Note: The problem of the imams is the key to solving the difficulties of muslims in the West.
The imams are all the same...the 'extremists' and the the 'moderates' all believe the same things. They operate a duplicitous policy that successfully fools dopes like the Howard government and all the State Labor governments.
The imams are the 'recruiting sergeants' for the jihad war of mainstream Islam against the West. Kick them all out from Asutralia and do not allow any replacements. Let mosques in Australia make their own arrangements from their locally available resources.
By kicking out the imams the Australian government would isolate the local muslims from the whirlwind of violence that has erupted from mainstream Islam as it dies. Our national interest takes precedence over any concern for a culturally strange and intellectually foreign Islam.
What does Islam give Australians? What does it bring to our country, that we don't already have? Do we get a benefit for the price we pay?
Read on and learn some terrible truths about the current reality of mainstream Islam...
August 13, 2006
Sense and nonsense from Richard Perle
Richard Perle offers common sense about monitoring mosques, and silliness about working with moderate Muslims, in "We should not tolerate the preachers of jihad," in the Telegraph:
Omar Sheikh was a promising LSE student from a comfortably middle-class Anglo-Pakistani family. On a humanitarian mission to Bosnia in 1992, he was recruited into a life of terror. In July 2002, he was sentenced to death in Pakistan for his role in the beheading of an American journalist, Daniel Pearl.
In his book Who Killed Daniel Pearl?, Bernard-Henri Levy recounts young Omar's reaction to the suggestion that he go to Afghanistan for training. He imagines him thinking "…he has to finish his studies… and his father is still the one who decides everything." "We'll talk to your father," he is told by the Islamist he meets in Bosnia. "I'll organise a meeting for him with Maulana Ismail, imam of the Clifton mosque, a holy man, who is experienced at guiding young English Muslims to our places in Afghanistan and who will find the words to convince him, I'm sure. It's an honour for a family to have a son who abandons his useless studies to consecrate himself to the life of jihad."
Thus was a bright student from a good family lured into a holy war that aims to impose Islamist fundamentalism on the world.
It is a war fought with planes crashed into buildings or blown up in mid-air, roadside bombs, kidnappings, beheadings and other unspeakable instruments of terror. It is decentralised but global in scope, from madrassas in Pakistan, to mosques in London, to "charities" in America, to banks and boardrooms in the Middle East.
It is a war with a cultural and ideological component that is lavishly financed by easy oil money from states like Saudi Arabia that we have long (and foolishly) regarded as "moderates" and "friends". It is a war utilising sophisticated technology for destruction and communications, and equally sophisticated techniques for inculcating lethal extremism.
The warriors in this jihad are identified, indoctrinated and recruited by men who manipulate the power of faith to induce a fanaticism whose ultimate expression is the martyrdom of suicide missions. Among them are clerics who have rewarded their welcome into our liberal, open societies by preaching our destruction.
How many acts of holy war - how many recruitments? - were performed by the imam who carried out his assigned task of facilitating Omar Sheikh's training at an al-Qaeda camp in Afghanistan? By what concept of liberal democracy must we allow these clerics who are out to destroy us the opportunity to reach impressionable young people with their message of holy war?
It has always been difficult to draw the fine line between protected speech, which is fundamental to our individual liberty, and incitement to prohibited criminal activity. In the United States, that line has long been defined by the concept of a "clear and present" danger. You don't claim the right to shout "Fire!" in a crowded theatre as a matter of free speech. In the UK, too, advocacy that falls short of incitement to immediate violence has been widely tolerated.
But combating Islamist extremism may require rethinking the idea of imminence in judging the dangers, and the appropriate response to them, of the insidious process leading ultimately to acts of mass murder. It is the act of recruitment into the swamp of a world divided into believers and infidels that may well be the more appropriate line dividing acceptable from unacceptable advocacy.
Yet in both the UK and the US we have been reluctant - dangerously so - to restrict, and in many cases even to monitor, what is said in the mosques and social centres of Islamist extremists.
In both our countries, there is great resistance to the effective surveillance of extremist Islamist groups. Opposed by most Muslim and civil liberty organisations, which fear that official scrutiny will lead to harassment and discrimination, police authorities have found it difficult to gather essential intelligence that could give timely warning of the formation of cells and networks destined to plan and execute acts of terror.
There was a (largely partisan) outcry in the US when it was learned that telephone conversations and bank transfer records were being scrutinised for terrorist connections, even though not a single aggrieved individual could be found. The occasional, inevitable mistakes by over-worked police and security organisations have further inhibited aggressive surveillance.
After 9/11, 7/7, Madrid, Bali and the rest, all carried out in the name of jihad, and after the chilling discovery of the successfully foiled plot to destroy thousands of air travellers last week, it is obvious we need to know what is going on in those parts of the Muslim community where Islamist extremists have made inroads. At the same time, we need to encourage the vast majority of Muslims who do not share jihadist views to join in opposing them.
Of course, Western officials have been doing all they can to encourage them, but have failed to do so. Perle thinks this is because they have chosen to work with "extremists" rather than "moderates":
To gain the trust and confidence of the American and British Muslim communities, officials in both countries have "outreach" programmes to work with mainstream community leaders. Sadly, these programmes have often left the silent majority of moderate, tolerant Muslims on the sidelines while courting organisations and leaders who are doing more for the disease than the cure.
In an important study released by the British think tank Policy Exchange, "When Progressives Treat with Reactionaries", Martin Bright has described what he calls "the Government's bizarre dalliance with the Islamists".
Based on leaked official documents, Bright demonstrates convincingly the Foreign Office's eagerness to work with, and inevitably enhance the standing of, representatives of the Muslim Brother-hood, an organisation committed to holy war ("Jihad is our way. Dying in the way of Allah is our highest hope"), as well as individuals who have openly supported suicide bombing.
Inexplicably, the British Government has accepted as its main partner on Muslim issues the Muslim Council of Britain despite "the clear Islamist sympathies of its leaders".
Something similar has happened in the US, where extremist leaders claiming to speak for America's tolerant Muslim community have been received at official events. On both sides of the Atlantic we need to abandon the illusion that extremist leaders are authentic and less voluble moderates are not. Talk to the latter - and keep a close watch on the former.
But of course, there is no such illusion. No Western officials have chosen to work with "extremists" rather than "moderates." Perle is correct that the British government has courted the Muslim Brotherhood, and there are other examples of this sort of thing, but that has not been at the expense of their consuming desire to find moderate Muslim leaders with whom they could work.
European and American government and law enforcement officials have generally been proceeding upon the assumption that, as Perle puts it, they "need to encourage the vast majority of Muslims who do not share jihadist views to join in opposing them." To this end they have been engaged for quite some time in a search for reliable spokesmen for that vast majority. But to their repeated surprise, they have found again and again that the "moderates" with whom they have engaged, such as the Muslim Council of Britain, are not as moderate as they thought they were.
I have heard Western officials affirm the existence of this vast majority and then in practically the same breath lament the difficulty of finding moderate leaders with whom they could work, without ever noticing their self-contradiction. Perle assumes here that they can't find such leaders because they haven't tried, which is just absurd. The other possibility -- that the vast majority of moderates they assume exists actually doesn't -- is much more likely to be true, but is apparently too frightening for Perle and other Western analysts to contemplate.
Comment: There are NO moderate imams. All imams promote jihad war against the West. In Australia the war has not yet opened, as it has in Europe. Be patient.
Sensible policies require that Australian governments act first and cut off the local muslims from the sources of jihad promotion. Expel the imams, without exception. Do not allow any replacements.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Monday, August 14, 2006
Sunday, August 13, 2006
Remarks From The Publisher Of The 'Mohammad Cartoons'.
Note: Wouldn't it be nice if the Australian press had people who could write intelligently about Islam as this author does?
Dream on...
2006-05-30
Europe's politics of victimology
Flemming Rose, cultural editor of Jyllands-Posten and publisher of the Muhammad cartoons, clarifies his position on the conflict he set off.
The worldwide furore unleashed by the cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad that I published last September in Jyllands-Posten (comprehensive press review here), the Danish newspaper where I work, was both a surprise and a tragedy, especially for those directly affected by it. Lives were lost, buildings were torched, people were driven into hiding.
And yet the unbalanced reactions to the not-so-provocative caricatures—loud denunciations and even death threats toward us, but very little outrage toward the people who attacked two Danish Embassies—unmasked unpleasant realities about Europe's failed experiment with multiculturalism. It's time for the Old Continent to face facts, and make some profound changes in its outlook on immigration, integration, and the coming Muslim demographic surge. After decades of appeasement and political correctness, combined with growing fear of a radical minority prepared to commit serious violence, Europe's moment of truth is here.
Europe today finds itself trapped in a posture of moral relativism that is undermining its liberal values. An unholy three-cornered alliance between Middle East dictators, radical imams who live in Europe, and Europe's traditional left wing is enabling a politics of victimology. This politics drives a culture that resists integration and adaptation, perpetuates national and religious differences, and aggravates such debilitating social ills as high immigrant crime rates and entrenched unemployment.
As one who once championed the utopian state of multicultural bliss, I think I know what I'm talking about. I was raised on the ideals of the 1960s, in the midst of the Cold War. I saw life through the lens of the countercultural turmoil, adopting both the hippie pose and the political superiority complex of my generation. I and my high school peers believed that the West was imperialistic and racist. We analysed decaying Western civilization through the texts of Marx and Engels and lionized John Lennon's beautiful but stupid tune about an ideal world without private property: "Imagine no possessions/ I wonder if you can/ No need for greed or hunger/ A brotherhood of man/ Imagine all the people/ Sharing all the world."
It took me only 10 months as a young student in the Soviet Union in 1980-81 to realize what a world without private property looks like, although many years had to pass until the full implications of the central Marxist dogma became clear to me.
That experience was the beginning of a long intellectual journey that has thus far culminated in the reactions to the Mohammed cartoons. Politically, I came of age in the Soviet Union. I returned there in 1990 to spend 11 years as a foreign correspondent. Through close contact with courageous dissidents who were willing to suffer and go to prison for their belief in the ideals of Western democracy, I was cured of my woolly dreams of idealistic collectivism. I had a strong sense of the high price my friends were willing to pay for the very freedoms that we had taken for granted in high school—but did not grasp as values inherent in our civilization: freedom of speech, religion, assembly, and movement. Justice and equality implies equal opportunity, I learned, not equal outcome.
Now, in Europe's failure to grapple realistically with its dramatically changing demographic picture, I see a new parallel to that Cold War journey. Europe's left is deceiving itself about immigration, integration, and Islamic radicalism today the same way we young hippies deceived ourselves about Marxism and Communism 30 years ago. It is a narrative of confrontation and hierarchy that claims that the West exploits, abuses, and marginalises the Islamic world. Left-wing intellectuals have insisted that the Danes were oppressing and marginalising Muslim immigrants. This view comports precisely with the late Edward Said's model of Orientalism, which argues that experts on the Orient and the Muslim World have not depicted it as it is but as some dreaded "other," as exactly the opposite of ourselves—and therefore to be rejected. The West, in this narrative, is democratic, the East is despotic. We are rational, they are irrational.
This kind of thinking gave birth to a distorted approach to immigration in countries like Denmark. Left-wing commentators decided that Denmark was both racist and Islamophobic. Therefore, the chief obstacle to integration was not the immigrants' unwillingness to adapt culturally to their adopted country (there are 200,000 Danish Muslims now); it was the country's inherent racism and anti-Muslim bias.
A cult of victimology arose and was happily exploited by clever radicals among Europe's Muslims, especially certain religious leaders like Imam Ahmad Abu Laban in Denmark and Mullah Krekar in Norway. Mullah Krekar—a Kurdish founder of Ansar al Islam who this spring was facing an expulsion order from Norway—called our publication of the cartoons "a declaration of war against our religion, our faith, and our civilization. Our way of thinking is penetrating society and is stronger than theirs. This causes hate in the Western way of thinking; as the losing side, they commit violence."
The role of victim is very convenient because it frees the self-declared victim from any responsibility, while providing a posture of moral superiority. It also obscures certain inconvenient facts that might suggest a different explanation for the lagging integration of some immigrant groups—such as the relatively high crime rates, the oppression of women, and a tradition of forced marriage.
Dictatorships in the Middle East and radical imams have adopted the jargon of the European left, calling the cartoons racist and Islamophobic. When Westerners criticize their lack of civil liberties and the oppression of women, they say we behave like imperialists. They have adopted the rhetoric and turned it against us.
These events are occurring against the disturbing backdrop of increasingly radicalised Muslims in Europe. Mohammed Atta, the 9/11 ringleader, became a born-again Muslim after he moved to Europe. So did the perpetrators behind the bombings in Madrid and London. The same goes for Mohammed Bouyeri, the young Muslim who slaughtered filmmaker Theo van Gogh in Amsterdam. Europe, not the Middle East, may now be the main breeding ground for Islamic terrorism.
What's wrong with Europe? For one thing, Europe's approach to immigration and integration is rooted in its historic experience with relatively homogeneous cultures. In the United States one's definition of nationality is essentially political; in Europe it is historically cultural. I am a Dane because I look European, speak Danish, descend from centuries of other Scandinavians. But what about the dark, bearded new Danes who speak Arabic at home and poor Danish in the streets? We Europeans must make a profound cultural adjustment to understand that they, too, can be Danes.
Another great impediment to integration is the European welfare state. Because Europe's highly developed, but increasingly unaffordable, safety nets provide such strong unemployment insurance and not enough incentive to work, many new immigrants go straight onto the dole.
While it can be argued that the fast-growing community of about 20 million Muslim immigrants in Europe is the equivalent of America's new Hispanic immigrants, the difference in their productivity and prosperity is staggering. An Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development study in 1999 showed that while immigrants in the United States are almost equal to native-born workers as taxpayers and contributors to American prosperity, in Denmark there is a glaring gap of 41 percent between the contributions of the native-born and of the immigrants. In the United States, a laid-off worker gets an average of 32 percent compensation for his former wages in welfare services; in Denmark the figure is 81 percent. A culture of welfare dependency is rife among immigrants, and taken for granted.
What to do? Obviously, we can never return to the comfortable monocultures of old. A demographic revolution is changing the face, and look, of Europe. In an age of mass migration and the Internet, cheap air fares and cell phones everywhere, cultural pluralism is an irreversible fact, like it or not. A nostalgic longing for cultural purity—racial purity, religious purity—easily descends into ethnic cleansing.
Yet multiculturalism that has all too often become mere cultural relativism is an indefensible proposition that often justifies reactionary and oppressive practices. Giving the same weight to the illiberal values of conservative Islam as to the liberal traditions of the European Enlightenment will, in time, destroy the very things that make Europe such a desirable target for migration.
Europe must shed the straitjacket of political correctness, which makes it impossible to criticize minorities for anything—including violations of laws, traditional mores, and values that are central to the European experience. Two experiences tell the tale for me.
Shortly after the horrific 2002 Moscow musical theatre siege by Chechen terrorists that left 130 dead, I met with one of my old dissident friends, Sergei Kovalev. A hero of the human rights movement in the old Soviet Union, Kovalev had long been a defender of the Chechens and a critic of the Russian attacks on Chechnya. But after the theatre massacre, he refused to indulge in politically correct drivel about the Chechens' just fight for secession and decolonization. He unhesitatingly denounced the terrorists, and insisted that a nation's right to self-determination did not imply a free ticket to kill and violate basic individual rights. For me, it was a clarifying moment on the dishonesty of identity politics and the sometime tyranny of elevating group rights above those of individuals—of justifying the killing of innocents in the name of some higher cause.
The other experience was a trip I made in the 1990s, when I was a correspondent based in the United States, to the Brighton Beach neighbourhood of Brooklyn, N.Y. There I wrote a story about the burgeoning, bustling, altogether vibrant Russian immigrant community that had arisen there—a perfect example of people retaining some of their old cultural identity (drinking samovars of tea, playing hours of chess, and attending church) while quickly taking advantage of America's free and open capitalism to establish an economic foothold. I marvelled at America's ability to absorb newcomers. It was another clarifying moment.
Equal treatment is the democratic way to overcome traditional barriers of blood and soil for newcomers. To me, that means treating immigrants just as I would any other Danes. And that's what I felt I was doing in publishing the 12 cartoons of Muhammad last year. Those images in no way exceeded the bounds of taste, satire, and humour to which I would subject any other Dane, whether the queen, the head of the Church, or the prime minister. By treating a Muslim figure the same way I would a Christian or Jewish icon, I was sending an important message: You are not strangers, you are here to stay, and we accept you as an integrated part of our life. And we will satirize you, too. It was an act of inclusion, not exclusion; an act of respect and recognition.
Alas, some Muslims did not take it that way—though it required a highly organized campaign, several falsified (and very nasty) cartoons, and several months of overseas travel for the aggrieved imams to stir up an international reaction.
Maybe Europe needs to take a leaf—or a whole book—from the American experience. For a new Europe of many cultures that is somehow a single entity to emerge, as it has in the United States, will take effort from both sides—the native-born and the newly arrived.
For the immigrants, the expectation that they not only learn the host language but also respect their new countries' political and cultural traditions is not too much to demand, and some stringent (maybe too stringent) new laws are being passed to force that. At the same time, Europeans must show a willingness to jettison entrenched notions of blood and soil and accept people from foreign countries and cultures as just what they are, the new Europeans.
*
The article was originally published in German in Der Spiegel on May 29, and in English in Blueprint Magazine on May 17, 2006. We would like to thank Blueprint editor Peter Ross Range for his consent.
Flemming Rose is cultural editor at the Jyllands-Posten, Denmark's largest newspaper.
Comment: The role of the press in Australia is to publish high quality thinking like this and put pressure on the politicians here to adopt sensible policies that lead muslims in Asutralia into proper integration with the rest of the Australian population. There can be no option on the question of integration.
Why else have the muslims come here if not to integrate into Australia?
Dream on...
2006-05-30
Europe's politics of victimology
Flemming Rose, cultural editor of Jyllands-Posten and publisher of the Muhammad cartoons, clarifies his position on the conflict he set off.
The worldwide furore unleashed by the cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad that I published last September in Jyllands-Posten (comprehensive press review here), the Danish newspaper where I work, was both a surprise and a tragedy, especially for those directly affected by it. Lives were lost, buildings were torched, people were driven into hiding.
And yet the unbalanced reactions to the not-so-provocative caricatures—loud denunciations and even death threats toward us, but very little outrage toward the people who attacked two Danish Embassies—unmasked unpleasant realities about Europe's failed experiment with multiculturalism. It's time for the Old Continent to face facts, and make some profound changes in its outlook on immigration, integration, and the coming Muslim demographic surge. After decades of appeasement and political correctness, combined with growing fear of a radical minority prepared to commit serious violence, Europe's moment of truth is here.
Europe today finds itself trapped in a posture of moral relativism that is undermining its liberal values. An unholy three-cornered alliance between Middle East dictators, radical imams who live in Europe, and Europe's traditional left wing is enabling a politics of victimology. This politics drives a culture that resists integration and adaptation, perpetuates national and religious differences, and aggravates such debilitating social ills as high immigrant crime rates and entrenched unemployment.
As one who once championed the utopian state of multicultural bliss, I think I know what I'm talking about. I was raised on the ideals of the 1960s, in the midst of the Cold War. I saw life through the lens of the countercultural turmoil, adopting both the hippie pose and the political superiority complex of my generation. I and my high school peers believed that the West was imperialistic and racist. We analysed decaying Western civilization through the texts of Marx and Engels and lionized John Lennon's beautiful but stupid tune about an ideal world without private property: "Imagine no possessions/ I wonder if you can/ No need for greed or hunger/ A brotherhood of man/ Imagine all the people/ Sharing all the world."
