslim community that needs to do more to combat "extremism."

Nearly half (49 per cent) of Britain’s 1.6 million Muslims also think it acceptable for the authorities to monitor what is being preached in mosques more closely.
Good. So do I.

13% of British Muslims think that the four men who carried out the London Tube and bus bombings of July 7, 2005, should be regarded as “martyrs”
7% agree that suicide attacks on civilians in the UK can be justified in some circumstances, rising to 16 per cent for a military target

16% of British Muslims say that while the attacks may have been wrong, the cause was right

2% would be proud if a family member decided to join al-Qaeda. Sixteen per cent would be “indifferent”

56% of British Muslims believe that the Government is not doing enough to fight extremism, more than the 49 per cent of the whole population who agree

50% think the intelligence services have the right to infiltrate Muslim organisations to gather information about their activities and the way they obtain funding

65% of British Muslims say that their community needs to do more to integrate properly with British society

35% say that they would feel proud if a close family member joined the police.



Comment: This survey shows that while a sizeable minority of British muslims are 'at war' with the rest of British society, the majority are not. I suspect that similar figures would be shown in an Australian survey.

We need that survey to be done and we need the governments in Australia to make life very difficult for the minority muslim troublemakers. Equally, the powers of the peaceable majority need to be strengthened.

All this must be done in the full glare of public knowledge. That way the general confidence of the whole Australian community will be built up.

Is anyone awake in Canberra?

Tuesday, July 04, 2006

Australia Must Encourage Muslim Apostates.

Note: The plight of ex-muslims, who have converted to Christianity, or no religion, is shamelessly ignored in the West. This neglect is another typical Western mistake.





Muslims Turned Christian Pay the Price

As I have pointed out many times, Abdul Rahman's case was not isolated. The killing of apostates is sanctioned by Islamic law. Note the interview below with Jihad Watch Board member Ibn Warraq.

CBN News spoke to one Christian convert we will call “Khaleed.” Khaleed works for the popular Web site, answering-islam.org. His story is one of rejection and abuse by Muslims in his own community in Western Europe.
“A lot of people don't even want to talk with me or even sit with me at the same table. I was like the reject of the community,” Khaleed said.

It was not long before Khaleed was forced to defend himself against physical violence.

He said, “They'd get very angry and very abusive verbally--call me "traitor" and things like that. And I'd even sometimes get into fistfights with some angry Muslims who hated the fact that I left Islam.”

And when he began doing Christian missionary work in these European Muslim communities, things only got worse.

“'We will kill you.' That's the verbal abuse--OK?” Khaleed said. “’…One day you'll die. And you will die suddenly.’ It was death threats all the time. And I got more and more -- actually physical attacks several times -- from them.”

Khaleed left Europe and now lives in the U.S., but he is careful not to advertise his Christian faith.

So what is being done to protect converts like Khaleed? According to one former Muslim, who also wanted his face hidden, not nearly enough.

Author and renowned scholar Ibn Warraq said, “I would find it difficult to give you precise statistics, but many people have been killed by the family to save the family honor if they discover the family member has converted to Christianity, especially...and you don't hear about it. The police just turn a blind eye to it.”

Warraq is the author of Leaving Islam: Apostates Speak Out. Warraq considers himself a secularist and lives in an undisclosed location because he fears for his family's safety. He says the left, in particular, has largely ignored the plight of apostates.

"There was an article by a Muslim in the Columbia Law Review that argued strongly enough that even Muslims in the West who leave Islam should be punished in the most severe form possible," Warraq said.

“No one thought to criticize this,” Warraq said. “It was accepted by the Columbia Law Review.”

Gartenstein-Ross points to what he calls a stark contrast in the West: “Those who convert out of Christianity and to Islam are often interviewed favorably in glossy magazines, talk about their conversion very openly, and are lauded for it. It's seen as something of a brave step.”

But he says that those who leave Islam usually do so quietly, even in the Christian world, because it's dangerous -- “In large part, because even in the Christian world, those who leave Islam for Christianity are not safe,” he said.

Fred Farrokh wants to change that. Farrokh is executive director of the Jesus for Muslims Network. Raised Muslim, he is now a Christian. His book is called Jailbreak: A Christian's Guide to Praying for the Muslim World.

Farrokh is opening a refuge center for Christian converts in New York City.

“Muslim background believers who are suffering persecution can come live and receive discipleship, training, equipping...and then, they themselves will be among the greatest missionaries, if you will, to Muslim people,” Farrokh said.

Warraq says that the West needs more people like Farrokh--who are willing to stand up and protect the rights of apostates here. But he says that even after the Abdul Rahman fiasco, the West remains crippled by political correctness--and largely indifferent to the plight of apostates.

“All we would have to do in the West is to simply stick to our own principles,” Warraq said, “and we would bring about change in the Islamic world. But we don't seem to be able to do that. We seem to be incapable of defending our own values.”



Comment: It is clearly in the cultural interest of the West for muslims to abandon Islam and, preferably, seek religious sustenence in a Christian community. Western governments should be financing the outreach services from the Christian churches to those many muslims who are now aware that Islam is not really a religion that can function, or help them in the modern world.

Instead of allowing 'religious' muslims to freely enter Australia, it ought to be easy for muslim apostates to enter and become citizens. Australia gets no advantage from 'religious' muslims. We are conducting an immigration program to get advantages for Australia, not to do favours for backward groups who will not/cannot overcome their backwardness.

Is anyone awake in Canberra?