It took me only 10 months as a young student in the Soviet Union in 1980-81 to realize what a world without private property looks like, although many years had to pass until the full implications of the central Marxist dogma became clear to me.
That experience was the beginning of a long intellectual journey that has thus far culminated in the reactions to the Mohammed cartoons. Politically, I came of age in the Soviet Union. I returned there in 1990 to spend 11 years as a foreign correspondent. Through close contact with courageous dissidents who were willing to suffer and go to prison for their belief in the ideals of Western democracy, I was cured of my woolly dreams of idealistic collectivism. I had a strong sense of the high price my friends were willing to pay for the very freedoms that we had taken for granted in high school—but did not grasp as values inherent in our civilization: freedom of speech, religion, assembly, and movement. Justice and equality implies equal opportunity, I learned, not equal outcome.
Now, in Europe's failure to grapple realistically with its dramatically changing demographic picture, I see a new parallel to that Cold War journey. Europe's left is deceiving itself about immigration, integration, and Islamic radicalism today the same way we young hippies deceived ourselves about Marxism and Communism 30 years ago. It is a narrative of confrontation and hierarchy that claims that the West exploits, abuses, and marginalises the Islamic world. Left-wing intellectuals have insisted that the Danes were oppressing and marginalising Muslim immigrants. This view comports precisely with the late Edward Said's model of Orientalism, which argues that experts on the Orient and the Muslim World have not depicted it as it is but as some dreaded "other," as exactly the opposite of ourselves—and therefore to be rejected. The West, in this narrative, is democratic, the East is despotic. We are rational, they are irrational.
This kind of thinking gave birth to a distorted approach to immigration in countries like Denmark. Left-wing commentators decided that Denmark was both racist and Islamophobic. Therefore, the chief obstacle to integration was not the immigrants' unwillingness to adapt culturally to their adopted country (there are 200,000 Danish Muslims now); it was the country's inherent racism and anti-Muslim bias.
A cult of victimology arose and was happily exploited by clever radicals among Europe's Muslims, especially certain religious leaders like Imam Ahmad Abu Laban in Denmark and Mullah Krekar in Norway. Mullah Krekar—a Kurdish founder of Ansar al Islam who this spring was facing an expulsion order from Norway—called our publication of the cartoons "a declaration of war against our religion, our faith, and our civilization. Our way of thinking is penetrating society and is stronger than theirs. This causes hate in the Western way of thinking; as the losing side, they commit violence."
The role of victim is very convenient because it frees the self-declared victim from any responsibility, while providing a posture of moral superiority. It also obscures certain inconvenient facts that might suggest a different explanation for the lagging integration of some immigrant groups—such as the relatively high crime rates, the oppression of women, and a tradition of forced marriage.
Dictatorships in the Middle East and radical imams have adopted the jargon of the European left, calling the cartoons racist and Islamophobic. When Westerners criticize their lack of civil liberties and the oppression of women, they say we behave like imperialists. They have adopted the rhetoric and turned it against us.
These events are occurring against the disturbing backdrop of increasingly radicalised Muslims in Europe. Mohammed Atta, the 9/11 ringleader, became a born-again Muslim after he moved to Europe. So did the perpetrators behind the bombings in Madrid and London. The same goes for Mohammed Bouyeri, the young Muslim who slaughtered filmmaker Theo van Gogh in Amsterdam. Europe, not the Middle East, may now be the main breeding ground for Islamic terrorism.
What's wrong with Europe? For one thing, Europe's approach to immigration and integration is rooted in its historic experience with relatively homogeneous cultures. In the United States one's definition of nationality is essentially political; in Europe it is historically cultural. I am a Dane because I look European, speak Danish, descend from centuries of other Scandinavians. But what about the dark, bearded new Danes who speak Arabic at home and poor Danish in the streets? We Europeans must make a profound cultural adjustment to understand that they, too, can be Danes.
Another great impediment to integration is the European welfare state. Because Europe's highly developed, but increasingly unaffordable, safety nets provide such strong unemployment insurance and not enough incentive to work, many new immigrants go straight onto the dole.
While it can be argued that the fast-growing community of about 20 million Muslim immigrants in Europe is the equivalent of America's new Hispanic immigrants, the difference in their productivity and prosperity is staggering. An Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development study in 1999 showed that while immigrants in the United States are almost equal to native-born workers as taxpayers and contributors to American prosperity, in Denmark there is a glaring gap of 41 percent between the contributions of the native-born and of the immigrants. In the United States, a laid-off worker gets an average of 32 percent compensation for his former wages in welfare services; in Denmark the figure is 81 percent. A culture of welfare dependency is rife among immigrants, and taken for granted.
What to do? Obviously, we can never return to the comfortable monocultures of old. A demographic revolution is changing the face, and look, of Europe. In an age of mass migration and the Internet, cheap air fares and cell phones everywhere, cultural pluralism is an irreversible fact, like it or not. A nostalgic longing for cultural purity—racial purity, religious purity—easily descends into ethnic cleansing.
Yet multiculturalism that has all too often become mere cultural relativism is an indefensible proposition that often justifies reactionary and oppressive practices. Giving the same weight to the illiberal values of conservative Islam as to the liberal traditions of the European Enlightenment will, in time, destroy the very things that make Europe such a desirable target for migration.
Europe must shed the straitjacket of political correctness, which makes it impossible to criticize minorities for anything—including violations of laws, traditional mores, and values that are central to the European experience. Two experiences tell the tale for me.
Shortly after the horrific 2002 Moscow musical theatre siege by Chechen terrorists that left 130 dead, I met with one of my old dissident friends, Sergei Kovalev. A hero of the human rights movement in the old Soviet Union, Kovalev had long been a defender of the Chechens and a critic of the Russian attacks on Chechnya. But after the theatre massacre, he refused to indulge in politically correct drivel about the Chechens' just fight for secession and decolonization. He unhesitatingly denounced the terrorists, and insisted that a nation's right to self-determination did not imply a free ticket to kill and violate basic individual rights. For me, it was a clarifying moment on the dishonesty of identity politics and the sometime tyranny of elevating group rights above those of individuals—of justifying the killing of innocents in the name of some higher cause.
The other experience was a trip I made in the 1990s, when I was a correspondent based in the United States, to the Brighton Beach neighbourhood of Brooklyn, N.Y. There I wrote a story about the burgeoning, bustling, altogether vibrant Russian immigrant community that had arisen there—a perfect example of people retaining some of their old cultural identity (drinking samovars of tea, playing hours of chess, and attending church) while quickly taking advantage of America's free and open capitalism to establish an economic foothold. I marvelled at America's ability to absorb newcomers. It was another clarifying moment.
Equal treatment is the democratic way to overcome traditional barriers of blood and soil for newcomers. To me, that means treating immigrants just as I would any other Danes. And that's what I felt I was doing in publishing the 12 cartoons of Muhammad last year. Those images in no way exceeded the bounds of taste, satire, and humour to which I would subject any other Dane, whether the queen, the head of the Church, or the prime minister. By treating a Muslim figure the same way I would a Christian or Jewish icon, I was sending an important message: You are not strangers, you are here to stay, and we accept you as an integrated part of our life. And we will satirize you, too. It was an act of inclusion, not exclusion; an act of respect and recognition.
Alas, some Muslims did not take it that way—though it required a highly organized campaign, several falsified (and very nasty) cartoons, and several months of overseas travel for the aggrieved imams to stir up an international reaction.
Maybe Europe needs to take a leaf—or a whole book—from the American experience. For a new Europe of many cultures that is somehow a single entity to emerge, as it has in the United States, will take effort from both sides—the native-born and the newly arrived.
For the immigrants, the expectation that they not only learn the host language but also respect their new countries' political and cultural traditions is not too much to demand, and some stringent (maybe too stringent) new laws are being passed to force that. At the same time, Europeans must show a willingness to jettison entrenched notions of blood and soil and accept people from foreign countries and cultures as just what they are, the new Europeans.
*
The article was originally published in German in Der Spiegel on May 29, and in English in Blueprint Magazine on May 17, 2006. We would like to thank Blueprint editor Peter Ross Range for his consent.
Flemming Rose is cultural editor at the Jyllands-Posten, Denmark's largest newspaper.
Comment: The role of the press in Australia is to publish high quality thinking like this and put pressure on the politicians here to adopt sensible policies that lead muslims in Asutralia into proper integration with the rest of the Australian population. There can be no option on the question of integration.
Why else have the muslims come here if not to integrate into Australia?
Saturday, August 12, 2006
A Few Small Voices For Islamic Reform.
Note: This post is a little bit of good news. It is good to read of these developments. You will note that this conference took place in Christian europe where police exist to protect the participants from being murdered by adherents of mainstream Islam.
I wonder if the next such conference will take place in Mecca, broadcast from beginning to end by al Jazeera? Let us hope so.
Read and be (slightly) encouraged...
Now for some good news about Islam
By Irshad Manji
It is easy to believe that the Muslim world has only bad news to offer. But easy does not mean accurate. In fact, there is much good news to report.
Before all else, allow me to confess the obvious: We Muslims play the villain role quite well, thank you. Last month, a group of terrorists - evidently Islamist militants - blew commuter trains to shreds in India. The next day, Hezbollah crossed a UN-delineated boundary to kidnap and kill Israeli soldiers, touching off the latest litany of bombs and bullets to rock the Middle East.
Then again, I expect the worst from religious extremists. Moderate Muslims tend to disappoint me more. We call for a "proportionate response" from Israel. Yet we engage in a disproportionate response of our own when we diminish or outright ignore Hezbollah's crimes, too. They attacked Israel from southern Lebanon and Gaza, the very areas the Jewish state had unilaterally evacuated. If Islam is another word for peace, what is un-Islamic about opposing such bald aggression?
Moreover, Hezbollah deliberately throws Muslim and Christian civilians at death's door. Its fighters set up shop in the middle of busy residential districts, so that going after them must involve hitting innocents. What makes Muslims moderate when we wink at this cruel calculus?
Above all, given our hostility-turned-hypocrisy, what could I possibly be talking about when I say there is good news to share?
Brace yourselves: During the same week that India and Israel were reminded of Islamist brutality, liberal Muslims made progress in reclaiming our faith, both in the East and in the West.
Let us start in the East. For almost three decades, Pakistan has followed a controversial set of laws called "Hudood." Named for "hudd," or penalties prescribed by God, these laws determine punishment in cases of rape and adultery. Finally, the Hudood ordinances are being seriously challenged. And not a moment too soon: Under them, more than 4,600 Pakistani women have been thrown in prison for charges that include adultery. By contrast, virtually all men accused of rape have gotten off. Thanks to a vocal but religiously respectful campaign by civil society groups, Pakistan's Council for Islamic Ideology - an influential body - recently recommended changing the Hudood laws. That move laid the foundation for President Pervez Musharraf to begin releasing 1,300 jailed women who were awaiting trial. Even Muslim clerics in Pakistan now hint that the Hudood laws are not divinely created. The politics behind them tell us so.
In 1977, a U.S.-backed coup installed General Zia ul-Haq as Pakistan's president. To cement his tenuous grip, the strongman surrounded himself with sycophantic mullahs who referred to him as "Commander of the Faithful," a term reserved for the Prophet Muhammad's successors.
To curry favor among village leaders, Zia mixed a selective reading of the Koran with tribal customs. In this way, stoning arose as a legal punishment for adultery and it was required that a rape be witnessed by four men before any offender could be charged. But suppose a rape does not have the benefit of so many male eyes - and male voices willing to testify? Then it would be a case of adultery committed by the woman, who in turn could be condemned to jail, lashing, or stoning.
The injustices that followed have slandered not only women, but Islam itself. As more and more of Pakistan's Muslims recognize that these laws emanate from humans, they acknowledge that the duty to re-think them rests in their hands, not God's. Muslims believe that Allah is perfect. We are learning to appreciate that Allah's interpreters are not.
At the same time, the liberal reformation of Islam picked up speed - in Copenhagen, the city that served as Ground Zero for worldwide riots over cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad. A Danish newspaper, Jyllands-Posten, first published the caricatures. I joined 99 other "Muslim Leaders of Tomorrow" in Copenhagen to debate how Islam and the West can enrich each other. We came from the United States, Canada, Australia and across Europe. Permit me to divulge among the more shocking statements:
Man from the Netherlands: "We, as Muslims, need to look in the mirror instead of blaming everybody else!"
Woman from Germany: "I don't have an identity crisis. I'm Western and Muslim and grateful to be both."
Imam from Britain: "The minute a woman becomes a mufti [Islamic judge], I will be the first to study at her feet."
One delegate tested the young clerics: "Is Islam the only way to salvation?" A Danish imam gripped the microphone. "The short answer," he said, "is no." A British imam disputed that response and an Italian took the middle road. Remarkably, they never accused each other of being evil or insincere. For the first time in my life, I heard the message that in Islam, unity is not uniformity.
Maybe the most compelling insight came from a surprise guest: Flemming Rose, publisher of the reviled Prophet Muhammad cartoons. After addressing us and answering our challenges, Rose confided that the reception we gave him was more civil than anything he has experienced at the hands of humanist groups.
A liberal reformation of Islam will be marked by at least two features: the empowerment of women in the Muslim world and the willingness of Muslims in the West to exercise our freedom of conscience.
In one week, both got a promising boost. We will need to remember that as God's soldiers continue grabbing the spotlight.
Irshad Manji, a Fellow at Yale University, is author of "The Trouble with Islam Today: A Muslim's Call for Reform in Her Faith" (published in Israel by Kinneret-Zmora).
Comment: Australian authorities can do much to promote this liberalisation of Islam in Australia by adopting the Three Point Plan:
Communities...all muslim groups and institutions in Asutralia be legally required to only elect Executive members who were born and raised in Australia.
Imams...send away from Australia all the imams, without exception,and do not allow any replacements. The local mosques can make their own arrangements using the resources available in Australia. The imams are the source of the poison which is inevitably leading to an 'Event' in Australia.
Money...ban as a felony all money from outside Australia that is intended for any muslim group, charity, school(all of which must be absorbed into the state education system)or mosque. Make it a felony to receive such funds. This prevents the subornation of local muslims to foreign Wahhabi fascist muslims who are enemies of Australia's welfare and peace.
This policy will safeguard Australia from the growing Islamist menace from abroad.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
I wonder if the next such conference will take place in Mecca, broadcast from beginning to end by al Jazeera? Let us hope so.
Read and be (slightly) encouraged...
Now for some good news about Islam
By Irshad Manji
It is easy to believe that the Muslim world has only bad news to offer. But easy does not mean accurate. In fact, there is much good news to report.
Before all else, allow me to confess the obvious: We Muslims play the villain role quite well, thank you. Last month, a group of terrorists - evidently Islamist militants - blew commuter trains to shreds in India. The next day, Hezbollah crossed a UN-delineated boundary to kidnap and kill Israeli soldiers, touching off the latest litany of bombs and bullets to rock the Middle East.
Then again, I expect the worst from religious extremists. Moderate Muslims tend to disappoint me more. We call for a "proportionate response" from Israel. Yet we engage in a disproportionate response of our own when we diminish or outright ignore Hezbollah's crimes, too. They attacked Israel from southern Lebanon and Gaza, the very areas the Jewish state had unilaterally evacuated. If Islam is another word for peace, what is un-Islamic about opposing such bald aggression?
Moreover, Hezbollah deliberately throws Muslim and Christian civilians at death's door. Its fighters set up shop in the middle of busy residential districts, so that going after them must involve hitting innocents. What makes Muslims moderate when we wink at this cruel calculus?
Above all, given our hostility-turned-hypocrisy, what could I possibly be talking about when I say there is good news to share?
Brace yourselves: During the same week that India and Israel were reminded of Islamist brutality, liberal Muslims made progress in reclaiming our faith, both in the East and in the West.
Let us start in the East. For almost three decades, Pakistan has followed a controversial set of laws called "Hudood." Named for "hudd," or penalties prescribed by God, these laws determine punishment in cases of rape and adultery. Finally, the Hudood ordinances are being seriously challenged. And not a moment too soon: Under them, more than 4,600 Pakistani women have been thrown in prison for charges that include adultery. By contrast, virtually all men accused of rape have gotten off. Thanks to a vocal but religiously respectful campaign by civil society groups, Pakistan's Council for Islamic Ideology - an influential body - recently recommended changing the Hudood laws. That move laid the foundation for President Pervez Musharraf to begin releasing 1,300 jailed women who were awaiting trial. Even Muslim clerics in Pakistan now hint that the Hudood laws are not divinely created. The politics behind them tell us so.
In 1977, a U.S.-backed coup installed General Zia ul-Haq as Pakistan's president. To cement his tenuous grip, the strongman surrounded himself with sycophantic mullahs who referred to him as "Commander of the Faithful," a term reserved for the Prophet Muhammad's successors.
To curry favor among village leaders, Zia mixed a selective reading of the Koran with tribal customs. In this way, stoning arose as a legal punishment for adultery and it was required that a rape be witnessed by four men before any offender could be charged. But suppose a rape does not have the benefit of so many male eyes - and male voices willing to testify? Then it would be a case of adultery committed by the woman, who in turn could be condemned to jail, lashing, or stoning.
The injustices that followed have slandered not only women, but Islam itself. As more and more of Pakistan's Muslims recognize that these laws emanate from humans, they acknowledge that the duty to re-think them rests in their hands, not God's. Muslims believe that Allah is perfect. We are learning to appreciate that Allah's interpreters are not.
At the same time, the liberal reformation of Islam picked up speed - in Copenhagen, the city that served as Ground Zero for worldwide riots over cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad. A Danish newspaper, Jyllands-Posten, first published the caricatures. I joined 99 other "Muslim Leaders of Tomorrow" in Copenhagen to debate how Islam and the West can enrich each other. We came from the United States, Canada, Australia and across Europe. Permit me to divulge among the more shocking statements:
Man from the Netherlands: "We, as Muslims, need to look in the mirror instead of blaming everybody else!"
Woman from Germany: "I don't have an identity crisis. I'm Western and Muslim and grateful to be both."
Imam from Britain: "The minute a woman becomes a mufti [Islamic judge], I will be the first to study at her feet."
One delegate tested the young clerics: "Is Islam the only way to salvation?" A Danish imam gripped the microphone. "The short answer," he said, "is no." A British imam disputed that response and an Italian took the middle road. Remarkably, they never accused each other of being evil or insincere. For the first time in my life, I heard the message that in Islam, unity is not uniformity.
Maybe the most compelling insight came from a surprise guest: Flemming Rose, publisher of the reviled Prophet Muhammad cartoons. After addressing us and answering our challenges, Rose confided that the reception we gave him was more civil than anything he has experienced at the hands of humanist groups.
A liberal reformation of Islam will be marked by at least two features: the empowerment of women in the Muslim world and the willingness of Muslims in the West to exercise our freedom of conscience.
In one week, both got a promising boost. We will need to remember that as God's soldiers continue grabbing the spotlight.
Irshad Manji, a Fellow at Yale University, is author of "The Trouble with Islam Today: A Muslim's Call for Reform in Her Faith" (published in Israel by Kinneret-Zmora).
Comment: Australian authorities can do much to promote this liberalisation of Islam in Australia by adopting the Three Point Plan:
Communities...all muslim groups and institutions in Asutralia be legally required to only elect Executive members who were born and raised in Australia.
Imams...send away from Australia all the imams, without exception,and do not allow any replacements. The local mosques can make their own arrangements using the resources available in Australia. The imams are the source of the poison which is inevitably leading to an 'Event' in Australia.
Money...ban as a felony all money from outside Australia that is intended for any muslim group, charity, school(all of which must be absorbed into the state education system)or mosque. Make it a felony to receive such funds. This prevents the subornation of local muslims to foreign Wahhabi fascist muslims who are enemies of Australia's welfare and peace.
This policy will safeguard Australia from the growing Islamist menace from abroad.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Friday, August 11, 2006
Sensible Advice From An Arab Jesuit.
Note: This posting is from Fr. Samir SJ, an Egyptian Jesuit priest and Islam scholar. The eight point plan he produces contains the seeds of the solution. Well worth discussion.
Read and think...
10 August, 2006
LEBANON – MIDDLE EAST
Can a pointless war lead to a final peace settlement in the Middle East from?
by Samir Khalil Samir, sj
No one is benefiting from Israel’s war in Lebanon and Hezbollah’s and Hamas’s violence against Israel. Jesuit Fr Samir Khalil Samir, an Islam expert and professor in Beirut, offers a few suggestions to the United Nations.
Beirut (AsiaNews) – Israel’s expanded offensive in Lebanon which began yesterday has already raised the death toll by 15 more Israeli soldiers and 40 Hezbollah guerrillas. But the most blood is being shed by the Lebanese people, who are losing hope a lit bit more every day.
Caught between the blind violence of the Israeli army and the hesitations of international diplomacy, the more peaceful Lebanese opt for emigration; those who are less peaceful become Hezbollah supporters. The hatred for Israel grows in all.
For many analysts and political leaders, Israeli included, the situation is clear. A military victory won’t give Israel security, nor will it bring peace to the region. All it will do is boost hatred against Israel and therefore create greater insecurity.
Similarly, Hezbollah’s and Hamas’s attacks won’t free Lebanese and Palestinian land nor will they lead to peace. All they will do is increase hatred against them and convince Israel (as if that was necessary) that “Arabs know only the language of force”.
There will just be more destruction, more losses, more hatred . . . until the next war.
No one gains from war. No One! As an ideological movement “Islamic terrorism” cannot be defeated by force alone. This was demonstrated by the Red Brigades and ETA, shown in Algeria and Afghanistan, or is seen day after day in Iraq where hundreds of people still die after the US “liberation”. So what can be done?
“Get to the bottom of the problem”
Politicians say: “A ceasefire does not solve the problem.” That is true, but at least it will stop the violence in Israel and Lebanon.
Everyone says: “We must get to the bottom of the problem.” That is equally true.
Hezbollah, which usurped the Lebanese army’s role as defender of the country, is not the root of the problem. It did not exist when Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982. Hamas also is not the root of the problem, nor is Fatah. The attack against Israel at the 1972 Munich Olympic Games, which began the wave of terrorism in the region, is not the root of the problem.
The problem goes back to the creation of the State of Israel and the partition of Palestine in 1948. The Big Powers chose to partition the country in the wake of the organised and systematic persecution of the Jews but failed to take into account the populations already present in the (Holy) land. This is the real cause of all the wars that followed.
The partition is none the less a fact of history that was sanctioned by the international community. The existence of two states, Israel and Palestine, is a reality that finds its legitimacy in the United Nations and cannot be challenged.
Every wound inflicted on international legality carries an even greater evil. Hence any solution to the conflict that does not respect international legality, i.e. UN resolutions, will not bring peace.
Proposals for a final peace plan
As things stand right now, diplomacy is the only path to peace as long as it follows two rules: first, justice and respect for international legality; two, the need to make concessions which implies flexibility, thoughtfulness and willingness to surrender some of our rights for the sake of those of others.
We need a lasting solution, or better still, we need a final solution to the Mideast crisis so that together, slowly, we can build the peace and—if we are allowed to dream for a moment—a “Middle East Union”.
To reach that goal, I’ll layout the essential points of what I consider a just and realistic course of action:
1. A Palestinian state based on pre-1967 War boundaries with small changes, if necessary, as long as they are agreed upon by both Israel and Palestine.
2. Palestinians must give up the “right to return” and Israelis must give up their settlements in Palestinian territories. Small territorial adjustments might have to be made but only with the agreement of Israel and Palestine. The international community should compensate the parties for what they relinquish.
3. All the countries of the Middle East (including Turkey, Iran, Iraq, etc.) must officially recognise the borders of the region’s states as final and exchange ambassadors with them.
4. An international force “with teeth” should be deployed where peace is not fully implemented to prevent arms smuggling, especially between Israel and Palestine, Israel and Lebanon, Lebanon and Syria, Syria and Iraq, Iran and Iraq, and Turkey and Iraq.
5. Each state should receive assistance in setting up its own national army to disarm all groups, parties, settlers, etc.
6. Prisoners held by other countries should be freed. Exchange agreements should be reached, in particular between Israel, Palestine, Lebanon and Syria.
7. An international commission should be set up for Jerusalem to guarantee security within the city, freedom of movement and respect for the borders between the two states, both of which legitimately wish to have the city as their capital.
8. An international commission should be created to equitably solve water use in the region, which is an essential condition for development and often cause of friction and source of conflict.
The war currently underway, with its after-effects in terms of brutality and suffering, is letting millions of people, whatever their side, to come to the realisation that violence is pointless, that wars will not change the Middle East.
Realising this might be the only good thing coming out of this tragedy, which is being fought on the backs of the Lebanese people.
If from this tragedy a final peace plan can emerge, then this martyrdom may not have been in vain! Talks now taking place at the United Nations Security Council in New York might be the first steps in just such a direction.
Comment: Australia should suport this initiative. Currently we do not get involved in this crisis. I think that is a mistake. Australia has very good relations with all sides in the Middle East. We should put this to work.
Read and think...
10 August, 2006
LEBANON – MIDDLE EAST
Can a pointless war lead to a final peace settlement in the Middle East from?
by Samir Khalil Samir, sj
No one is benefiting from Israel’s war in Lebanon and Hezbollah’s and Hamas’s violence against Israel. Jesuit Fr Samir Khalil Samir, an Islam expert and professor in Beirut, offers a few suggestions to the United Nations.
Beirut (AsiaNews) – Israel’s expanded offensive in Lebanon which began yesterday has already raised the death toll by 15 more Israeli soldiers and 40 Hezbollah guerrillas. But the most blood is being shed by the Lebanese people, who are losing hope a lit bit more every day.
Caught between the blind violence of the Israeli army and the hesitations of international diplomacy, the more peaceful Lebanese opt for emigration; those who are less peaceful become Hezbollah supporters. The hatred for Israel grows in all.
For many analysts and political leaders, Israeli included, the situation is clear. A military victory won’t give Israel security, nor will it bring peace to the region. All it will do is boost hatred against Israel and therefore create greater insecurity.
Similarly, Hezbollah’s and Hamas’s attacks won’t free Lebanese and Palestinian land nor will they lead to peace. All they will do is increase hatred against them and convince Israel (as if that was necessary) that “Arabs know only the language of force”.
There will just be more destruction, more losses, more hatred . . . until the next war.
No one gains from war. No One! As an ideological movement “Islamic terrorism” cannot be defeated by force alone. This was demonstrated by the Red Brigades and ETA, shown in Algeria and Afghanistan, or is seen day after day in Iraq where hundreds of people still die after the US “liberation”. So what can be done?
“Get to the bottom of the problem”
Politicians say: “A ceasefire does not solve the problem.” That is true, but at least it will stop the violence in Israel and Lebanon.
Everyone says: “We must get to the bottom of the problem.” That is equally true.
Hezbollah, which usurped the Lebanese army’s role as defender of the country, is not the root of the problem. It did not exist when Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982. Hamas also is not the root of the problem, nor is Fatah. The attack against Israel at the 1972 Munich Olympic Games, which began the wave of terrorism in the region, is not the root of the problem.
The problem goes back to the creation of the State of Israel and the partition of Palestine in 1948. The Big Powers chose to partition the country in the wake of the organised and systematic persecution of the Jews but failed to take into account the populations already present in the (Holy) land. This is the real cause of all the wars that followed.
The partition is none the less a fact of history that was sanctioned by the international community. The existence of two states, Israel and Palestine, is a reality that finds its legitimacy in the United Nations and cannot be challenged.
Every wound inflicted on international legality carries an even greater evil. Hence any solution to the conflict that does not respect international legality, i.e. UN resolutions, will not bring peace.
Proposals for a final peace plan
As things stand right now, diplomacy is the only path to peace as long as it follows two rules: first, justice and respect for international legality; two, the need to make concessions which implies flexibility, thoughtfulness and willingness to surrender some of our rights for the sake of those of others.
We need a lasting solution, or better still, we need a final solution to the Mideast crisis so that together, slowly, we can build the peace and—if we are allowed to dream for a moment—a “Middle East Union”.
To reach that goal, I’ll layout the essential points of what I consider a just and realistic course of action:
1. A Palestinian state based on pre-1967 War boundaries with small changes, if necessary, as long as they are agreed upon by both Israel and Palestine.
2. Palestinians must give up the “right to return” and Israelis must give up their settlements in Palestinian territories. Small territorial adjustments might have to be made but only with the agreement of Israel and Palestine. The international community should compensate the parties for what they relinquish.
3. All the countries of the Middle East (including Turkey, Iran, Iraq, etc.) must officially recognise the borders of the region’s states as final and exchange ambassadors with them.
4. An international force “with teeth” should be deployed where peace is not fully implemented to prevent arms smuggling, especially between Israel and Palestine, Israel and Lebanon, Lebanon and Syria, Syria and Iraq, Iran and Iraq, and Turkey and Iraq.
5. Each state should receive assistance in setting up its own national army to disarm all groups, parties, settlers, etc.
6. Prisoners held by other countries should be freed. Exchange agreements should be reached, in particular between Israel, Palestine, Lebanon and Syria.
7. An international commission should be set up for Jerusalem to guarantee security within the city, freedom of movement and respect for the borders between the two states, both of which legitimately wish to have the city as their capital.
8. An international commission should be created to equitably solve water use in the region, which is an essential condition for development and often cause of friction and source of conflict.
The war currently underway, with its after-effects in terms of brutality and suffering, is letting millions of people, whatever their side, to come to the realisation that violence is pointless, that wars will not change the Middle East.
Realising this might be the only good thing coming out of this tragedy, which is being fought on the backs of the Lebanese people.
If from this tragedy a final peace plan can emerge, then this martyrdom may not have been in vain! Talks now taking place at the United Nations Security Council in New York might be the first steps in just such a direction.
Comment: Australia should suport this initiative. Currently we do not get involved in this crisis. I think that is a mistake. Australia has very good relations with all sides in the Middle East. We should put this to work.
Wednesday, August 09, 2006
Saudi Money Poisons The Muslims In Australia.
Note: This site has mentioned time after time that the supply of Saudi Arabian money to sunni muslim groups in Australia is the beachhead for poisoning the local muslims. This money, all linked with Wahhabi fascism, continues to flow into Australia despite any agreement that Government may have with the nine year olds in Canberra who run Australia's relations with the 'Islam Crisis'.
Read on...this posting from the Australian newspaper.
SAUDI Arabia has been secretly bankrolling the terror group responsible for killing 92 Australians in the two Bali bombings. US intelligence agencies have confirmed links between a Saudi charity, the International Islamic Relief Organisation, and the Indonesian terror group Jemaah Islamiah.
The IIRO is also registered in NSW under the name of Shafiq Rahman Abdullah Khan - a prominent member of Sydney's Muslim community who helps distribute Saudi government funds to Islamic projects in Australia.
However, Mr Khan insisted yesterday that the IIRO was not active in Australia.
"They never did open an office here and I am not representing them," he told The Australian.
The IIRO is not listed as a terrorist organisation in Australia, but in 2004 the Federal Government warned Saudi Arabia to alert it about all Saudi funds arriving in the country after ASIO expressed concern about how they might be used.
The US Treasury last Thursday publicly identified the Indonesian and Philippines offices of the Saudi government-sanctioned IIRO as "facilitating fundraising for al Qaeda and affiliated terrorist groups".
It has also identified a senior IIRO official in Saudi Arabia, Abd Al Hamid Sulaiman al-Mujil, of "using his position to bankroll the al Qeda network in South-East Asia".
It describes Mr Mujil as a "major fundraiser" for JI, the group that carried out the Bali bombings of 2002 and last year.
Comment: STOP SAUDI MONEY COMING INTO AUSTRALIA!
How hard can it be to do this? Why can't we get any adults involved with this problem?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Read on...this posting from the Australian newspaper.
SAUDI Arabia has been secretly bankrolling the terror group responsible for killing 92 Australians in the two Bali bombings. US intelligence agencies have confirmed links between a Saudi charity, the International Islamic Relief Organisation, and the Indonesian terror group Jemaah Islamiah.
The IIRO is also registered in NSW under the name of Shafiq Rahman Abdullah Khan - a prominent member of Sydney's Muslim community who helps distribute Saudi government funds to Islamic projects in Australia.
However, Mr Khan insisted yesterday that the IIRO was not active in Australia.
"They never did open an office here and I am not representing them," he told The Australian.
The IIRO is not listed as a terrorist organisation in Australia, but in 2004 the Federal Government warned Saudi Arabia to alert it about all Saudi funds arriving in the country after ASIO expressed concern about how they might be used.
The US Treasury last Thursday publicly identified the Indonesian and Philippines offices of the Saudi government-sanctioned IIRO as "facilitating fundraising for al Qaeda and affiliated terrorist groups".
It has also identified a senior IIRO official in Saudi Arabia, Abd Al Hamid Sulaiman al-Mujil, of "using his position to bankroll the al Qeda network in South-East Asia".
It describes Mr Mujil as a "major fundraiser" for JI, the group that carried out the Bali bombings of 2002 and last year.
Comment: STOP SAUDI MONEY COMING INTO AUSTRALIA!
How hard can it be to do this? Why can't we get any adults involved with this problem?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Tuesday, August 08, 2006
Background Information On Hezbollah.
Note: The religious divide in Islam is basically along the line of the majority Sunni and the minority Shia. Hezbollah are Shia like their masters in Iran. This information is important to read as one cannot begin to understand any of the complexities of the Middle East without some basic knowledge of Muslim religious sociology.
Read and learn...
ROMA, August 8, 2006 – Coming on the heel of one another, a book and an essay in “Foreign Affairs” by Vali Nasr, a report by Peter Waldman in “The Wall Street Journal” and an editorial in Italian daily “la Repubblica” by Khaled Fouad Allam are drawing attention to an historical shift now underway in the Islamic world: the Shia revival.
“The Shia revival” is in point of fact the title of Vali Nasr’s book on the issue. Born in Iran, the 46-year-old scholar is the son of another well-known expert on Islam from an important family that can trade its ancestry back to the prophet Muhammad. Both father and son lived in Tehran till Khomeini’s 1979 revolution upon which they immigrated to the United States. Vali Nasr’s father, Seyyed Hossein Nasr, teaches at George Washington University, while he is a professor at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, California.
In both his book – published in the United States by W.W. Norton & Co. – and his essay which appears in the July-August issue of “Foreign Affairs”, the prestigious US journal of geopolitics, Nasr substantiates his thesis with an impressive array of data.
The greatest novelty has occurred in Iraq, where majority Shiites were largely powerless till the fall of Saddam Hussein. No more! Now they occupy most command posts. The holy city of Najaf is now more than ever the religious capital of the world’s Shia community. From near and afar pilgrims come in increasing numbers to visit the shrines of Najaf and Karbala. And ties with Iran’s Shia regime are growing tighter as ever.
But similar changes are taking place in a wider area that runs from Lebanon to Central Asia. Power over Shia Islam is no longer a prerogative of Iran and Persians. From Iran and Iraq Shia power has spread to Lebanon thanks to the ‘Party of God’ – Hezbollah –, to Saudi Arabia, the Gulf States, Pakistan, and is taking in increasingly transnational forms. As Nasr writes in “Foreign Affairs”:
“Ethnic antagonism between Arabs and Persians cannot possibly be all-important when Iraq’s supreme religious leader Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani is Iranian and Iran’s chief justice Mahmoud Shahroudi, is Iraqi.”
Khaled Fouad Allam is an Algerian-born expert on Islam who now lives in Italy where he teaches at the universities of Trieste and Urbino. He is held in high esteem by the Church of Rome and what he has to say easily finds ears that listen. His analysis goes further than Nasr’s. Largely inspired by Khomeini’s revolution, the Shia revival is for the first time finding significant support amongst Sunni Arabs and threatens to spread across the entire Middle East. Politically, Iran might become what it never was in Khomeini’s lifetime, a great regional power.
So what is in store for international politics? In a report that appeared in the August 4 issue of the “The Wall Street Journal”, Peter Waldman writes that the Bush administration is increasingly paying attention to what Nasr is saying. Two White House foreign policy officials attended one of his conferences in Washington in early August and Condoleezza Rice had a meeting with him. “But his influence on U.S. policy is unclear,” for now.
Nasr argues that the United States must accept that Iran is going to play the role of regional power and ought to start talks with its leaders. Instead of trying to overthrow the regime in Tehran, it should work in ways to contain it.
In other words, Nasr is suggesting the US follow a realist policy of “containment.” This runs against the advice proffered by Bernard Lewis, an Islamic history specialist and hitherto the neo-Conservative voice with the greatest influence in the Bush administration, his idea being that the democratization of Iraq would lead to the collapse of neighboring dictatorships, first of all that of Iran.
In Nasr’s opinion, US policy has created in Iraq the first Shia-dominated Arab state, and this has unleashed the aspirations of 150 million Shiites around the world, and yet U.S. policy is still operating under the “old paradigm” based on Sunni predominance in the “Great Middle East”.
The Sunni-Shia split goes back to Muhammad’s death and the problem of his succession. Those who became “Shiites” were initially “Shi`at `Ali”, i.e. followers of Ali (in Arabic), the prophet’s son-in-law. Ali’s adversaries were able though to prevail and appoint the first three caliphs before he finally donned the prophet’s mantle. But in the end, he was still killed. His son Hussein was defeated and killed as well. But his martyrdom in what is now Iraq has left an indelible mark in Shiites’ memory – the commemoration of his death constitutes the most solemn religious observance in the Shia calendar. In addition to the issue of succession, Sunnis and Shiites come down on different sides on important matters of doctrine to the extent that some radical Sunni groups consider Shiites heretical.
In his “Foreign Affairs” essay, Nasr provides the following percentages indicating the size of the Shia population in various countries:
Iran 90 %
Azerbaijan 75%
Bahrain 75%
Iraq 65%
Lebanon 45%
Kuwait 30%
Pakistan 20%
Afghanistan 19%
Qatar 16%
Saudi Arabia 10%
United Arab Emirates 6%
Syria 1%
These percentages include only the main Twelver branch of Shia Islam. Other Shia groups include Alevis, well-represented in Turkey; Alawis, who run Syria thanks to the Assad clan, and the Ismailis, who recognize the Aga Khan as their leader and have a large community in Afghanistan and even a larger one in Pakistan.
The Holy See and Iran have regular diplomatic relations. Traditionally, Vatican diplomacy has been closer to the realist approach advocated by Vali Nasr rather than the “regime change” policy associated with US neo-conservatives.
Net surfers can read Nasr’s entire essay in the July-August issue of “Foreign Affairs” by visiting its website:
> “When the Shiites Rise”, by Vali Nasr
Comment: Australia is home to very many Shia muslims. It is therefore in our national interest to learn about them and give them particular help in the process of integration to Australia.
Read and learn...
ROMA, August 8, 2006 – Coming on the heel of one another, a book and an essay in “Foreign Affairs” by Vali Nasr, a report by Peter Waldman in “The Wall Street Journal” and an editorial in Italian daily “la Repubblica” by Khaled Fouad Allam are drawing attention to an historical shift now underway in the Islamic world: the Shia revival.
“The Shia revival” is in point of fact the title of Vali Nasr’s book on the issue. Born in Iran, the 46-year-old scholar is the son of another well-known expert on Islam from an important family that can trade its ancestry back to the prophet Muhammad. Both father and son lived in Tehran till Khomeini’s 1979 revolution upon which they immigrated to the United States. Vali Nasr’s father, Seyyed Hossein Nasr, teaches at George Washington University, while he is a professor at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, California.
In both his book – published in the United States by W.W. Norton & Co. – and his essay which appears in the July-August issue of “Foreign Affairs”, the prestigious US journal of geopolitics, Nasr substantiates his thesis with an impressive array of data.
The greatest novelty has occurred in Iraq, where majority Shiites were largely powerless till the fall of Saddam Hussein. No more! Now they occupy most command posts. The holy city of Najaf is now more than ever the religious capital of the world’s Shia community. From near and afar pilgrims come in increasing numbers to visit the shrines of Najaf and Karbala. And ties with Iran’s Shia regime are growing tighter as ever.
But similar changes are taking place in a wider area that runs from Lebanon to Central Asia. Power over Shia Islam is no longer a prerogative of Iran and Persians. From Iran and Iraq Shia power has spread to Lebanon thanks to the ‘Party of God’ – Hezbollah –, to Saudi Arabia, the Gulf States, Pakistan, and is taking in increasingly transnational forms. As Nasr writes in “Foreign Affairs”:
“Ethnic antagonism between Arabs and Persians cannot possibly be all-important when Iraq’s supreme religious leader Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani is Iranian and Iran’s chief justice Mahmoud Shahroudi, is Iraqi.”
Khaled Fouad Allam is an Algerian-born expert on Islam who now lives in Italy where he teaches at the universities of Trieste and Urbino. He is held in high esteem by the Church of Rome and what he has to say easily finds ears that listen. His analysis goes further than Nasr’s. Largely inspired by Khomeini’s revolution, the Shia revival is for the first time finding significant support amongst Sunni Arabs and threatens to spread across the entire Middle East. Politically, Iran might become what it never was in Khomeini’s lifetime, a great regional power.
So what is in store for international politics? In a report that appeared in the August 4 issue of the “The Wall Street Journal”, Peter Waldman writes that the Bush administration is increasingly paying attention to what Nasr is saying. Two White House foreign policy officials attended one of his conferences in Washington in early August and Condoleezza Rice had a meeting with him. “But his influence on U.S. policy is unclear,” for now.
Nasr argues that the United States must accept that Iran is going to play the role of regional power and ought to start talks with its leaders. Instead of trying to overthrow the regime in Tehran, it should work in ways to contain it.
In other words, Nasr is suggesting the US follow a realist policy of “containment.” This runs against the advice proffered by Bernard Lewis, an Islamic history specialist and hitherto the neo-Conservative voice with the greatest influence in the Bush administration, his idea being that the democratization of Iraq would lead to the collapse of neighboring dictatorships, first of all that of Iran.
In Nasr’s opinion, US policy has created in Iraq the first Shia-dominated Arab state, and this has unleashed the aspirations of 150 million Shiites around the world, and yet U.S. policy is still operating under the “old paradigm” based on Sunni predominance in the “Great Middle East”.
The Sunni-Shia split goes back to Muhammad’s death and the problem of his succession. Those who became “Shiites” were initially “Shi`at `Ali”, i.e. followers of Ali (in Arabic), the prophet’s son-in-law. Ali’s adversaries were able though to prevail and appoint the first three caliphs before he finally donned the prophet’s mantle. But in the end, he was still killed. His son Hussein was defeated and killed as well. But his martyrdom in what is now Iraq has left an indelible mark in Shiites’ memory – the commemoration of his death constitutes the most solemn religious observance in the Shia calendar. In addition to the issue of succession, Sunnis and Shiites come down on different sides on important matters of doctrine to the extent that some radical Sunni groups consider Shiites heretical.
In his “Foreign Affairs” essay, Nasr provides the following percentages indicating the size of the Shia population in various countries:
Iran 90 %
Azerbaijan 75%
Bahrain 75%
Iraq 65%
Lebanon 45%
Kuwait 30%
Pakistan 20%
Afghanistan 19%
Qatar 16%
Saudi Arabia 10%
United Arab Emirates 6%
Syria 1%
These percentages include only the main Twelver branch of Shia Islam. Other Shia groups include Alevis, well-represented in Turkey; Alawis, who run Syria thanks to the Assad clan, and the Ismailis, who recognize the Aga Khan as their leader and have a large community in Afghanistan and even a larger one in Pakistan.
The Holy See and Iran have regular diplomatic relations. Traditionally, Vatican diplomacy has been closer to the realist approach advocated by Vali Nasr rather than the “regime change” policy associated with US neo-conservatives.
Net surfers can read Nasr’s entire essay in the July-August issue of “Foreign Affairs” by visiting its website:
> “When the Shiites Rise”, by Vali Nasr
Comment: Australia is home to very many Shia muslims. It is therefore in our national interest to learn about them and give them particular help in the process of integration to Australia.
Pope Benedict And The War In Lebanon.
Note: Pope Benedict supports peace in the middle East. This is most proper. His remarks made in a recent interview need to be expanded. In the Christian world there is uniform support for both a Jewish State of Israel and an Arab State of Palestine. This is the crux of the UN Resolution 181 of November 1947.
In the Muslim world there is no such uniform support for the UN Resolution. How is it possible to overcome this dichotomy?
War is undoubtedly bad, but sometimes war is the only way to overcome a situation. Pope Benedict was a teenager at the time of the Second World War, so he has actual experience of Nazism. Was it possible to 'talk' Hitler out of his world view and the actions that followed this world view?
Read on...
Sat Aug 5, 2006.
CASTEL GANDOLFO, Italy (AFP) -Pope Benedict XVI appealed for "moral forces" to mobilize to bring peace to the troubled Middle East during another day of fierce bombardments in Lebanon and Israel.
"There are moral forces which are ready to make it understood that the only solution is that we must live together," Benedict said in an interview with several German radio and television stations ahead of his visit to his native country in September.
"These are the forces we want to mobilize. Politicians must find the way in order that this can happen as rapidly as possible and especially in a sustainable way," said Benedict in the interview at his summer residence in Castel Gandolfo, excerpts of which were released by the Vatican.
"Naturally the Holy See seeks no political power. But we want to address ourselves to Christians and everyone who feels in some way called on by words of the Holy See, in order that all the forces which recognize that the war is the worst solution for all are mobilized."
"It brings nothing good to anyone, not even for the apparent victors. We know that very well in Europe, following the two World Wars.
Comment: The core question in the Middle East is how can the world bring the muslim countries and people to accept the division of Mandatory Palestine into two states; Israel and Palestine?
This site supports the establishment of a legal State of Palestine (even without wide muslim acceptance of Israel)and considers it to be in Israel's best interest to allow this immediately.
Instead of seeking to get wide agreement on this issue, time should be allowed to heal wounds. This means that the Israelis and Palestinians must stop adding to these wounds; neither side is currently doing this.
Australia, which was the first country in the world, at the UN, to vote for the division of Mandatory Palestine in November 1947, could do a lot of good work on the ground in both Israel and Occupied Palestine (to use Prime Minister Sharon's description)to help these wounds to slowly bind. We should do so, as a moral requirement on our part.
In the Muslim world there is no such uniform support for the UN Resolution. How is it possible to overcome this dichotomy?
War is undoubtedly bad, but sometimes war is the only way to overcome a situation. Pope Benedict was a teenager at the time of the Second World War, so he has actual experience of Nazism. Was it possible to 'talk' Hitler out of his world view and the actions that followed this world view?
Read on...
Sat Aug 5, 2006.
CASTEL GANDOLFO, Italy (AFP) -Pope Benedict XVI appealed for "moral forces" to mobilize to bring peace to the troubled Middle East during another day of fierce bombardments in Lebanon and Israel.
"There are moral forces which are ready to make it understood that the only solution is that we must live together," Benedict said in an interview with several German radio and television stations ahead of his visit to his native country in September.
"These are the forces we want to mobilize. Politicians must find the way in order that this can happen as rapidly as possible and especially in a sustainable way," said Benedict in the interview at his summer residence in Castel Gandolfo, excerpts of which were released by the Vatican.
"Naturally the Holy See seeks no political power. But we want to address ourselves to Christians and everyone who feels in some way called on by words of the Holy See, in order that all the forces which recognize that the war is the worst solution for all are mobilized."
"It brings nothing good to anyone, not even for the apparent victors. We know that very well in Europe, following the two World Wars.
Comment: The core question in the Middle East is how can the world bring the muslim countries and people to accept the division of Mandatory Palestine into two states; Israel and Palestine?
This site supports the establishment of a legal State of Palestine (even without wide muslim acceptance of Israel)and considers it to be in Israel's best interest to allow this immediately.
Instead of seeking to get wide agreement on this issue, time should be allowed to heal wounds. This means that the Israelis and Palestinians must stop adding to these wounds; neither side is currently doing this.
Australia, which was the first country in the world, at the UN, to vote for the division of Mandatory Palestine in November 1947, could do a lot of good work on the ground in both Israel and Occupied Palestine (to use Prime Minister Sharon's description)to help these wounds to slowly bind. We should do so, as a moral requirement on our part.
Monday, August 07, 2006
Real Islam At Work.
Note: The major non muslim defence of Islam in the West comes from the political Left. they are very mistaken to do so; Islam does not support any of the core Left positions in Western politics and society. This posting is a prime example of what the Left is actually supporting when they rush to the defence of REAL ISLAM.
Read and learn....
Gays flee Iraq as Shia death squads find a new target
Evidence shows increase in number of executions as homosexuals plead for asylum in Britain
Jennifer Copestake
Sunday August 6, 2006
The Observer
Hardline Islamic insurgent groups in Iraq are targeting a new type of victim with the full protection of Iraqi law, The Observer can reveal. The country is seeing a sudden escalation of brutal attacks on what are being called the 'immorals' - homosexual men and children as young as 11 who have been forced into same-sex prostitution.
There is growing evidence that Shia militias have been killing men suspected of being gay and children who have been sold to criminal gangs to be sexually abused. The threat has led to a rapid increase in the numbers of Iraqi homosexuals now seeking asylum in the UK because it has become impossible for them to live safely in their own country.
Ali Hili runs the Iraqi LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender) group out of London. He used to have 40 volunteers in Iraq but says after recent raids by militia in Najaf, Karbala and Basra he has lost contact with half of them. They move to different safe houses to protect their identities, but their work is incredibly dangerous.
Eleven-year-old Ameer Hasoon al-Hasani was kidnapped by policemen from the front of his house last month. He was known in his district to have been forced into prostitution. His father Hassan told me he searched for his son for three days after his abduction, then found him, shot in the head. A copy of the death certificate confirms the cause of death.
Homosexuality is seen as so immoral that it qualifies as an 'honour killing' to murder someone who is gay - and the perpetrator can escape punishment. Section 111 of Iraq's penal code lays out protections for murder when people are acting against Islam.
'The government will do nothing to tackle this issue. It's really desperate when people get to the stage they're trading their children for money. They have no alternatives because there are no jobs,' Hili says.
Graphic photos obtained from Baghdad sources too frightened to identify themselves as having known a gay man, and seen by the Observer, show other gay Iraqis who have been executed. One shows two men, suspected of having a relationship, blindfolded with their hands tied behind their backs - guns at the ready behind their heads - awaiting execution. Another picture captured on a mobile phone shows a gay man being beaten to death. Yet another shows a corpse being dragged through the streets after his execution.
One photograph is of the mutilated, burnt body of 38-year-old Karar Oda from Sadr City. He was kidnapped by the Badr Brigade in mid-June. They work with the Ministry of Interior and are the informal armed wing of the Supreme Council of Islamic Revolution in Iraq, who make up the largest Shia bloc in the Iraq parliament. Oda's family were given an arrest warrant signed by the Ministry of Interior which said their son deserved to be arrested and killed for immorality as a homosexual. His body was found ten days later.
Dr Haider Jaber is currently seeking asylum in the UK after fleeing Iraq in 2004. He says the abuse started to escalate in his neighbourhood after the invasion. One night, walking home from work, he was surrounded by five men, who told him he had to become a heterosexual Muslim. He says they abused him for wearing jeans and a T-shirt with English writing, and told him he should adopt traditional robes. As a crowd gathered to watch, he was then beaten and kicked to the ground.
The threats continued. Armed militiamen broke into his family home and then his workplace looking for him. Jaber finally left the country in April. His partner, Ali. was not so lucky. Jaber learned of his Ali's murder a few days after leaving Iraq. 'They didn't send the body to the family to have a grave or a flower garden. They said he didn't deserve it because he was an animal,' he said.
Ibaa Alawi has also fled Iraq. A former employee at the British embassy in Baghdad, Alawi met Tony Blair on one of his surprise visits to Iraq. He said Blair was concerned about the safety of the Iraqis working there and praised their bravery. 'Tony Blair said the British government was thankful for our efforts and knew we were putting our lives at risk working for the British embassy in Baghdad.'
Alawi is upset the same government is not willing to help him out. He believes the Home Office will refuse him asylum because it would have to face up to the level of chaos in Iraq, and how much influence is being waged by radical Islamists - and face the fact that, for some, there is still no freedom in Iraq.
Comment: This sort of behaviour is not a surprise to those of us who have real world experience of islamist muslims at work. With so many people trying to get into Australia why let in Muslims? They will only bring these murderous attitudes to our country.
Australia does not have a muslim attitude to a whole range of social situations; homosexuality is just one of these situations. Why introduce to Australia people who have such primitive views? Are there not many non problematic people we can admit?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Read and learn....
Gays flee Iraq as Shia death squads find a new target
Evidence shows increase in number of executions as homosexuals plead for asylum in Britain
Jennifer Copestake
Sunday August 6, 2006
The Observer
Hardline Islamic insurgent groups in Iraq are targeting a new type of victim with the full protection of Iraqi law, The Observer can reveal. The country is seeing a sudden escalation of brutal attacks on what are being called the 'immorals' - homosexual men and children as young as 11 who have been forced into same-sex prostitution.
There is growing evidence that Shia militias have been killing men suspected of being gay and children who have been sold to criminal gangs to be sexually abused. The threat has led to a rapid increase in the numbers of Iraqi homosexuals now seeking asylum in the UK because it has become impossible for them to live safely in their own country.
Ali Hili runs the Iraqi LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender) group out of London. He used to have 40 volunteers in Iraq but says after recent raids by militia in Najaf, Karbala and Basra he has lost contact with half of them. They move to different safe houses to protect their identities, but their work is incredibly dangerous.
Eleven-year-old Ameer Hasoon al-Hasani was kidnapped by policemen from the front of his house last month. He was known in his district to have been forced into prostitution. His father Hassan told me he searched for his son for three days after his abduction, then found him, shot in the head. A copy of the death certificate confirms the cause of death.
Homosexuality is seen as so immoral that it qualifies as an 'honour killing' to murder someone who is gay - and the perpetrator can escape punishment. Section 111 of Iraq's penal code lays out protections for murder when people are acting against Islam.
'The government will do nothing to tackle this issue. It's really desperate when people get to the stage they're trading their children for money. They have no alternatives because there are no jobs,' Hili says.
Graphic photos obtained from Baghdad sources too frightened to identify themselves as having known a gay man, and seen by the Observer, show other gay Iraqis who have been executed. One shows two men, suspected of having a relationship, blindfolded with their hands tied behind their backs - guns at the ready behind their heads - awaiting execution. Another picture captured on a mobile phone shows a gay man being beaten to death. Yet another shows a corpse being dragged through the streets after his execution.
One photograph is of the mutilated, burnt body of 38-year-old Karar Oda from Sadr City. He was kidnapped by the Badr Brigade in mid-June. They work with the Ministry of Interior and are the informal armed wing of the Supreme Council of Islamic Revolution in Iraq, who make up the largest Shia bloc in the Iraq parliament. Oda's family were given an arrest warrant signed by the Ministry of Interior which said their son deserved to be arrested and killed for immorality as a homosexual. His body was found ten days later.
Dr Haider Jaber is currently seeking asylum in the UK after fleeing Iraq in 2004. He says the abuse started to escalate in his neighbourhood after the invasion. One night, walking home from work, he was surrounded by five men, who told him he had to become a heterosexual Muslim. He says they abused him for wearing jeans and a T-shirt with English writing, and told him he should adopt traditional robes. As a crowd gathered to watch, he was then beaten and kicked to the ground.
The threats continued. Armed militiamen broke into his family home and then his workplace looking for him. Jaber finally left the country in April. His partner, Ali. was not so lucky. Jaber learned of his Ali's murder a few days after leaving Iraq. 'They didn't send the body to the family to have a grave or a flower garden. They said he didn't deserve it because he was an animal,' he said.
Ibaa Alawi has also fled Iraq. A former employee at the British embassy in Baghdad, Alawi met Tony Blair on one of his surprise visits to Iraq. He said Blair was concerned about the safety of the Iraqis working there and praised their bravery. 'Tony Blair said the British government was thankful for our efforts and knew we were putting our lives at risk working for the British embassy in Baghdad.'
Alawi is upset the same government is not willing to help him out. He believes the Home Office will refuse him asylum because it would have to face up to the level of chaos in Iraq, and how much influence is being waged by radical Islamists - and face the fact that, for some, there is still no freedom in Iraq.
Comment: This sort of behaviour is not a surprise to those of us who have real world experience of islamist muslims at work. With so many people trying to get into Australia why let in Muslims? They will only bring these murderous attitudes to our country.
Australia does not have a muslim attitude to a whole range of social situations; homosexuality is just one of these situations. Why introduce to Australia people who have such primitive views? Are there not many non problematic people we can admit?
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Sunday, August 06, 2006
Analysis Of The War In Lebanon by Egyptian Jesuit.
Note: Fr. Samir SJ is a major Catholic scholar of Islam. He is currently in Lebanon teaching. His observations are well worth reading...
5 August, 2006
LEBANON – ISRAEL – MIDDLE EAST
Lebanon’s nightmare: hostage to war, Israel and Hezbollah
by Samir Khalil Samir, sj
Israel’s military reaction cannot beat terrorism; all it can do is increased hatred. Hezbollah’s claims are unforgivable and are causing Lebanon’s destruction. Christians are paying the highest price for the violence, as not even the international community seems ready to deal with the core issues of the Middle East crisis: a homeland for the Palestinians, security for Israel, a return to the borders set by the United Nations. Here is the analysis by Fr Samir Khalil, an Egyptian-born Jesuit; now a professor in Beirut.
Beirut (AsiaNews) – A year and half ago Lebanon was reborn in a peaceful and joyful Intifada as people took to the streets and forced Syrian troops to pull out after 30 years of occupation. Today, the people of Lebanon is reliving once more the nightmare of war. The disenchantment is tremendous, rage and even hatred much greater.
A very good Christian woman who is far from being politicised wrote to me expressing great anger at Israel. Even though she is rock-solidly against Hezbollah, but with a million Lebanese on the run and means of communications in tatters, her hatred for the new invader has grown boundless. Tersely, she told me what she thought of the situation. “For two hostages, Israel has taken the whole of Lebanon hostage.”
Someone else told me: “Instead of attacking its real enemies, Iran and Syria, Israel preferred to destroy an innocent and peaceful country because it is weak.”
Even the soldier abducted by Hamas in Gaza has given Israel the pretext to bomb, demolish and destroy Gaza. In the name of security and survival, Israel seems to be throwing everything at its disposal at its neighbours in order to destroy them—all this with the backing of the most powerful countries in the world.
I would personally use all my strength to fight for the security of Israel, but I ask myself. Does Israel need security so much? Shouldn’t its Palestinian, Lebanese and Syrian neighbours get at least as much security?
A wrong and entirely disproportionate reaction
In three weeks almost a quarter of the Lebanese population was forced to flee. Nothing like it happened during the civil war. Israel’s extreme blind violence has already killed 900 people and injured another 3,000, whilst suffering 64 dead, 24 of them civilians.
When Israel’s reaction is said to be disproportionate it is just a statement of fact, not an emotional outburst. Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said: “We want to uproot Hezbollah’s terrorism”. But was it necessary to destroy an entire country to get at Hezbollah. Was it necessary to destroy all of the main roads, the bridges, Beirut’s recently renovated Rafik Hariri International Airport, the highway to Syria, the power station, three ports, a milk factory, etc., only because Hezbollah might have used them? If this is goes on, nothing will be left in Lebanon!
More to the point, how can terrorism be uprooted? The experience of the last five years has shown that the fight against terrorism cannot be pursued by military means alone. On the contrary, with the illegal invasion of Iraq terrorism has spread and proliferated. The roots of terrorism are not military, but ideological, cultural and some times spiritual. This is what must be uprooted.
Hezbollah’s actions are unforgivable
I have never accepted Hezbollah’s claim that it had a mission to defend the homeland; only the army has.
Hezbollah is the only armed militia left standing after the civil war ended in 1991. The party’s position is unacceptable. The recent UN Resolution 1559, which calls for the demilitarisation of all armed groups in the country, must be implemented.
It is necessary to know a bit of Hezbollah’s history to understand how much it is an anomaly.
Like other militias, Hezbollah emerged during the civil war, but unlike them, it was created in the wake of Israel’s second invasion of Lebanon in 1982.
Officially, it was founded on February 16, 1985, but in fact it was set up on November 22, 1982. Its mission was to free the southern parts of the country—where many Shiites live—from the invader.
This is one of the essential factors that fuel Mideast Islamic terrorism: respond to the terrorism and the continuous attacks by the State of Israel, and above all its occupation of non-Israeli territories.
Israel’s almost 40-year-old occupation of Palestine is one of the fundamental causes of Middle Eastern Islamic terrorism.
In the name of security Israel has engaged in expansionist wars to enlarge its territory. Comparing the territory assigned by the United Nations to Israel in 1947 to that of 1948-49, 1956 (attack against Egypt over Suez), 1967 (Six Day War), and today, it is clear that Israel has always increased its territory, doubling it. All this was done illegally, i.e. without the approval of the United Nations, the only international body that can give legitimacy to a nation.
At any rate, under occupation part of the population became galvanised by the idea of taking revenge against Israel (encouraged by false Islamic arguments) and at least initially backed and expressed sympathy for Hezbollah.
It must also be said that even if Hezbollah was right in provoking Israel (I don’t think it was), its action was unforgivably stupid from a strategic point of view. Its provocation has resulted in hundreds of dead and above all in the destruction of the country which was rebuilding itself for the past 15 years from the ruins left by the civil war.
Lebanon is now nearly all destroyed. Reconstruction will require billions of euros and who knows how much time.
The one economic activity it had going for it was tourism. But tourists have now fled and no one knows when they will be back.
The country’s situation is catastrophic. The population’s morale is at its lowest.
The international community has abandoned Lebanon
The international community has always said that it was concerned about the fate of Lebanon. But what does that mean? In politics, deeds are what count.
Right now the UN and European proposal of sending an international force to guarantee a ceasefire is the one that makes most sense, but I am afraid that it will take a lot of time to be implemented.
Israel is bent on going ahead with its plans and claims the right to do so, backed by some powers, especially the United States, which has unconditionally lined up behind it.
In their own way, the G8 countries have justified the war by only criticising Israel’s excessive use of force rather than condemning its action altogether.
The problem is not the excessive reaction but the reaction itself. No one has the right to use a pretext to make war. There is a qualitative difference between Hezbollah’s provocation and a war that involves the use of air and naval power as well as tanks. Lebanon did not send in its army. On the contrary, the Lebanese government knew nothing of Hezbollah’s actions. What is more, attacks by both sides in southern Lebanon were not something new. So why such a violent reaction this time?
Addressing the underlying problems and finding lasting solutions
Right now it is urgent and necessary to get a ceasefire and UN troops deployed. With a lot of difficulties the international community is trying to find ways to implement it. But it is really important to stop this unjustifiable war.
In a balanced statement, the Vatican secretary of State Cardinal Sodano said on July 14:
“As in the past, the Holy See also condemns both the terrorist attacks on the one side and the military reprisals on the other. Indeed, a state's right to self-defence does not exempt it from respecting the norms of international law, especially as regards the protection of civilian populations. In particular, the Holy See deplores the attack on Lebanon, a free and sovereign nation, and gives assurances of its closeness to those people who have suffered so much in the defence of their own independence.”
However, the war will start all over again at the first opportunity if there is no international multilateral solution (and not unilateral as was the case for Lebanon and Gaza) that recognises the rights of Israel and Palestine. The Pope said this to the diplomatic corps last January 9. In the Holy land, “the state of Israel has to be able to exist peacefully in conformity with the norms of international law; there, equally, the Palestinian population has to be able to develop serenely its own democratic institutions for a free and prosperous future.”
Unfortunately, the international community seems to be distracted by other problems. Everyone is more concerned that whatever choices are made they do not impact one or the other party. It seems that in the end there is no desire to find a solution to the underlying problems.
This war might be stopped, but if no solution is found for the root causes, there will be another one soon, and then another.
We must have the courage to find a lasting solution. This problem has been going on for decades and it is like a cancer that is always mutating.
Any radical solution must be based on international law. This means implementing Resolution 242, which requires all parties to pull back to their internationally recognised boundaries, then Resolution 1559, which calls for the demilitarisation of all Lebanese militias (like Hezbollah’s). It also means that Arab states must recognise Israel within its international borders, and Israel must recognise its neighbouring states (Egypt, Palestine, Lebanon and Syria) within their own international borders. All sides will then be able to exchange ambassadors (let us not forget that Syria has never recognised Lebanon’s international borders nor exchanged ambassadors). Only then shall peace be possible.
Lebanon’s Christians
The Christian community is under shock. To the last man and woman, it was always in favour of the country’s total independence and for this it has fought against Syria and paid a hefty price. With the exception of Hariri’s assassination, since Syria’s pullout last year, all murders involved Christian leaders.
Christians have always called for Hezbollah’s disarmament, but because of Syria’s influence have failed to achieve it. They know that as long as Hezbollah’s armed militias are allowed to exist, the agreements and the authority of the state will be flouted—which is what happened.
Now they have to live with the bombs or find refuge in some other country. Then again Christians cannot find refuge in neighbouring countries because they are all Muslim. For many, safety is in Europe and America. But unlike those who do go to Muslim countries, when Christians opt for the West it is a one-way journey and few come back.
The situation is so terrible that, as the Maronite bishop of Jbeil said, “more than 70 per cent of Christians still living in Lebanon want to leave as soon as Beirut International Airport opens”.
Our community will come out of this war even weaker, especially since terrorist violence is undeniably all by Islamic groups. Once again Christians are paying the highest price for Mideast violence.
At least one good thing has come out of this tragedy, namely the solidarity between Muslims and Christians. Outside aggression has brought together all of the nation’s communities. Christians have opened their churches, monasteries and schools to the refugees, whoever they may be, whatever their religion. And this is a beautiful thing to witness.
Comment: This site has constantly called for the establishment in Australia of a government funded lecture circuit on general middle east matters. This would include liberal minded reformists among muslim scholars and serious non muslim scholars of islam. Until Australians can hear such people we will remain unaware of the possibilities that exist for improvements in Islam and for muslim communities in Australia. Fr. Samir SJ should be brought to Australia to speak at Universities and to members of Parliament.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
5 August, 2006
LEBANON – ISRAEL – MIDDLE EAST
Lebanon’s nightmare: hostage to war, Israel and Hezbollah
by Samir Khalil Samir, sj
Israel’s military reaction cannot beat terrorism; all it can do is increased hatred. Hezbollah’s claims are unforgivable and are causing Lebanon’s destruction. Christians are paying the highest price for the violence, as not even the international community seems ready to deal with the core issues of the Middle East crisis: a homeland for the Palestinians, security for Israel, a return to the borders set by the United Nations. Here is the analysis by Fr Samir Khalil, an Egyptian-born Jesuit; now a professor in Beirut.
Beirut (AsiaNews) – A year and half ago Lebanon was reborn in a peaceful and joyful Intifada as people took to the streets and forced Syrian troops to pull out after 30 years of occupation. Today, the people of Lebanon is reliving once more the nightmare of war. The disenchantment is tremendous, rage and even hatred much greater.
A very good Christian woman who is far from being politicised wrote to me expressing great anger at Israel. Even though she is rock-solidly against Hezbollah, but with a million Lebanese on the run and means of communications in tatters, her hatred for the new invader has grown boundless. Tersely, she told me what she thought of the situation. “For two hostages, Israel has taken the whole of Lebanon hostage.”
Someone else told me: “Instead of attacking its real enemies, Iran and Syria, Israel preferred to destroy an innocent and peaceful country because it is weak.”
Even the soldier abducted by Hamas in Gaza has given Israel the pretext to bomb, demolish and destroy Gaza. In the name of security and survival, Israel seems to be throwing everything at its disposal at its neighbours in order to destroy them—all this with the backing of the most powerful countries in the world.
I would personally use all my strength to fight for the security of Israel, but I ask myself. Does Israel need security so much? Shouldn’t its Palestinian, Lebanese and Syrian neighbours get at least as much security?
A wrong and entirely disproportionate reaction
In three weeks almost a quarter of the Lebanese population was forced to flee. Nothing like it happened during the civil war. Israel’s extreme blind violence has already killed 900 people and injured another 3,000, whilst suffering 64 dead, 24 of them civilians.
When Israel’s reaction is said to be disproportionate it is just a statement of fact, not an emotional outburst. Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said: “We want to uproot Hezbollah’s terrorism”. But was it necessary to destroy an entire country to get at Hezbollah. Was it necessary to destroy all of the main roads, the bridges, Beirut’s recently renovated Rafik Hariri International Airport, the highway to Syria, the power station, three ports, a milk factory, etc., only because Hezbollah might have used them? If this is goes on, nothing will be left in Lebanon!
More to the point, how can terrorism be uprooted? The experience of the last five years has shown that the fight against terrorism cannot be pursued by military means alone. On the contrary, with the illegal invasion of Iraq terrorism has spread and proliferated. The roots of terrorism are not military, but ideological, cultural and some times spiritual. This is what must be uprooted.
Hezbollah’s actions are unforgivable
I have never accepted Hezbollah’s claim that it had a mission to defend the homeland; only the army has.
Hezbollah is the only armed militia left standing after the civil war ended in 1991. The party’s position is unacceptable. The recent UN Resolution 1559, which calls for the demilitarisation of all armed groups in the country, must be implemented.
It is necessary to know a bit of Hezbollah’s history to understand how much it is an anomaly.
Like other militias, Hezbollah emerged during the civil war, but unlike them, it was created in the wake of Israel’s second invasion of Lebanon in 1982.
Officially, it was founded on February 16, 1985, but in fact it was set up on November 22, 1982. Its mission was to free the southern parts of the country—where many Shiites live—from the invader.
This is one of the essential factors that fuel Mideast Islamic terrorism: respond to the terrorism and the continuous attacks by the State of Israel, and above all its occupation of non-Israeli territories.
Israel’s almost 40-year-old occupation of Palestine is one of the fundamental causes of Middle Eastern Islamic terrorism.
In the name of security Israel has engaged in expansionist wars to enlarge its territory. Comparing the territory assigned by the United Nations to Israel in 1947 to that of 1948-49, 1956 (attack against Egypt over Suez), 1967 (Six Day War), and today, it is clear that Israel has always increased its territory, doubling it. All this was done illegally, i.e. without the approval of the United Nations, the only international body that can give legitimacy to a nation.
At any rate, under occupation part of the population became galvanised by the idea of taking revenge against Israel (encouraged by false Islamic arguments) and at least initially backed and expressed sympathy for Hezbollah.
It must also be said that even if Hezbollah was right in provoking Israel (I don’t think it was), its action was unforgivably stupid from a strategic point of view. Its provocation has resulted in hundreds of dead and above all in the destruction of the country which was rebuilding itself for the past 15 years from the ruins left by the civil war.
Lebanon is now nearly all destroyed. Reconstruction will require billions of euros and who knows how much time.
The one economic activity it had going for it was tourism. But tourists have now fled and no one knows when they will be back.
The country’s situation is catastrophic. The population’s morale is at its lowest.
The international community has abandoned Lebanon
The international community has always said that it was concerned about the fate of Lebanon. But what does that mean? In politics, deeds are what count.
Right now the UN and European proposal of sending an international force to guarantee a ceasefire is the one that makes most sense, but I am afraid that it will take a lot of time to be implemented.
Israel is bent on going ahead with its plans and claims the right to do so, backed by some powers, especially the United States, which has unconditionally lined up behind it.
In their own way, the G8 countries have justified the war by only criticising Israel’s excessive use of force rather than condemning its action altogether.
The problem is not the excessive reaction but the reaction itself. No one has the right to use a pretext to make war. There is a qualitative difference between Hezbollah’s provocation and a war that involves the use of air and naval power as well as tanks. Lebanon did not send in its army. On the contrary, the Lebanese government knew nothing of Hezbollah’s actions. What is more, attacks by both sides in southern Lebanon were not something new. So why such a violent reaction this time?
Addressing the underlying problems and finding lasting solutions
Right now it is urgent and necessary to get a ceasefire and UN troops deployed. With a lot of difficulties the international community is trying to find ways to implement it. But it is really important to stop this unjustifiable war.
In a balanced statement, the Vatican secretary of State Cardinal Sodano said on July 14:
“As in the past, the Holy See also condemns both the terrorist attacks on the one side and the military reprisals on the other. Indeed, a state's right to self-defence does not exempt it from respecting the norms of international law, especially as regards the protection of civilian populations. In particular, the Holy See deplores the attack on Lebanon, a free and sovereign nation, and gives assurances of its closeness to those people who have suffered so much in the defence of their own independence.”
However, the war will start all over again at the first opportunity if there is no international multilateral solution (and not unilateral as was the case for Lebanon and Gaza) that recognises the rights of Israel and Palestine. The Pope said this to the diplomatic corps last January 9. In the Holy land, “the state of Israel has to be able to exist peacefully in conformity with the norms of international law; there, equally, the Palestinian population has to be able to develop serenely its own democratic institutions for a free and prosperous future.”
Unfortunately, the international community seems to be distracted by other problems. Everyone is more concerned that whatever choices are made they do not impact one or the other party. It seems that in the end there is no desire to find a solution to the underlying problems.
This war might be stopped, but if no solution is found for the root causes, there will be another one soon, and then another.
We must have the courage to find a lasting solution. This problem has been going on for decades and it is like a cancer that is always mutating.
Any radical solution must be based on international law. This means implementing Resolution 242, which requires all parties to pull back to their internationally recognised boundaries, then Resolution 1559, which calls for the demilitarisation of all Lebanese militias (like Hezbollah’s). It also means that Arab states must recognise Israel within its international borders, and Israel must recognise its neighbouring states (Egypt, Palestine, Lebanon and Syria) within their own international borders. All sides will then be able to exchange ambassadors (let us not forget that Syria has never recognised Lebanon’s international borders nor exchanged ambassadors). Only then shall peace be possible.
Lebanon’s Christians
The Christian community is under shock. To the last man and woman, it was always in favour of the country’s total independence and for this it has fought against Syria and paid a hefty price. With the exception of Hariri’s assassination, since Syria’s pullout last year, all murders involved Christian leaders.
Christians have always called for Hezbollah’s disarmament, but because of Syria’s influence have failed to achieve it. They know that as long as Hezbollah’s armed militias are allowed to exist, the agreements and the authority of the state will be flouted—which is what happened.
Now they have to live with the bombs or find refuge in some other country. Then again Christians cannot find refuge in neighbouring countries because they are all Muslim. For many, safety is in Europe and America. But unlike those who do go to Muslim countries, when Christians opt for the West it is a one-way journey and few come back.
The situation is so terrible that, as the Maronite bishop of Jbeil said, “more than 70 per cent of Christians still living in Lebanon want to leave as soon as Beirut International Airport opens”.
Our community will come out of this war even weaker, especially since terrorist violence is undeniably all by Islamic groups. Once again Christians are paying the highest price for Mideast violence.
At least one good thing has come out of this tragedy, namely the solidarity between Muslims and Christians. Outside aggression has brought together all of the nation’s communities. Christians have opened their churches, monasteries and schools to the refugees, whoever they may be, whatever their religion. And this is a beautiful thing to witness.
Comment: This site has constantly called for the establishment in Australia of a government funded lecture circuit on general middle east matters. This would include liberal minded reformists among muslim scholars and serious non muslim scholars of islam. Until Australians can hear such people we will remain unaware of the possibilities that exist for improvements in Islam and for muslim communities in Australia. Fr. Samir SJ should be brought to Australia to speak at Universities and to members of Parliament.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Saturday, August 05, 2006
Princely Words From A Proper Muslim.
Note: These words are fully endorsed by this site. I recommend them to all readers.
The events of the past three weeks have brought us to the edge of the abyss. They are the result not of timeless and inevitable conflict, but of intransigence, fear and a shocking lack of creativity by leaders in our region and beyond. The indiscriminate loss of life on all sides has polarised our populations and shown diplomacy for the devalued and scorned art it has become. The focus on polemics and the ensuing escalation of violence has sidelined the very real and dangerous concerns that underlie our region’s spiralling decline.
Aggressive ideology is nurtured by an increasing lack of economic equality, poor social mobility, a denial to many of human security and the exclusion of the silenced majority. It is evident to us all that military might cannot cure the evils of our region. Violence begets violence and the mass bombings of civilians can only result in increased use of terror tactics further down the line.
It has become exceedingly clear that the current crisis requires the application of a two-fold solution if we are ever to hope for a secure and stable peace for all our citizens. The conflicts that rule our daily lives must be addressed at the political level but we cannot afford to ignore the effects of military overkill on basic humanitarian issues. Human rights are the first casualties of war and the degradation of human dignity in our region has undone generations of agreement and convention on the rights of civilians to protection and well-being. The anger and trauma created by hundreds of dead and injured and the displacement of hundreds of thousands of civilians so far can only have violent repercussions for a hitherto democratic, pluralistic and multicultural Lebanon reality. The shockwaves are felt by our entire region.
The continued reliance on violence to tackle problems created by a ruthless ignorance of the right to economic and existential security of civilian populations can only succeed in handing over to extremists on all sides the power to represent our grievances. A Conference for Security and Cooperation in the region must be a priority for our leaders if human security is ever to become a reality. Diplomatic avenues must be opened and explored and this arduous process should include Syria and Iran. War and its tragic repercussions are inclusive of all — surely a model for peace should strive for such inclusiveness.
In memory of my late brother, HM King Hussein, and of PM Yitzhak Rabin, we must strive not to wage wars, but to win peace. Real peace must be built, it is not just the absence of war. We need to immediately call a Conference for Security and Cooperation to talk about the endgame, to develop regional understanding, to address the energy issue that is at the heart of so much instability and to devise a multilateral approach to such thorny issues as the proliferation of WMD, together with a regional concept for human rights, prosperity and security. Ideally, it could lead to a regional Code of Conduct and a Cohesion Fund that establishes principles of common interest, responsibility, transparency and a collective defence identity, reflecting the fact that interdependency is the reality today. Anthro-centric policies, policies where people matter, is the way to close the human dignity divide. Through good governance, we must empower the poor and dispossessed who find expression for their frustrations in extremist ideology.
The international community must firmly commit to supplanting unilateralist policies with regional strategies with the final aim of drawing up a comprehensive Regional Stabilisation Pact. The sooner a cessation of hostilities is achieved and international peacekeeping forces are deployed on both sides of the border, the sooner a collective strive towards institutionalised regional stability can begin. I cannot emphasise enough the need for diplomacy to transpose violence and this call echoes President Eisenhower’s appeal that the “table, though scarred by many past frustrations, cannot be abandoned for the certain agony of the battlefield.”
###
* Prince El Hassan bin Talal, brother of the late King Hussein of Jordan, is chairman of several organizations in fields which include diplomacy, interfaith studies, human resources, and science and technology.
Comment: Australia should endorse this call by Prince Hassan of Jordan. Australia has been actively involved with the Middle East since the time of the First World War; Australian troops under Colonel Chauvel conquered Damascus from the Turks in 1917. Lawrence of Arabia arrived in Damascus the following day, after the Australians had secured it.
We have a long involvement and we should continue it.
The events of the past three weeks have brought us to the edge of the abyss. They are the result not of timeless and inevitable conflict, but of intransigence, fear and a shocking lack of creativity by leaders in our region and beyond. The indiscriminate loss of life on all sides has polarised our populations and shown diplomacy for the devalued and scorned art it has become. The focus on polemics and the ensuing escalation of violence has sidelined the very real and dangerous concerns that underlie our region’s spiralling decline.
Aggressive ideology is nurtured by an increasing lack of economic equality, poor social mobility, a denial to many of human security and the exclusion of the silenced majority. It is evident to us all that military might cannot cure the evils of our region. Violence begets violence and the mass bombings of civilians can only result in increased use of terror tactics further down the line.
It has become exceedingly clear that the current crisis requires the application of a two-fold solution if we are ever to hope for a secure and stable peace for all our citizens. The conflicts that rule our daily lives must be addressed at the political level but we cannot afford to ignore the effects of military overkill on basic humanitarian issues. Human rights are the first casualties of war and the degradation of human dignity in our region has undone generations of agreement and convention on the rights of civilians to protection and well-being. The anger and trauma created by hundreds of dead and injured and the displacement of hundreds of thousands of civilians so far can only have violent repercussions for a hitherto democratic, pluralistic and multicultural Lebanon reality. The shockwaves are felt by our entire region.
The continued reliance on violence to tackle problems created by a ruthless ignorance of the right to economic and existential security of civilian populations can only succeed in handing over to extremists on all sides the power to represent our grievances. A Conference for Security and Cooperation in the region must be a priority for our leaders if human security is ever to become a reality. Diplomatic avenues must be opened and explored and this arduous process should include Syria and Iran. War and its tragic repercussions are inclusive of all — surely a model for peace should strive for such inclusiveness.
In memory of my late brother, HM King Hussein, and of PM Yitzhak Rabin, we must strive not to wage wars, but to win peace. Real peace must be built, it is not just the absence of war. We need to immediately call a Conference for Security and Cooperation to talk about the endgame, to develop regional understanding, to address the energy issue that is at the heart of so much instability and to devise a multilateral approach to such thorny issues as the proliferation of WMD, together with a regional concept for human rights, prosperity and security. Ideally, it could lead to a regional Code of Conduct and a Cohesion Fund that establishes principles of common interest, responsibility, transparency and a collective defence identity, reflecting the fact that interdependency is the reality today. Anthro-centric policies, policies where people matter, is the way to close the human dignity divide. Through good governance, we must empower the poor and dispossessed who find expression for their frustrations in extremist ideology.
The international community must firmly commit to supplanting unilateralist policies with regional strategies with the final aim of drawing up a comprehensive Regional Stabilisation Pact. The sooner a cessation of hostilities is achieved and international peacekeeping forces are deployed on both sides of the border, the sooner a collective strive towards institutionalised regional stability can begin. I cannot emphasise enough the need for diplomacy to transpose violence and this call echoes President Eisenhower’s appeal that the “table, though scarred by many past frustrations, cannot be abandoned for the certain agony of the battlefield.”
###
* Prince El Hassan bin Talal, brother of the late King Hussein of Jordan, is chairman of several organizations in fields which include diplomacy, interfaith studies, human resources, and science and technology.
Comment: Australia should endorse this call by Prince Hassan of Jordan. Australia has been actively involved with the Middle East since the time of the First World War; Australian troops under Colonel Chauvel conquered Damascus from the Turks in 1917. Lawrence of Arabia arrived in Damascus the following day, after the Australians had secured it.
We have a long involvement and we should continue it.
Friday, August 04, 2006
Canadian Muslim Reformer In Deep Trouble.
Note: Death threats,damaged property,harassment,abuse,slander...all the usual techniques used by the 'religion of peace' to get its point across. In Canada they are starting to reap the poison they have sown by having too many muslims come into the country.
Readers should realise that this is real Islam as it works in Western countries. Is Australia next?
Read and see what your future may hold...
"Fearing for safety, Muslim official quits," from the Globe and Mail.
Tarek Fatah, the outspoken, controversial communications director of the Muslim Canadian Congress, has resigned, citing concerns for his safety and that of his family.
Mr. Fatah said he will also resign from the MCC's board, severing all official ties with the organization he helped found.
"It's not just for me. It's for my wife and my daughters," he said in an interview.
"Part of it is also to get out of the limelight."
Mr. Fatah's socially liberal views have always been controversial within the Muslim community, and in the past month he has been the subject of an e-mail campaign aimed at the Canadian news media....
Along with his resignation, Mr. Fatah has filed a report with Toronto Police detailing what he says are a number of threats he has received since 2003. A police investigation is under way....
Mr. Fatah has always carried a high profile, both with the Muslim Canadian Congress -- known for its liberal interpretations of Islam, including its support of homosexuality -- and as the host of Muslim Chronicle, a CTS TV current-affairs show that focuses on the Muslim community.
But in recent months, he said, he has been coming under increasing fire. There was the e-mail campaign and he is more worried than ever about threats after the arrests of 17 terrorism suspects in Toronto in early June.
Mr. Fatah's unpopularity among conservative segments of the Muslim community is not surprising. He is a strong advocate of gay rights for Muslims and the inclusion of secular voices in the Muslim community. He publicly and vehemently opposed the adoption of sharia law in Canada.
Recently, many Muslims were angered by his very vocal campaign against British imam Sheik Riyadh ul Haq, who ultimately was refused a visa to attend a conference in Toronto. Mr. Haq's address was transmitted live by satellite instead.
Many Muslims have also accused Mr. Fatah of hogging the media spotlight.
He is frequently a subject of animated discussions on blogs and Internet chat forums, and early last month, a student group based in Montreal began bombarding five news outlets -- The Globe and Mail, the Toronto Star, The Toronto Sun, CBC and CTV -- with e-mails insisting that he does not represent the Muslim community and should not be recognized as a legitimate voice.
Mr. Fatah was quick to respond to accusations about his views.
"My position is that same-sex marriage is a human right and whether someone believes it is valid from a religious perspective is not the question. Most Muslims do not believe homosexuality is permitted but that is not the question," he said.
Mr. Fatah has fiercely advocated for a separation of church and state, although he said he has no issue with sharia arbitration as long as it is not part of the state legal system....
On June 30, Mr. Fatah was identified by the Canadian Islamic Congress as one of four people who are anti-Islam in an article in the CIC's weekly Friday Magazine, which is sent to e-mail subscribers. The article, "Smearing Islam and Bashing Muslims, Who and Why," was penned by Mohamed Elmasry, the CIC's director and an adjunct professor in the department of electrical and computer engineering at the University of Waterloo.
The list, which also included Globe and Mail columnist Margaret Wente, was led by Mr. Fatah, whom Dr. Elmasry wrote "is well known in Canada for smearing Islam and bashing Muslims."
Dr. Elmasry levelled similar accusations against the Muslim Canadian Congress last October.
Mr. Fatah said he is concerned because he understands the implication of statements such as "anti-Islam" and "smearing Islam."
He said they are akin to fatwas, pronouncing blasphemy, a crime that under sharia law is punishable by death.
"Anyone can issue a fatwa," Mr. Fatah said. " And anyone can issue a counter-fatwa. There is no clergy that oversees the process. This is a complete hijacking of the system, and everyone is complicit."
Wahida Valiante, vice-chair and national vice-president of the Canadian Islamic Congress, said there are "different versions and different ideologies" when asked whether the assertion amounted to a fatwa.
"We're not into fatwas," she said. "We are not a religious body. We are looking into issues. If someone is misrepresenting facts, we simply address that."
Mrs. Valiante said she had not read the article and could not refer to it directly. But she said that through her intimate exposure to the Muslim community, she felt confident that many people believe Mr. Fatah is smearing and misrepresenting Islam.
"Tarek Fatah's views are diametrically opposed to most Muslims. There is a tremendous amount of discussion in the community. His point of view contradicts the fundamentals of Islam," she said, refusing to elaborate on what she meant.
"The nature of the work we do implicitly entails that there will be people who don't like what we do," said El-Farouk Khaki, secretary-general of the Muslim Canadian Congress. The articulated hostility is par for the course for those who feel threatened by them, he said.
Mr. Khaki warned that police have to be sensitive to the reality that people who challenge established views so overtly are often in danger of being attacked.
Mr. Fatah has been attacked both physically and verbally, he said -- at an Islamic conference at the former SkyDome in 2003, dozens of young Muslim men mobbed him while a cleric shouted out that he had insulted the Prophet Mohammed's name. In 2006, he said, was accosted on Yonge Street by a man who accused him of being an apostate. His car windows were smashed.
He also wrote a letter to the RCMP about the article sent by e-mail by the Canadian Islamic Congress.
"This is as close as one can gets to issuing a death threat, as it places me as an apostate and blasphemer," he wrote.
Mr. Fatah says it is this concern for his safety that has pushed him to hand in his resignation. He said he is planning to write a book.
Comment: This is only to be expected. the Islamist war waged against the West is not a hidden thing. The Islamists have never hesitated to state their agenda; it is the dumb and bovine Westerners (like senior politicians and public servants in Canberra)who have deliberately pretended that Islam is a 'religion of peace' who are really to blame for this crisis.
In Australia, we still have the choice to keep the numbers of muslims low. It should be a bi-partisan policy to keep muslims at no more than 1% of the Australian total population. This will save us and them a lot of heartache in the future.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Readers should realise that this is real Islam as it works in Western countries. Is Australia next?
Read and see what your future may hold...
"Fearing for safety, Muslim official quits," from the Globe and Mail.
Tarek Fatah, the outspoken, controversial communications director of the Muslim Canadian Congress, has resigned, citing concerns for his safety and that of his family.
Mr. Fatah said he will also resign from the MCC's board, severing all official ties with the organization he helped found.
"It's not just for me. It's for my wife and my daughters," he said in an interview.
"Part of it is also to get out of the limelight."
Mr. Fatah's socially liberal views have always been controversial within the Muslim community, and in the past month he has been the subject of an e-mail campaign aimed at the Canadian news media....
Along with his resignation, Mr. Fatah has filed a report with Toronto Police detailing what he says are a number of threats he has received since 2003. A police investigation is under way....
Mr. Fatah has always carried a high profile, both with the Muslim Canadian Congress -- known for its liberal interpretations of Islam, including its support of homosexuality -- and as the host of Muslim Chronicle, a CTS TV current-affairs show that focuses on the Muslim community.
But in recent months, he said, he has been coming under increasing fire. There was the e-mail campaign and he is more worried than ever about threats after the arrests of 17 terrorism suspects in Toronto in early June.
Mr. Fatah's unpopularity among conservative segments of the Muslim community is not surprising. He is a strong advocate of gay rights for Muslims and the inclusion of secular voices in the Muslim community. He publicly and vehemently opposed the adoption of sharia law in Canada.
Recently, many Muslims were angered by his very vocal campaign against British imam Sheik Riyadh ul Haq, who ultimately was refused a visa to attend a conference in Toronto. Mr. Haq's address was transmitted live by satellite instead.
Many Muslims have also accused Mr. Fatah of hogging the media spotlight.
He is frequently a subject of animated discussions on blogs and Internet chat forums, and early last month, a student group based in Montreal began bombarding five news outlets -- The Globe and Mail, the Toronto Star, The Toronto Sun, CBC and CTV -- with e-mails insisting that he does not represent the Muslim community and should not be recognized as a legitimate voice.
Mr. Fatah was quick to respond to accusations about his views.
"My position is that same-sex marriage is a human right and whether someone believes it is valid from a religious perspective is not the question. Most Muslims do not believe homosexuality is permitted but that is not the question," he said.
Mr. Fatah has fiercely advocated for a separation of church and state, although he said he has no issue with sharia arbitration as long as it is not part of the state legal system....
On June 30, Mr. Fatah was identified by the Canadian Islamic Congress as one of four people who are anti-Islam in an article in the CIC's weekly Friday Magazine, which is sent to e-mail subscribers. The article, "Smearing Islam and Bashing Muslims, Who and Why," was penned by Mohamed Elmasry, the CIC's director and an adjunct professor in the department of electrical and computer engineering at the University of Waterloo.
The list, which also included Globe and Mail columnist Margaret Wente, was led by Mr. Fatah, whom Dr. Elmasry wrote "is well known in Canada for smearing Islam and bashing Muslims."
Dr. Elmasry levelled similar accusations against the Muslim Canadian Congress last October.
Mr. Fatah said he is concerned because he understands the implication of statements such as "anti-Islam" and "smearing Islam."
He said they are akin to fatwas, pronouncing blasphemy, a crime that under sharia law is punishable by death.
"Anyone can issue a fatwa," Mr. Fatah said. " And anyone can issue a counter-fatwa. There is no clergy that oversees the process. This is a complete hijacking of the system, and everyone is complicit."
Wahida Valiante, vice-chair and national vice-president of the Canadian Islamic Congress, said there are "different versions and different ideologies" when asked whether the assertion amounted to a fatwa.
"We're not into fatwas," she said. "We are not a religious body. We are looking into issues. If someone is misrepresenting facts, we simply address that."
Mrs. Valiante said she had not read the article and could not refer to it directly. But she said that through her intimate exposure to the Muslim community, she felt confident that many people believe Mr. Fatah is smearing and misrepresenting Islam.
"Tarek Fatah's views are diametrically opposed to most Muslims. There is a tremendous amount of discussion in the community. His point of view contradicts the fundamentals of Islam," she said, refusing to elaborate on what she meant.
"The nature of the work we do implicitly entails that there will be people who don't like what we do," said El-Farouk Khaki, secretary-general of the Muslim Canadian Congress. The articulated hostility is par for the course for those who feel threatened by them, he said.
Mr. Khaki warned that police have to be sensitive to the reality that people who challenge established views so overtly are often in danger of being attacked.
Mr. Fatah has been attacked both physically and verbally, he said -- at an Islamic conference at the former SkyDome in 2003, dozens of young Muslim men mobbed him while a cleric shouted out that he had insulted the Prophet Mohammed's name. In 2006, he said, was accosted on Yonge Street by a man who accused him of being an apostate. His car windows were smashed.
He also wrote a letter to the RCMP about the article sent by e-mail by the Canadian Islamic Congress.
"This is as close as one can gets to issuing a death threat, as it places me as an apostate and blasphemer," he wrote.
Mr. Fatah says it is this concern for his safety that has pushed him to hand in his resignation. He said he is planning to write a book.
Comment: This is only to be expected. the Islamist war waged against the West is not a hidden thing. The Islamists have never hesitated to state their agenda; it is the dumb and bovine Westerners (like senior politicians and public servants in Canberra)who have deliberately pretended that Islam is a 'religion of peace' who are really to blame for this crisis.
In Australia, we still have the choice to keep the numbers of muslims low. It should be a bi-partisan policy to keep muslims at no more than 1% of the Australian total population. This will save us and them a lot of heartache in the future.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Wednesday, August 02, 2006
Serious Non Muslim Writing On Islam.
Note: This post is an article from a German Jesuit Professor on current muslim scholars of the reform trend. All of them have been forced to flee from their muslim countries for obvious reasons. An important article for those wanting to think intelligently about Islam, today.
Read and learn...
German Jesuit Christian W. Troll, professor of islamic studies at the Sankt Georgen faculty of theology in Frankfurt, wrote the article. He also opened the discussions in last year’s Ratzinger-Schülerkreis seminar.
The 2005 seminar caused a considerable stir, especially in the United States after an account by one of the participants, US Jesuit Joseph Fessio, gave the impression that for Benedict XVI Islam and democracy were incompatible.
Things were not as reported however. Both Father Fessio and professor Troll, as well as Samir Khalil Samir, an Egyptian-born Jesuit expert on Islam who attended the seminar, and Ratzinger-Schülerkreis coordinator, professor Stephan Horn, made it clear that while the pope thought that a positive encounter between Islam and modernity was difficult, he also believed that it was not altogether impossible.
In his “La Civiltà Cattolica” article, professor Troll takes up exactly this point. In it he looks at what is happening in Islam and illustrates how some Muslims are trying to reconcile modernity and the Qur'an.
The article in Italian, entitled “Il pensiero progressista nell’islam contemporaneo. Un profilo critico [Progressive Thinking in Contemporary Islam: A Critical Profile],” appeared in the July 15, 2006, issue of “La Civiltà Cattolica,” pp. 123-135.
Here are its main passages. It must be said that most Muslim thinkers quoted in the article either live and work in the West, or have had to flee their respective countries.
Progressive Thinking in Contemporary Islam
by Christian W. Troll S.I.
Three main trends seem to be emerging in the Islamic world. Beside cultural Islam, a form of Islam we might call with some reservations traditional Islam, we find an “Islamist” Islam, one that is literalist in its approach to the scriptures. And in addition to these two, there is another Islam, one that is open to new interpretations, one based on the spirit of the text.
Today the Islam based on the spirit of the text is not in the foreground, [...] but its proponents are making enormous efforts, so much so that it is not uncommon to see them overlap with the goals and views of large segments of Muslim societies.
It is true that this Islam has still left many things unsaid and has purposefully dealt with others in a vague manner – the more so since its proponents fear attacks and accusations by “Islamists” or anti-democratic potentates who use cultural or traditional Islam to leave the status quo unchanged.
Yet on the long run the future might belong to the Islam based on the spirit of the text because it flexibly copes with the challenges of modernity without breaking with at least some past views of Islam. [...] More and more Muslims are converting to a critical view of religion, one that is less and less conditioned by its environment but is instead founded on a personal and responsible acceptance of the faith.
Within this newly-interpreted Islam we see to a great extent the rise of a new Islamic way of thinking. [...] The representatives of this progressive trend view modernity from a different perspective than that of past reformers, i.e. those of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. [...] Like Rachid Benzine, they believe that “at the core of modernity is the idea that the individual acts and thinks freely, that his experiments can penetrate nature’s mysteries, and that through his own efforts and those of others a new and better world can be built.”
In short, for the standard bearers of this new progressive trend modernity must be viewed with a critical eye and they must steadfastly rely on their own conscience and individual freedom. “We need to freely look at our religious heritage. This is the first condition for religious renewal,” wrote Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd in a 2002 article published in “Al-Ahram.” [...]
In general, such an appeal requires freedom, but also a social system that allows the mind to run free rather than oppressed it through violence. [...]
Subjecting religion and religious discourse to an open scientific critique is something new for Muslim societies. For this reason, the label of apostate has been constantly pinned on the members of this new movement of ideas. Not only are they unwelcome to the establishment because of how they deal with specific theological issues, but also because they are always involved in current issues like the relationship between state and religion in Muslim societies or the interferences between Shari’a and positive law in modern states – above all as they relate to human rights and women’s emancipation – as well as concrete social issues such as the Islamic view on faith and social justice, or on whether Islam has its own social or political system.
It would be a great mistake to believe as the adversaries of free thinking do that its proponents have uncritically adopted a Western perspective or that they have blindly and uncritically fallen prey to the West and its value system. Modernity for progressive Muslims does not mean the same thing as it does in the West; rather it refers to the critical light that modern knowledge can shed. This way, by studying Islam and ways to interpret the scriptures, progressive thinkers can favor those broader and more critical perspectives typical of modern social sciences like linguistics, semiotics, comparative religion and especially sociology. [...]
Among the many in the forefront of this trend a few stand out; thinkers like Mohammed Arkoun (Algeria/France), Leila Babès (Algeria/France), Rachid Benzine (Morocco/ France), Abdolkarim Soroush (Iran), Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd (Egypt/Netherlands), Abdou Filali-Ansary (Morocco), Abdelmajid Sharfi (Tunisia), Farid Esack (South Africa/USA), Ebrahim Moosa (USA), Ashgar Ali Engineer (India), Abdullahi an-Naim (Sudan/US), Amina Wadud (USA), Fatima Mernissi (Morocco), Khaled Abou El Fadl (USA), Nurcholish Madjid (Indonesia), Farish Noor (Malaysia), Ömer Özsoy (Turkey). [...]
Proportionately, these progressive scholars are more likely to be trained social scientists compared to the “Islamists”, who tend to have a background in the natural and applied sciences. [...]
In practical terms, all progressive thinkers are trying to define the place of religion in a world that, despite appearances to the contrary, is becoming increasingly secular. Indeed the process of secularization has come to the Islamic world unannounced and with such speed that it has left it unprepared to assimilate it from within. Given the circumstances, Muslim thinkers have had to face the challenges this process entails directly – they have had to find ways to reconcile religion, something quintessentially seen as unchangeable, with change itself. [...]
For progressive thinkers, only a fresh, prejudice-free reading of Islam’s fundamental texts can allow its essential values to meet the needs of the modern world in all its varying forms. Only through this kind of reinterpretation can Islamic Law and legal system become more open; only through it can Islam’s political ideas become reconciled to democracy with the necessary spiritual and intellectual coherence and conviction that would allow for equality between men and women. And all this might come about with a clear conscience vis-à-vis Islam and the Sunnah and in an open dialogue with critical approaches to the modern world. [...]
Progressive thinkers are today tackling issues relating to the Qur'an that modern perspectives and scientific approaches are explicitly raising. [...]
Their answers are informed by historical-critical methods which [...] try to analyze a text within its original context. Thus, the Qur'an can be seen as part of history. The Qur'an might be God’s Word, but its words are laden with history. As Rachid Benzine put it, its historical nature is “incarnated” in its textuality, i.e. in the nature and structure of the written text. [...]
According to this new approach, while the Qur'an certainly conveys eternal truths, the way it transmits them is culturally specific and not universally applicable for it reflects the culture of 7th and 8th century Hejazi Arabs. [...]
Linguistics and literary criticism are used today to read and understand the Qur'an, in particular by many new thinkers like Egypt’s Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd, a hermeneutics scholar born in 1943 who currently teaches in Leiden, the Netherlands. [...]
It is self-evident that the Qur'an, or any other text, can only be viewed through culturally-specific lenses, those of the reader or listener. [...] The act of reading is always one of re-reading, [...] so much so that reading the Qur'an cannot be done from a single perspective. No one reading can claim to be the one and only, true for all times.
For progressive Muslim thinkers, scientific research and literary analysis are not in contradiction with approaches informed by religious belief and faith in the Qur'an. On the contrary [...] they are meant for and can contribute to understanding the Qur'an’s deepest sense and therefore the truest religious meaning it can convey today. [...]
Perhaps this might open the way to another way of experiencing faith, one that is more strongly held, and more open to issues and problems that can arise, proud of the Qur'an’s wider horizons, but also conscious of the fact that this greater depth allows the believer to grow in humility and in openness to others. [...]
However the case may be, whether openly expressed or not, two questions dog modern progressive Muslim thinkers. The first one is: “How does God speak?” The second one is: “Who speaks in God’s name?” [...]
A problem inevitably arises the moment the bases of the Qur'an are no longer considered untouchable and binding but are instead open to personal interpretations based on the spirit of the text however defined or justified. What was hitherto viewed in a relative unambiguous ways, or was informed by the earliest interpretation formulated during Islam’s first two centuries, is now open to a self-renewing process of legitimation in which new exegeses come into focus. Likewise, it is impossible not to ask how far and by what means the Qur'an, and consequently God’s revelation in our times, can be truly understood.
Furthermore, from a social and political point of view the issue of consensus (igma’) was and is central to understanding Islam. Does Islam have a theologically-based theory of what an Islamic society (Ummah) ought to be? That is to say, does it have a theory of the Ummah? And what would be that theory’s role and how would that role be played out insofar as the theory tried to explain God’s revelation in matters of faith and ethics? And, if necessary, how could that theory be upheld and justified? Ultimately, is it not true that both those who uphold the traditional view with regard to the prophet’s authority or to God’s words of which the prophet was the messenger, and those who have serious doubts about it are ultimately involved in a struggle over who can rightfully claim the authority that were vested in the prophet and the scriptures that were revealed through him?
Comment: In Australia it is impossible to make use of excellent information from scholars like Professor Troll. There is no quality arabic language weekly, run by serious people, to present these articles and articles from the reformist muslim scholars he mentions. Local muslims are still enslaved by their vicious ignorant imams; muslim bookshops are dens of censorship and mosques are towers of threats directed at all who would propose a reformed Australian Islam.
This situation exists because the stupid Australian government wants this. They will blindly continue along these lines until the policy actually blows up in their face.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Read and learn...
German Jesuit Christian W. Troll, professor of islamic studies at the Sankt Georgen faculty of theology in Frankfurt, wrote the article. He also opened the discussions in last year’s Ratzinger-Schülerkreis seminar.
The 2005 seminar caused a considerable stir, especially in the United States after an account by one of the participants, US Jesuit Joseph Fessio, gave the impression that for Benedict XVI Islam and democracy were incompatible.
Things were not as reported however. Both Father Fessio and professor Troll, as well as Samir Khalil Samir, an Egyptian-born Jesuit expert on Islam who attended the seminar, and Ratzinger-Schülerkreis coordinator, professor Stephan Horn, made it clear that while the pope thought that a positive encounter between Islam and modernity was difficult, he also believed that it was not altogether impossible.
In his “La Civiltà Cattolica” article, professor Troll takes up exactly this point. In it he looks at what is happening in Islam and illustrates how some Muslims are trying to reconcile modernity and the Qur'an.
The article in Italian, entitled “Il pensiero progressista nell’islam contemporaneo. Un profilo critico [Progressive Thinking in Contemporary Islam: A Critical Profile],” appeared in the July 15, 2006, issue of “La Civiltà Cattolica,” pp. 123-135.
Here are its main passages. It must be said that most Muslim thinkers quoted in the article either live and work in the West, or have had to flee their respective countries.
Progressive Thinking in Contemporary Islam
by Christian W. Troll S.I.
Three main trends seem to be emerging in the Islamic world. Beside cultural Islam, a form of Islam we might call with some reservations traditional Islam, we find an “Islamist” Islam, one that is literalist in its approach to the scriptures. And in addition to these two, there is another Islam, one that is open to new interpretations, one based on the spirit of the text.
Today the Islam based on the spirit of the text is not in the foreground, [...] but its proponents are making enormous efforts, so much so that it is not uncommon to see them overlap with the goals and views of large segments of Muslim societies.
It is true that this Islam has still left many things unsaid and has purposefully dealt with others in a vague manner – the more so since its proponents fear attacks and accusations by “Islamists” or anti-democratic potentates who use cultural or traditional Islam to leave the status quo unchanged.
Yet on the long run the future might belong to the Islam based on the spirit of the text because it flexibly copes with the challenges of modernity without breaking with at least some past views of Islam. [...] More and more Muslims are converting to a critical view of religion, one that is less and less conditioned by its environment but is instead founded on a personal and responsible acceptance of the faith.
Within this newly-interpreted Islam we see to a great extent the rise of a new Islamic way of thinking. [...] The representatives of this progressive trend view modernity from a different perspective than that of past reformers, i.e. those of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. [...] Like Rachid Benzine, they believe that “at the core of modernity is the idea that the individual acts and thinks freely, that his experiments can penetrate nature’s mysteries, and that through his own efforts and those of others a new and better world can be built.”
In short, for the standard bearers of this new progressive trend modernity must be viewed with a critical eye and they must steadfastly rely on their own conscience and individual freedom. “We need to freely look at our religious heritage. This is the first condition for religious renewal,” wrote Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd in a 2002 article published in “Al-Ahram.” [...]
In general, such an appeal requires freedom, but also a social system that allows the mind to run free rather than oppressed it through violence. [...]
Subjecting religion and religious discourse to an open scientific critique is something new for Muslim societies. For this reason, the label of apostate has been constantly pinned on the members of this new movement of ideas. Not only are they unwelcome to the establishment because of how they deal with specific theological issues, but also because they are always involved in current issues like the relationship between state and religion in Muslim societies or the interferences between Shari’a and positive law in modern states – above all as they relate to human rights and women’s emancipation – as well as concrete social issues such as the Islamic view on faith and social justice, or on whether Islam has its own social or political system.
It would be a great mistake to believe as the adversaries of free thinking do that its proponents have uncritically adopted a Western perspective or that they have blindly and uncritically fallen prey to the West and its value system. Modernity for progressive Muslims does not mean the same thing as it does in the West; rather it refers to the critical light that modern knowledge can shed. This way, by studying Islam and ways to interpret the scriptures, progressive thinkers can favor those broader and more critical perspectives typical of modern social sciences like linguistics, semiotics, comparative religion and especially sociology. [...]
Among the many in the forefront of this trend a few stand out; thinkers like Mohammed Arkoun (Algeria/France), Leila Babès (Algeria/France), Rachid Benzine (Morocco/ France), Abdolkarim Soroush (Iran), Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd (Egypt/Netherlands), Abdou Filali-Ansary (Morocco), Abdelmajid Sharfi (Tunisia), Farid Esack (South Africa/USA), Ebrahim Moosa (USA), Ashgar Ali Engineer (India), Abdullahi an-Naim (Sudan/US), Amina Wadud (USA), Fatima Mernissi (Morocco), Khaled Abou El Fadl (USA), Nurcholish Madjid (Indonesia), Farish Noor (Malaysia), Ömer Özsoy (Turkey). [...]
Proportionately, these progressive scholars are more likely to be trained social scientists compared to the “Islamists”, who tend to have a background in the natural and applied sciences. [...]
In practical terms, all progressive thinkers are trying to define the place of religion in a world that, despite appearances to the contrary, is becoming increasingly secular. Indeed the process of secularization has come to the Islamic world unannounced and with such speed that it has left it unprepared to assimilate it from within. Given the circumstances, Muslim thinkers have had to face the challenges this process entails directly – they have had to find ways to reconcile religion, something quintessentially seen as unchangeable, with change itself. [...]
For progressive thinkers, only a fresh, prejudice-free reading of Islam’s fundamental texts can allow its essential values to meet the needs of the modern world in all its varying forms. Only through this kind of reinterpretation can Islamic Law and legal system become more open; only through it can Islam’s political ideas become reconciled to democracy with the necessary spiritual and intellectual coherence and conviction that would allow for equality between men and women. And all this might come about with a clear conscience vis-à-vis Islam and the Sunnah and in an open dialogue with critical approaches to the modern world. [...]
Progressive thinkers are today tackling issues relating to the Qur'an that modern perspectives and scientific approaches are explicitly raising. [...]
Their answers are informed by historical-critical methods which [...] try to analyze a text within its original context. Thus, the Qur'an can be seen as part of history. The Qur'an might be God’s Word, but its words are laden with history. As Rachid Benzine put it, its historical nature is “incarnated” in its textuality, i.e. in the nature and structure of the written text. [...]
According to this new approach, while the Qur'an certainly conveys eternal truths, the way it transmits them is culturally specific and not universally applicable for it reflects the culture of 7th and 8th century Hejazi Arabs. [...]
Linguistics and literary criticism are used today to read and understand the Qur'an, in particular by many new thinkers like Egypt’s Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd, a hermeneutics scholar born in 1943 who currently teaches in Leiden, the Netherlands. [...]
It is self-evident that the Qur'an, or any other text, can only be viewed through culturally-specific lenses, those of the reader or listener. [...] The act of reading is always one of re-reading, [...] so much so that reading the Qur'an cannot be done from a single perspective. No one reading can claim to be the one and only, true for all times.
For progressive Muslim thinkers, scientific research and literary analysis are not in contradiction with approaches informed by religious belief and faith in the Qur'an. On the contrary [...] they are meant for and can contribute to understanding the Qur'an’s deepest sense and therefore the truest religious meaning it can convey today. [...]
Perhaps this might open the way to another way of experiencing faith, one that is more strongly held, and more open to issues and problems that can arise, proud of the Qur'an’s wider horizons, but also conscious of the fact that this greater depth allows the believer to grow in humility and in openness to others. [...]
However the case may be, whether openly expressed or not, two questions dog modern progressive Muslim thinkers. The first one is: “How does God speak?” The second one is: “Who speaks in God’s name?” [...]
A problem inevitably arises the moment the bases of the Qur'an are no longer considered untouchable and binding but are instead open to personal interpretations based on the spirit of the text however defined or justified. What was hitherto viewed in a relative unambiguous ways, or was informed by the earliest interpretation formulated during Islam’s first two centuries, is now open to a self-renewing process of legitimation in which new exegeses come into focus. Likewise, it is impossible not to ask how far and by what means the Qur'an, and consequently God’s revelation in our times, can be truly understood.
Furthermore, from a social and political point of view the issue of consensus (igma’) was and is central to understanding Islam. Does Islam have a theologically-based theory of what an Islamic society (Ummah) ought to be? That is to say, does it have a theory of the Ummah? And what would be that theory’s role and how would that role be played out insofar as the theory tried to explain God’s revelation in matters of faith and ethics? And, if necessary, how could that theory be upheld and justified? Ultimately, is it not true that both those who uphold the traditional view with regard to the prophet’s authority or to God’s words of which the prophet was the messenger, and those who have serious doubts about it are ultimately involved in a struggle over who can rightfully claim the authority that were vested in the prophet and the scriptures that were revealed through him?
Comment: In Australia it is impossible to make use of excellent information from scholars like Professor Troll. There is no quality arabic language weekly, run by serious people, to present these articles and articles from the reformist muslim scholars he mentions. Local muslims are still enslaved by their vicious ignorant imams; muslim bookshops are dens of censorship and mosques are towers of threats directed at all who would propose a reformed Australian Islam.
This situation exists because the stupid Australian government wants this. They will blindly continue along these lines until the policy actually blows up in their face.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Proper Religious Spirit Among Communities.
Note: This post is to remind readers that good things are also happening with muslims and non muslims in places where, formerly, much violence reigned.
Read on...
1 August, 2006
INDONESIA
Maluku: Christians and Muslims rebuild church dedicated to John Paul II
The chapel will emerge from the ruins of a church destroyed during the inter-faith conflict in Ambon in 2001. Muslims and Christians, who at the time were at war on each other, attended the stone-laying ceremony.
Ambon (AsiaNews/JP) – The reconstruction of a Catholic Church has served to build bridges between religious communities in Maluku. Thousands of Christians and Muslims from several villages gathered in Waai for the laying of the first stone of a Catholic church that will emerge from the ruins of the former building, which was destroyed in the inter-faith conflict that rocked Poso in 2001. The new chapel will be dedicated to John Paul II.
On 30 July, residents of Waai came together with their one-time enemies of the villages of Tulehu and Liang to celebrate the launch of reconstruction works of a Catholic parish, on the same land where the former parish – destroyed in the 2001 clashes – used to stand. At the time, Waai, a mainly Christian village, was razed to the ground and more than 9,000 people fled in search of refuge in the neighbouring villages of Suli and Passo. Tulehu and Liang were Muslim-majority settlements that had declared war on Waai at the time of the inter-faith clashes.
The cornerstone was laid by Archbishop S. Wesoly and Bishop Stefan Wylesek from the John Paul II Vatican Foundation. The Amboina Bishop, P.C. Mandagi, and the head of the Maluku Protestant Church (GPM) Rev. Jhon Puhulessin, as well as traditional village chiefs, also attended the ceremony.
People who witnessed the event talked about “a spirit of reconciliation”. Thirteen Tulehu youths performed a traditional dance to greet the guests. The Waai GPM band sang gospel songs, accompanied by dancing girls. A number of members of the church construction committee also attended the ceremony, including Muslims.
Mgr Mandagi said the building would be named “John Paul II chapel”. He expressed joy over an atmosphere, that was so “totally” different from the one that reigned during the not-too-distant conflict in which “not just Catholics suffered but also Muslims and Protestants”. He said: "I'm happy because Tulehu Muslims and Waai Protestants have warmly greeted us. Now is not the time for war, but for love and peace.”
Archbishop Wesoly said much the same, praising the spirit of inter-faith solidarity that was revealed in the commitment to rebuild the chapel. The village chief of Tulehu said the hostility between his village and Waai was a thing of the past.
The conflict between Christians and Muslims in Maluku (1999 – 2001) led to 5,000 deaths and half a million displaced people.
Comment: In view of the possibilities that exist for good relations between muslims and non muslims, readers should be aware that such outcomes are the much desired end for both muslim and non muslim mainstream people. We should never think that bad outcomes are the inevitable result of history. Good outcome? Bad outcome? We actually make the choice ourselves.
Read on...
1 August, 2006
INDONESIA
Maluku: Christians and Muslims rebuild church dedicated to John Paul II
The chapel will emerge from the ruins of a church destroyed during the inter-faith conflict in Ambon in 2001. Muslims and Christians, who at the time were at war on each other, attended the stone-laying ceremony.
Ambon (AsiaNews/JP) – The reconstruction of a Catholic Church has served to build bridges between religious communities in Maluku. Thousands of Christians and Muslims from several villages gathered in Waai for the laying of the first stone of a Catholic church that will emerge from the ruins of the former building, which was destroyed in the inter-faith conflict that rocked Poso in 2001. The new chapel will be dedicated to John Paul II.
On 30 July, residents of Waai came together with their one-time enemies of the villages of Tulehu and Liang to celebrate the launch of reconstruction works of a Catholic parish, on the same land where the former parish – destroyed in the 2001 clashes – used to stand. At the time, Waai, a mainly Christian village, was razed to the ground and more than 9,000 people fled in search of refuge in the neighbouring villages of Suli and Passo. Tulehu and Liang were Muslim-majority settlements that had declared war on Waai at the time of the inter-faith clashes.
The cornerstone was laid by Archbishop S. Wesoly and Bishop Stefan Wylesek from the John Paul II Vatican Foundation. The Amboina Bishop, P.C. Mandagi, and the head of the Maluku Protestant Church (GPM) Rev. Jhon Puhulessin, as well as traditional village chiefs, also attended the ceremony.
People who witnessed the event talked about “a spirit of reconciliation”. Thirteen Tulehu youths performed a traditional dance to greet the guests. The Waai GPM band sang gospel songs, accompanied by dancing girls. A number of members of the church construction committee also attended the ceremony, including Muslims.
Mgr Mandagi said the building would be named “John Paul II chapel”. He expressed joy over an atmosphere, that was so “totally” different from the one that reigned during the not-too-distant conflict in which “not just Catholics suffered but also Muslims and Protestants”. He said: "I'm happy because Tulehu Muslims and Waai Protestants have warmly greeted us. Now is not the time for war, but for love and peace.”
Archbishop Wesoly said much the same, praising the spirit of inter-faith solidarity that was revealed in the commitment to rebuild the chapel. The village chief of Tulehu said the hostility between his village and Waai was a thing of the past.
The conflict between Christians and Muslims in Maluku (1999 – 2001) led to 5,000 deaths and half a million displaced people.
Comment: In view of the possibilities that exist for good relations between muslims and non muslims, readers should be aware that such outcomes are the much desired end for both muslim and non muslim mainstream people. We should never think that bad outcomes are the inevitable result of history. Good outcome? Bad outcome? We actually make the choice ourselves.
Tuesday, August 01, 2006
What Do Muslims Hear In Mosque?
Note: This very interesting post is from the German magazine 'Der Spiegal'.
Read on and learn...
Last Monday, the 12th of Rabi al-Awwal 1427, traffic stood still in most Islamic countries, government employees had the day off and children stayed home from school. On the 12th of Rabi, the world's Muslims observe the birthday of the Prophet Muhammad.
Islam has many faces, and on the Friday before the Prophet's birthday, SPIEGEL correspondents visited mosques from Nigeria to Indonesia to listen to the sermons of the imams. They were there in part to look into a suspicion that has taken hold in the West, especially since the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. Have the mosques been transformed from a place of prayer into a hotbed of extremism and center of Islamist indoctrination? Is there truly a dangerous clash of cultures underway, as so many people in Europe and America fear?
Radical preachers have actively contributed to this impression. In a Berlin mosque, a television crew secretly recorded the sermon of a Turkish imam who described the Germans as godless and railed against their alleged stench. In London, hate preacher Abu Hamza al-Masri called upon the faithful to murder female tourists in his native Egypt, saying: "If a woman, even a Muslim woman, is naked and you have no way of covering her up, it is legitimate to kill her."
Other agents of the Koran speak moderately when addressing Western audiences, but their words turn decidedly more radical when directed towards Muslims. In an interview with SPIEGEL, television imam Yusuf al-Qaradawi, perhaps currently one of the most influential Islamic scholars around, magnanimously conceded that there is also room in heaven for devout Christians and Jews. But on his Arab-language website a short time later, he made it clear that he believes that Christians and Jews are ultimately nothing more than infidels.
To ensure that religious speech doesn't suddenly turn into political invective, hundreds of police officers are stationed in the streets around the al-Azhar mosque in Cairo every Friday during prayers. The faithful have rarely staged demonstrations after prayers in recent years, and when they have, many of the "demonstrators" were undercover police officers. But such precautions are unnecessary on the Friday before the Prophet's birthday. Indeed, Imam Yusuf warned his audience against the excesses of religious fervor, saying that "the extremist doesn't plow the earth, nor does he allow any flowers to grow."
Throughout the world, Friday prayers are the high point of the week in the life of a devout Muslim. It was a Friday when Adam entered the Garden of Eden, and it was a Friday when he left it again. The faithful believe that Muhammad said that the day of resurrection would also be a Friday. Muhammad supposedly also said that "God commanded both the Jews and the Christians to celebrate Friday as a day of worship but they ignored His command." Muslims see the Koran as God's last and complete revelation, and every Friday sermon serves as a reminder of that belief.
AL-AZHAR, CAIRO
The mosque and university was established more than a thousand years ago by Fatimide commander Gauhar al- Sikilli, and is considered the most important center of learning in Sunni Islam to this day. The Friday preacher, Dr. Id Abd al- Hamid Yussuf, 65, is completely against the use of Islam for political purposes.
The Prophet forgave those who committed injustices against him. He pardoned the murderer of his uncle, Hamsa. He forgave his people when they banished him from Mecca … Islam spread throughout the world through argument and conviction, but not through the sword, as the enemies of Islam have claimed. Islam only used the sword when it was attacked … The Prophet forbade extremism and fanaticism. He said: "I was sent to you out of the generosity of God. Night became day. Anyone who strays from this path will fall victim to ruin." For some, religion is like a maze. Enter it with caution, because whoever approaches religion as an extremist will perish in his extremism.
BLUE MOSQUE, ISTANBUL
The house of worship, completed in 1616 under Sultan Ahmet I, is one of Istanbul's major mosques intended to embody the faith and power of the Ottoman Empire. The mosque's imam, Emrullah Hatipoglu, delivered the sermon.
There is no science without God. We see all the things that can happen in the schools when children do not learn in the name of God. When there are murders in the schools today, when an inhuman development becomes a threat, we must ask ourselves what led to this development. God says in the Koran: Murdering an innocent person is the same as murdering all of mankind … The Koran permeates our lives.
But there are problems with our attitudes to the Koran. We do not apply it everywhere. Let us assume that we are running a supermarket. Are we permitted to sell merchandise there that is prohibited in Islam, goods that are not legitimate? No? But many Muslims are doing just that. The goods must conform to the standards established in Turkey and the rules of consumer protection, but not those of the Koran. Is the sale of alcohol and pork allowed? What about the Koran? These, my fellow Muslims, are all sins.
NUR MOSQUE, GAZA STRIP
In this mosque in the Jabaliya refugee camp with ties to the extremist Hamas movement, Friday prayers ended with an appeal to Palestinians to rise up against Israeli occupiers. The sermon was given by 38- year- old Imam Talal al- Majdalawi.
When the Jews withdrew from the Gaza Strip, we thought that we had gained all the freedom in the world. But then came the bombardment. This is a sign, you faithful, that your battle with the Jews is still a long way from coming to an end. It proves that the conflict is not taking place among us and between us, but with the infidel Jews. This is why you should say, whenever there is a rocket attack: God be praised, there is no God other than the one God, and He is our protector. We say to the Jews: "What you are doing to us today is written in the book of God." There it is said: "Your will suffer fear and hunger." But we too will sow fear and terror, as they have never seen before, in the hearts of those who bring us fear and hunger today. With the help of God, we should be afraid of nothing. We must not be afraid whenever a bullet strikes its target or whenever we are threatened … This does not frighten us. This should make us strong in our fight against the Jews.
UNIVERSITY OF TEHRAN
The Friday sermon at the University of Tehran is held exclusively by high- ranking members of the country's ruling Shiite clergy. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran's supreme religious leader, personally appoints the campus preachers, among whom Hojjatolislam Ahmed Khatami is a novice. He preached to thousands of the faithful.
The Shiite and Sunni brothers find themselves facing a common enemy, one whose goal is to attack Islam. This is not just about Shiites. Any insult to the Prophet is an insult to the entire religion. For this reason, the Shiites and the Sunnis must strive to achieve more cooperation and unity of the hearts in this respect. Shiites and Sunnis should live together like brothers …
Our enemies are using the fairy tale about nuclear energy to bring about a crisis. The Security Council of the United Nations has itself become a factor of uncertainty and injustice, instead a forum for the security of the world … According to international custom, it is our right to control the technology to obtain nuclear energy. The Security Council wants to prevent us from mastering this technology. There is a law of the jungle, and it says: The strong will prevail. But our nation has made it clear that we want our right. We will stand up for our right with our blood and until we breathe our last breath.
Comment: These speeches from various mosques around the world will be the very first time many readers will have read anything from a mosque. As readers can see politics features very much in the talks. The Western concept of the divsion of 'Church and State' has a long way to go in Islam.
Read on and learn...
Last Monday, the 12th of Rabi al-Awwal 1427, traffic stood still in most Islamic countries, government employees had the day off and children stayed home from school. On the 12th of Rabi, the world's Muslims observe the birthday of the Prophet Muhammad.
Islam has many faces, and on the Friday before the Prophet's birthday, SPIEGEL correspondents visited mosques from Nigeria to Indonesia to listen to the sermons of the imams. They were there in part to look into a suspicion that has taken hold in the West, especially since the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. Have the mosques been transformed from a place of prayer into a hotbed of extremism and center of Islamist indoctrination? Is there truly a dangerous clash of cultures underway, as so many people in Europe and America fear?
Radical preachers have actively contributed to this impression. In a Berlin mosque, a television crew secretly recorded the sermon of a Turkish imam who described the Germans as godless and railed against their alleged stench. In London, hate preacher Abu Hamza al-Masri called upon the faithful to murder female tourists in his native Egypt, saying: "If a woman, even a Muslim woman, is naked and you have no way of covering her up, it is legitimate to kill her."
Other agents of the Koran speak moderately when addressing Western audiences, but their words turn decidedly more radical when directed towards Muslims. In an interview with SPIEGEL, television imam Yusuf al-Qaradawi, perhaps currently one of the most influential Islamic scholars around, magnanimously conceded that there is also room in heaven for devout Christians and Jews. But on his Arab-language website a short time later, he made it clear that he believes that Christians and Jews are ultimately nothing more than infidels.
To ensure that religious speech doesn't suddenly turn into political invective, hundreds of police officers are stationed in the streets around the al-Azhar mosque in Cairo every Friday during prayers. The faithful have rarely staged demonstrations after prayers in recent years, and when they have, many of the "demonstrators" were undercover police officers. But such precautions are unnecessary on the Friday before the Prophet's birthday. Indeed, Imam Yusuf warned his audience against the excesses of religious fervor, saying that "the extremist doesn't plow the earth, nor does he allow any flowers to grow."
Throughout the world, Friday prayers are the high point of the week in the life of a devout Muslim. It was a Friday when Adam entered the Garden of Eden, and it was a Friday when he left it again. The faithful believe that Muhammad said that the day of resurrection would also be a Friday. Muhammad supposedly also said that "God commanded both the Jews and the Christians to celebrate Friday as a day of worship but they ignored His command." Muslims see the Koran as God's last and complete revelation, and every Friday sermon serves as a reminder of that belief.
AL-AZHAR, CAIRO
The mosque and university was established more than a thousand years ago by Fatimide commander Gauhar al- Sikilli, and is considered the most important center of learning in Sunni Islam to this day. The Friday preacher, Dr. Id Abd al- Hamid Yussuf, 65, is completely against the use of Islam for political purposes.
The Prophet forgave those who committed injustices against him. He pardoned the murderer of his uncle, Hamsa. He forgave his people when they banished him from Mecca … Islam spread throughout the world through argument and conviction, but not through the sword, as the enemies of Islam have claimed. Islam only used the sword when it was attacked … The Prophet forbade extremism and fanaticism. He said: "I was sent to you out of the generosity of God. Night became day. Anyone who strays from this path will fall victim to ruin." For some, religion is like a maze. Enter it with caution, because whoever approaches religion as an extremist will perish in his extremism.
BLUE MOSQUE, ISTANBUL
The house of worship, completed in 1616 under Sultan Ahmet I, is one of Istanbul's major mosques intended to embody the faith and power of the Ottoman Empire. The mosque's imam, Emrullah Hatipoglu, delivered the sermon.
There is no science without God. We see all the things that can happen in the schools when children do not learn in the name of God. When there are murders in the schools today, when an inhuman development becomes a threat, we must ask ourselves what led to this development. God says in the Koran: Murdering an innocent person is the same as murdering all of mankind … The Koran permeates our lives.
But there are problems with our attitudes to the Koran. We do not apply it everywhere. Let us assume that we are running a supermarket. Are we permitted to sell merchandise there that is prohibited in Islam, goods that are not legitimate? No? But many Muslims are doing just that. The goods must conform to the standards established in Turkey and the rules of consumer protection, but not those of the Koran. Is the sale of alcohol and pork allowed? What about the Koran? These, my fellow Muslims, are all sins.
NUR MOSQUE, GAZA STRIP
In this mosque in the Jabaliya refugee camp with ties to the extremist Hamas movement, Friday prayers ended with an appeal to Palestinians to rise up against Israeli occupiers. The sermon was given by 38- year- old Imam Talal al- Majdalawi.
When the Jews withdrew from the Gaza Strip, we thought that we had gained all the freedom in the world. But then came the bombardment. This is a sign, you faithful, that your battle with the Jews is still a long way from coming to an end. It proves that the conflict is not taking place among us and between us, but with the infidel Jews. This is why you should say, whenever there is a rocket attack: God be praised, there is no God other than the one God, and He is our protector. We say to the Jews: "What you are doing to us today is written in the book of God." There it is said: "Your will suffer fear and hunger." But we too will sow fear and terror, as they have never seen before, in the hearts of those who bring us fear and hunger today. With the help of God, we should be afraid of nothing. We must not be afraid whenever a bullet strikes its target or whenever we are threatened … This does not frighten us. This should make us strong in our fight against the Jews.
UNIVERSITY OF TEHRAN
The Friday sermon at the University of Tehran is held exclusively by high- ranking members of the country's ruling Shiite clergy. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran's supreme religious leader, personally appoints the campus preachers, among whom Hojjatolislam Ahmed Khatami is a novice. He preached to thousands of the faithful.
The Shiite and Sunni brothers find themselves facing a common enemy, one whose goal is to attack Islam. This is not just about Shiites. Any insult to the Prophet is an insult to the entire religion. For this reason, the Shiites and the Sunnis must strive to achieve more cooperation and unity of the hearts in this respect. Shiites and Sunnis should live together like brothers …
Our enemies are using the fairy tale about nuclear energy to bring about a crisis. The Security Council of the United Nations has itself become a factor of uncertainty and injustice, instead a forum for the security of the world … According to international custom, it is our right to control the technology to obtain nuclear energy. The Security Council wants to prevent us from mastering this technology. There is a law of the jungle, and it says: The strong will prevail. But our nation has made it clear that we want our right. We will stand up for our right with our blood and until we breathe our last breath.
Comment: These speeches from various mosques around the world will be the very first time many readers will have read anything from a mosque. As readers can see politics features very much in the talks. The Western concept of the divsion of 'Church and State' has a long way to go in Islam.
Some Australian Reactions To Muslims/Islam.
Note: This is an interesting poll. Careful persons must always be able to discern between Muslims, as people, and Islam as an ideology. The problem come from Islam as an ideology, not 'that nice muslim family next door'.
Read on...
Aussies fear Muslim way
The poll of 502 people discovered:
ONE in three people are more fearful of Muslims since 9/11.
SEVENTY-ONE per cent say women in Islam are treated as inferior.
FIFTY-SIX per cent believe Muslims are unfairly discriminated against and two in three people believe Muslims should be allowed to wear religious dress in schools and workplaces.
ONLY a quarter of people say they understand Islam well.
The research summary states: "The results show a complex mix of feelings about Muslims in Australia."
People aged between 18 and 29 are more likely to hold sympathetic views about Muslims, the research found.
Queenslanders and people in the over-56 age group felt most threatened by Islam, while Victorians and people in the 40 to 54 years age group felt they had the best understanding of the religion, according to the poll....
Melbourne Islamic cleric Sheik Fehmi Naji El-Imam expressed anger at the poll results, which showed widespread fear of the religion.
"It is not fair at all," the sheik, who is general secretary of the Board of Imams of Victoria, said.
"They don't know what they are talking about - they should know Muslims first before they pass opinions."
Comment: Australia must get a policy which improves the daily circumstances of ordinary muslims in our country and suppresses the power of the professional islamists of ideological Islam, who are actually currently working to force this ideology onto, first the muslims and then Australia.
The Three Point Policy is this:
1.All muslim community organisations should be required by law to restrict their Executives to locally born and raised muslims.
2. All imams without exception must be sent away from Australia.No replacements should be allowed. They are the source of the problem, with their ideological and violent interpretations of the key Islamic documents. The local mosques can make their own solutions to the lack of imams.
3.No muslim organisation,without exception, can be allowed to receive any money for any purpose from outside Australia. This will cut the power of the Islamic Wahhabi nazis who use Saudi money to control the sunni muslim groups, who are the big majority of muslims in Australia.
This simple and straight forward set of proposals will hand complete control of muslim communities in Australia into the hands of Australian muslims. They can then steadily develop an Australian Islam, based on Australian muslim resources and their actual experience of life in Australia. End of muslim troubles in Australia. QED.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Read on...
Aussies fear Muslim way
The poll of 502 people discovered:
ONE in three people are more fearful of Muslims since 9/11.
SEVENTY-ONE per cent say women in Islam are treated as inferior.
FIFTY-SIX per cent believe Muslims are unfairly discriminated against and two in three people believe Muslims should be allowed to wear religious dress in schools and workplaces.
ONLY a quarter of people say they understand Islam well.
The research summary states: "The results show a complex mix of feelings about Muslims in Australia."
People aged between 18 and 29 are more likely to hold sympathetic views about Muslims, the research found.
Queenslanders and people in the over-56 age group felt most threatened by Islam, while Victorians and people in the 40 to 54 years age group felt they had the best understanding of the religion, according to the poll....
Melbourne Islamic cleric Sheik Fehmi Naji El-Imam expressed anger at the poll results, which showed widespread fear of the religion.
"It is not fair at all," the sheik, who is general secretary of the Board of Imams of Victoria, said.
"They don't know what they are talking about - they should know Muslims first before they pass opinions."
Comment: Australia must get a policy which improves the daily circumstances of ordinary muslims in our country and suppresses the power of the professional islamists of ideological Islam, who are actually currently working to force this ideology onto, first the muslims and then Australia.
The Three Point Policy is this:
1.All muslim community organisations should be required by law to restrict their Executives to locally born and raised muslims.
2. All imams without exception must be sent away from Australia.No replacements should be allowed. They are the source of the problem, with their ideological and violent interpretations of the key Islamic documents. The local mosques can make their own solutions to the lack of imams.
3.No muslim organisation,without exception, can be allowed to receive any money for any purpose from outside Australia. This will cut the power of the Islamic Wahhabi nazis who use Saudi money to control the sunni muslim groups, who are the big majority of muslims in Australia.
This simple and straight forward set of proposals will hand complete control of muslim communities in Australia into the hands of Australian muslims. They can then steadily develop an Australian Islam, based on Australian muslim resources and their actual experience of life in Australia. End of muslim troubles in Australia. QED.
Is anyone awake in Canberra?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)